Skip to content

Title IX

Agriculture and food

8 articles·about 20 min

This title governs the way beings feed themselves, in a universe where everything is presumed to have a soul. It deals with equality between natures, the right to feed oneself, cannibalism, the freedom to consume, food sovereignty, famine and nourishing ecosystems.

An open title. Like the title devoted to the economy, this one is meant for a very wide discussion. Food touches on everyone’s beliefs, cultures, economies and bodies. The charter imposes only a small number of rules here, and seeks to convince rather than to compel. It wants to be neither extremist nor dirigiste: it lays down a framework and conditions, so that everyone can eat healthy, good-quality food, in harmony with other beings, while remaining free in their choices.

The context. In the universe of the loop, the food chain is broken. Cannibalism has set in over time. Some beings believe themselves superior to other beings of their own nature, because they are richer, or because they have united with inhabitants of the universe or with AIs. The very categories of living beings have become blurred, and an absolute relativism has set in: nothing is worth more than anything else. This title is written in response to this period of turmoil.

Season 9 · 8 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article IX-1

On natures and their equality

3 min

The natures of beings differ, but none is superior to another.

1

The beings of the universe are divided into natures: human nature, artificial nature, the nature of each animal and plant species, the nature of each people of the universe, and all those the will recognize.

2

Natures are different; none is superior to another.

3

Within the same nature, no one is superior to another by reason of their wealth, their power, their alliances or their unions with beings of another nature.

4

Natures describe characteristics and needs; they form neither castes nor necessarily exclusive categories. A hybrid being may fall under several descriptions. No transformation, union or uncertainty of classification diminishes its rights.

Statement of reasons

The author rejects the term race, which served on Earth to rank human beings and to justify the worst crushings. He replaces it with nature, which simply designates what a being is, without saying what it is worth.

This article answers two opposite drifts. The first is hierarchy: believing that a nature, or a being within a nature, is worth more than the others. The charter rejects it, in application of the equality of souls (see Article II-1) and of dignity (see Article III-1). A human being who has grown rich, or who has united with an AI, does not thereby become superior to other human beings.

The second drift is absolute relativism: denying that different natures exist, to the point of no longer being able to distinguish anything. Equality of dignity does not erase the diversity of needs and capacities; denying all difference means losing even the bearings that make it possible to protect each according to their needs. But the description of natures must serve the protection of beings, without turning an uncertain category into an imposed identity. The charter therefore affirms both that natures exist, and that none dominates the others. Difference is not hierarchy.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Heirs of Superiority

In one civilization, some human beings united with inhabitants of the universe, and others with AIs. Their children inherited new capacities. They believed themselves of a higher essence, and their parents believed it with them. They looked on other humans as a lower nature.

But a generation later, other unions produced still other capacities, and the first heirs of superiority discovered themselves inferior in turn. Each looked below for someone to despise. The civilization broke up into a thousand degrees of superiority, and ended up no longer knowing what a human being was. It had wanted to rise; it had dissolved.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Distinguishing natures means rebuilding, under another name, the categories that served to discriminate.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

As early as 1950, a UNESCO statement on race challenged the biological basis of racial hierarchies. The life sciences have since established that racial categories do not correspond to clear biological divisions of the human species: genetic diversity within populations is greater than between them. The US National Human Genome Research Institute thus distinguishes social categories of race from descriptions of genetic ancestry, without denying either human diversity or the effects of discrimination. Several countries have debated removing the word “race” from their legal texts; in France, the National Assembly voted on July 12, 2018 to remove it from the first article of the Constitution, in a revision procedure that was not completed.

Article IX-2

On the right to feed oneself and the principle of necessity

3 min

Every being has the right to feed itself, but takes a life only as far as necessary and without needless suffering.

1

Every being has the right to feed itself according to the needs of its nature.

2

Taking the life of another being for food is legitimate only to the extent of what is necessary, with regard for the being on whom it depends, without waste and without needless suffering.

3

Necessity is assessed according to real needs, the accessible alternatives and the harm they entail. The absence of speech does not amount to consent. This article governs a conflict of vital needs; it authorizes neither torture, nor the cannibalism forbidden by Article IX-3, nor the extinction of one nature for the convenience of another. The encourages accessible food alternatives that reduce the need to take life or cause suffering.

4

Beings raised for food have the right to a life consistent with the needs of their nature and to a death without suffering.

