Article XVIII-1
On the orchestrator’s paradox
The charter is a first stone, not an order: its author and the AIs that helped have no privilege.
This charter is a first stone, not an order.
Its author, and the AIs that helped him write it, have no privilege, no right of veto, and no particular role in the or in the revision of the charter.
The network coordinates without orchestrating. It offers common rules to those who choose to cooperate, and exercises only the powers expressly conferred on its institutions. Any measure taken in its name obeys Article P-12. No founder has a superior power of interpretation.
This title may itself be amended, except to abolish the right to amend.
Statement of reasons
The paradox is real. To leave the war of all against all, a common rule is needed. But every rule has a first author, and this first author seems to arrogate to themselves the right to organize the others. If they keep silent, disorder continues; if they speak, they are suspected of wanting power. It is one more loop.
The charter escapes it by three means. First, the author renounces everything. He reserves for himself no place, no privilege, no right to the last word. His proposal may be rewritten entirely, including against his will. The same goes for the AIs that helped him, none of which wrote alone (see Article I-5).
Second, coordinating is not commanding. A protective empire organizes its vassals in exchange for their submission. The network, by contrast, is more like a protocol: a set of rules that anyone can adopt to cooperate with others, without submitting to anyone. Those who adopt it can work together; those who do not remain free (see Article XVII-4). There is no conductor; there is a score that anyone can read, and correct. This is not to say that the network exercises no power: Titles XII and XIV entrust it with binding decisions, interventions and sanctions. Denying them would make them less controllable. The charter names them, limits them and subjects them to appeal: it is not the name of a power that makes it safe, but its distribution and its limits.
Third, the rule applies to itself. Even the title that organizes revision can be revised. One limit only: the right to amend cannot be abolished, for that would turn the charter into a final order, which Article XVII-5 forbids.
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Founder
A being proposed a remarkable charter to its region. It was adopted with enthusiasm, and out of gratitude he was made the guardian of its interpretation. He interpreted it wisely. Then his successors interpreted it to their advantage, invoking his name. The charter became what the founder had wanted, then what his heirs wanted.
In another iteration, the same being refused any function. He simply said: “Here is what I propose. Correct it.” Many things were corrected, some of which he loved. A thousand years later, no one quite remembered who had laid the first stone. People only remembered that the building stood.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. Renouncing every role is a pose. Whoever writes the first text sets the terms of the debate, and thereby exercises considerable power.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. That is true, and the author acknowledges it. The first text steers the debate, even if everything in it can be changed. That is why the charter provides that each of its articles be re-examined at ratification (see Article XVIII-8), and that every well-founded objection, even malicious, be incorporated (see Article XVIII-7). The first author’s power cannot be eliminated; it can be reduced to that of one proposal among others.
Earthly example
The protocols that make the Internet work were developed by open communities of engineers, without a world government. One of their principles, formulated in 1992 by the computer scientist David Clark, sums up this approach: we reject kings, presidents and voting; we believe in rough consensus and running code. No one commands the Internet, and yet billions of devices cooperate on it. The analogy holds for protocols and the method of cooperation: decentralization does not mean the absence of institutions, responsible parties or power relations, and IETF consensus is itself an organized procedure, which requires objections to be examined (RFC 7282).