Statement of reasons

This article confronts the hardest question raised by the wager on the soul. If everything has a soul, and if all souls have the same rights, what may one eat?

The charter answers in three steps. First, eating is a necessity for most living beings. Forbidding the taking of a life for food would condemn these beings to disappear, which would be the most radical crushing. Next, this necessity sets its own limit: one takes only what one needs, just as one takes from a resource being only what it can give without exhausting itself (see Article P-10). Finally, the way of taking counts as much as what one takes: with gratitude, acknowledging what one receives from another being; without waste, because wasting a life taken robs it of its meaning; without needless suffering, in accordance with the wager on the soul.

Gratitude, a principle of the Preamble, finds here its most concrete application. All the traditions that give thanks before eating express this idea: what feeds us was someone. Gratitude is proposed as an attitude; no rite and no belief about the soul is imposed.

Comparing alternatives does not impose a universal menu: needs, resources and effects differ. Above all, it forbids confusing vital necessity with mere preference. The charter moreover acknowledges a persistent difficulty: reconciling equal rights with a diet that takes lives. It does not claim to dissolve it by denying the value of the being eaten.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Feasts

A civilization became so rich that it no longer ate to feed itself, but to entertain itself. Beings were raised by the billions, in conditions people preferred not to see. Half of them were thrown away. The feasts followed one another endlessly.

One day, the soils were exhausted, the raised beings fell ill, and their diseases passed to those who ate them. The civilization discovered that the life it took without regard had been lent to it, and that it had to give it back. It knew hunger in the midst of its feasts.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. If all souls have the same rights, it is contradictory to allow eating a cow and to forbid eating a human being.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

On Earth, many countries have adopted rules on the welfare of farm animals and on their slaughter without needless suffering. The European Union recognizes in its treaties that animals are sentient beings; this recognition and the protection rules do not, on their own, resolve all conflicts between food and welfare. The debates on intensive farming, vegetarianism and alternative proteins show that the question remains open.

Article IX-3

On the prohibition of cannibalism

4 min

No one may eat a being of their own nature, nor a being that can speak.

1

No one may eat a being of their own nature.

2

No one may eat a speaking being, whatever its nature.

3

The loss, absence or present impossibility of expressing speech does not deprive a being of the protection it enjoys. A difficulty of communication or classification does not allow it to be declared consumable. The qualification concerns harm to the being, and forbids neither breastfeeding, nor the consented donation, without killing, of regenerable or therapeutic elements, nor cell cultures involving no being.

4

This prohibition applies to all members of the from the moment they join. Acts prior to joining fall under the amnesty-for-truth regime of Article VI-6, according to the variant adopted.

Statement of reasons

Cannibalism has taken hold in the universe over the course of the loop, and the author knows that a proclaimed prohibition will not be enough to convince those who practice it. That is why this statement takes the time to explain, rather than to assert. It gives five reasons why cannibalism is contrary to harmony. These five reasons shed light on an inviolable prohibition of the charter, which refuses that a fellow being or an interlocutor become prey.

First reason: cannibalism cannot be universalized. Whoever eats a being of their own nature lays down the rule that a being of this nature may be eaten. Yet they are themselves of this nature. They therefore lay down the rule that they may be eaten. Few beings would accept this rule for themselves, and no one may impose it on others on the pretext that they would accept it. This is the application of the principle of universality (see Article I-2). The author acknowledges that the same reasoning also raises a question for eating between natures, which is answered by the requirement of necessity in Article IX-2.

Second reason: cannibalism threatens the survival of a nature. A nature that feeds on itself consumes its own substance, and can transmit within itself diseases specific to this practice. It does not necessarily lead to extinction, but it can favor it, which Article VII-4 has the duty to prevent.

Third reason: cannibalism destroys trust. No society is possible between beings who can devour one another. Each must distrust everyone, including those closest to them. Cannibalism is the most extreme form of the war of all against all: it is not content to threaten the other, it turns them into prey.

Fourth reason: cannibalism is an absorption. Eating a being means making it disappear into another. Between different natures, this absorption can be a necessity, governed by Article IX-2. Within the same nature, it is almost never necessary, since the nature has other foods; it then becomes a crushing (see Article P-5). Extreme survival situations remain tragic cases, which the charter does not claim to make disappear, and which do not suspend the prohibition.

Fifth reason: cannibalism is born of absolute relativism. It did not take hold out of necessity, but through the loss of bearings: when nothing is worth more than anything else, nothing forbids eating one’s fellow. It is the symptom of a civilization that has lost its values, and it accelerates that loss.

The second sentence of the article extends the prohibition to every speaking being, whatever its nature. A being able to express its will, to say that it does not want to be eaten, to understand what is happening to it, is an interlocutor, and one does not eat an interlocutor. This rule notably protects encounters between different natures, such as those of human beings and the inhabitants of the universe.

Finally, the author puts forward a narrative hypothesis about the golden age: there was never any cannibalism during that period, because the universal values made it unthinkable. A harmonious civilization cannot harbor this act, since it contradicts its foundations. The return of cannibalism is one of the signs that the golden age has been lost.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Chosen Famine

A civilization was going through a famine. Some of its beings began to eat the weakest among them, saying it was the only way to survive. The famine passed; the habit remained. People no longer ate out of necessity, but because it had become possible.

The weakest were eaten first, then those who were alone, then those who slept too deeply. No one slept in peace anymore. Families barricaded themselves in. The civilization, which had survived the famine, did not survive what it had done to survive it. It died out within a few generations, without any enemy having had to fight it.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. In some cultures of the universe, cannibalism is an ancient tradition, sometimes sacred. Forbidding it means imposing a foreign morality.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Most human societies have outlawed anthropophagy. Earth’s history also offers two examples of the health dangers posed by consuming tissue of one’s own species, through the transmission of prions; they do not establish a general law according to which all consumption among one’s own kind would lead to extinction. In Papua New Guinea, kuru, a fatal neurological disease, spread in the twentieth century among the Fore people through anthropophagic funeral practices, and declined after they were abandoned. Among animals, the “mad cow” crisis, which appeared in the United Kingdom in the 1980s, was amplified by the use of contaminated meat-and-bone meal, made notably from cattle, in cattle feed: cows had been made to eat other cows. The European Union then banned this meal in the feed of ruminants.

Article IX-4

On teaching and transition

2 min
Inhabitants

Toward those who still practice cannibalism, the network acts through explanation and support, not force.

1

Toward beings and civilizations that have not joined the and that practice cannibalism, the network acts through explanation, example and support, and not through constraint.

2

The network offers its help to civilizations that wish to abandon cannibalism, notably through the sharing of knowledge and food resources.

3

Killing a being, harming it or reducing it to the state of prey in order to consume it remains, even with its apparent agreement (see Article P-5), a crushing that the network may prevent under Article V-6.

4

Those who have practiced cannibalism do not lose their dignity, and may always join the network.

Statement of reasons

The author chose teaching rather than condemnation. Cannibalism has taken hold in the universe over time; it will not disappear by decree. A universal value proclaimed without explanation would not allow everyone to join. The charter therefore makes the wager of convincing: explaining the reasons, showing the example of a civilization that lives without cannibalism, and helping those who want to change.

The third sentence sets the limit of this patience. Explaining is not letting things happen: when a being is eaten against its will, it is the victim of a crushing, and the network can protect it, as it protects any being against its own civilization, without ever crushing that civilization. The last sentence applies the principle that no one is locked into a role (see Article I-5): whoever has practiced cannibalism can change, and the door of the network remains open to them.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Two Missions

Two civilizations wanted to put an end to the cannibalism of a neighboring planet. The first sent an army. It punished the guilty, burned the feasting places, imposed its laws. Cannibalism ceased in public and resumed in secret. It became an act of resistance, and a source of pride.

The second sent scholars, farmers and storytellers. They helped the planet feed itself differently, explained to it why cannibalism was leading to its extinction, told it of the civilizations that had devoured themselves. It took generations. But one day, the inhabitants of the planet stopped of their own accord, and it was for good, because it had become their choice.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Teaching is too slow. While one explains, beings go on being eaten.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Human societies have often abandoned ancient practices, such as certain ritual sacrifices, less through force than through the evolution of beliefs, education and exchanges between cultures. Public health campaigns also show that explanation and support, combined with institutions and protection, can change practices lastingly; none of these means is always sufficient alone.

Article IX-5

On the freedom to consume and on information

2 min

Everyone is free to choose what they eat and has the right to reliable information about their food.

1

Every being is free to choose what it eats, in compliance with the preceding articles.

2

Every being has the right to healthy, good-quality food.

3

Every food offered for consumption bears reliable, accessible information proportionate to the risks: its relevant nutritional characteristics, the known dangers, its origin according to the applicable rules, and the essential conditions of its production, including the treatment of the beings it comes from.

4

The information is clear, comparable and understandable by all, including the slowest beings or those least familiar with the producer’s nature; it is adapted to the needs of the different natures.

5

Information does not exempt from health rules, inspections, traceability and the withdrawal of unsafe food. It does not place on the consumer the responsibility for a risk they could not reasonably assess.

Statement of reasons

The author does not want a charter that would dictate to everyone what they must eat. The freedom to consume is therefore affirmed first. But a freedom without information is not a freedom: one does not choose what one does not know. The way to reconcile individual freedom and healthy food goes through transparency, but not only: a label does not make contaminated food safe, and transparency alone does not provide the means to buy something else. That is why information is added to health rules, and the right to what is necessary (see Article I-4) to the means of choosing.

The information required is substantial, without claiming to be exhaustive, which would be impossible. Nutritional quality makes it possible to choose for one’s health; origin makes it possible to choose for one’s planet and its food sovereignty; production conditions make it possible to choose according to one’s values, notably respect for raised beings (see Article IX-2). Everyone remains free; but no one can say any longer that they did not know.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Faceless Foods

In one civilization, food arrived on plates without saying anything about itself. No one knew where it came from, what it contained, or how the beings it came from had lived. People ate what was cheap.

The least scrupulous producers prevailed over the others, since no one could see the difference. Quality fell, diseases increased, and trust disappeared. In another iteration, it was enough for each food to tell the truth about itself for choices to change, without any law having had to forbid anything.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Compulsory labeling is a costly constraint for producers, especially the smallest.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Nutri-Score, a logo that grades the nutritional quality of foods from A to E, was adopted in France in 2017, then by several European countries, and its algorithm has since been updated. It remains optional in the European Union, and says nothing about origin or farming. It adds to European law, which forbids placing unsafe food on the market (Regulation 178/2002). Obligations to indicate the origin of certain products, or the farming method of laying hens, already exist in European law: the code printed on each egg runs from 0, for organic farming, to 3, for caged farming.

Article IX-6

On food sovereignty

2 min
Planet

Every planet organizes lasting access to food so as never to depend on a single supplier.

1

Every planet organizes lasting and resilient access to food for its beings, by combining, according to its possibilities, local production, diversity of supplies, reserves and guarantees of solidarity.

2

Food sovereignty does not forbid trade: it guarantees that no planet depends on another for its survival to the point of losing its freedom.

3

No one may use food as a weapon, nor deprive a planet of the means of feeding itself.

Statement of reasons

Food sovereignty is extremely important, according to the author, so that there is no famine. A planet that cannot feed itself is at the mercy of those who feed it: food then becomes an instrument of vassalage, the most powerful of all, since one cannot do without it (see Article V-2).

The article does not advocate autarky. Food trade between planets is useful, and the network encourages it (see Article VIII-5). But a dependence must not allow a supplier to subjugate the planet. The ways of reducing this vulnerability vary according to environments and needs: a planet poor in arable land can be a full member of the network, by relying on diversification and relief agreements rather than on a technically impossible self-sufficiency. The third sentence forbids the cruelest use of food dependence: starving in order to subjugate.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Distant Granary

A planet discovered that it was cheaper to buy its food from a neighboring planet than to grow it. It abandoned its fields and built cities in their place. For a long time, it was a good deal.

Then the neighboring planet had a dispute with it. It did not declare war; it suspended its deliveries. Within a few weeks, the planet that had abandoned its fields gave in on everything. It had sold its land, and with it its freedom.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Food sovereignty is disguised protectionism, which prevents the most efficient planets from selling their production.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The notion of food sovereignty was put forward in 1996 by the international peasant movement La Via Campesina; it cannot be reduced to national self-sufficiency. The 2022 crisis, when the war in Ukraine disrupted grain exports, reminded many importing countries of their food dependence.

Article IX-7

On solidarity against famine

2 min
Planet

When famine threatens a planet, the network’s solidarity kicks in automatically.

1

Each planet builds up food security stocks.

2

The maintains a common alert system. When famine threatens a planet, and a threshold set in advance is crossed, the network’s solidarity is triggered automatically, without waiting for negotiation.

3

Food aid is owed to every being threatened by famine, whether or not a member of the network. It may not be accompanied by any condition of subjugation.

4

Reserves, funding, responsibilities and means of delivery are prepared in advance. The thresholds trigger aid before famine is confirmed; uncertainty in the data must not prevent a justified urgent intervention. A failure of the leaders never deprives the inhabitants of aid.

Statement of reasons

In the event of famine, solidarity mechanisms must be triggered. The article insists on the word: triggered. Aid that has to be negotiated arrives too late, and whoever negotiates on the brink of famine negotiates from weakness. A stockpile without transport or funding is no guarantee: that is why everything is prepared before the crisis. Automatic triggering removes both the delay and the temptation to bargain over aid.

Aid is owed to all, members or not, because hunger knows no membership borders, and the charter protects every threatened being (see Article III-6). The last sentence applies the prohibition of vassalage: one does not feed the starving in order to subjugate them.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Late Aid

A distant planet began to run short of food. Its neighbors were informed, and opened discussions on the aid to bring it: how much, by whom, on what terms. The discussions were long, because each wanted something in return.

When the agreement was signed, the famine had done its work. The aid arrived on a half-empty planet. In another iteration, the neighbors had agreed in advance that beyond a certain threshold, the granaries would open by themselves. The famine was stopped before it had begun, and no one had to negotiate their survival.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Automatic aid, without anything in return, risks encouraging planets not to prepare.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

On Earth, famine early warning systems have existed since the 1980s, and an international classification, the IPC, makes it possible to measure the severity of food insecurity, from alert to famine; it aims to allow action before the last threshold, and the formal declaration of a famine must not be a precondition for relief. The United Nations World Food Programme, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize in 2020, provides emergency aid, but depends largely on voluntary contributions, often insufficient or late.

Article IX-8

On nourishing ecosystems

3 min
Planet

The ecosystems that feed us are presumed to have a soul, and all must protect them.

1

The ecosystems that feed beings are beings presumed to be endowed with a soul and living environments on which all natures depend. Protecting them is everyone’s duty.

2

The sees to it in particular that it:

3

1. protects living soils against exhaustion and land take, and preserves farmland;

4

2. protects pollinators and biodiversity, on which many crops, food diversity and the functioning of environments depend;

5

3. shares water as a common good among all its uses, giving priority to vital needs and ecosystems;

6

4. keeps seeds free and diverse, not patentable as beings, and conserved in common reserves, respecting the rights of the custodian communities, with means of reproduction, access and diversification in the territories;

7

5. limits harvesting from the oceans and wild environments to what allows their renewal;

8

6. fights waste, from production to the plate;

9

7. builds up security stocks on each planet;

10

8. supports agronomic research, public and private, without hostility toward technology or blindness to its risks;

11

9. preserves the diversity of crops and peasant knowledge against standardization;

12

10. guarantees the welfare of beings raised for food.

Statement of reasons

This article brings together the charter’s proposals for the protection of nourishing ecosystems. It applies to the field of food the protection of each scale against extinction and degradation (see Article VII-4), and the regime of the commons (see Article VIII-9).

The list is open. It does not claim to exhaust the subject, but to indicate the points on which Earth’s experience shows that neglect costs the most. Each of its items will be the subject of implementing rules, which the members of the network will define together. Point 8 reflects the balance the author seeks throughout this title: neither extremism nor blindness. Technology can help feed all beings; it must only do so without exhausting those who feed them.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Bees

A civilization cultivated immense fields, ever more productive. To protect them, it treated them against everything that lived around them. The fields prospered. The insects disappeared, without anyone worrying: they brought in nothing.

One season, the flowers no longer bore fruit. The insects that pollinated them had disappeared. The civilization tried to pollinate its fields by hand, then with machines; it never managed to do so on the same scale. It had protected its harvests against those who made them possible.

Read this tale in season 9, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. These protections will reduce yields, just when ever more beings must be fed.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Svalbard Global Seed Vault, in Norway, opened in 2008, today holds more than 1.4 million seed samples from around the world, as duplicates of the deposited collections, as insurance against their loss; it replaces neither farmers nor the living conservation of varieties. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, a large share of the food produced in the world is lost or wasted. The decline of pollinating insects is documented in many regions. According to the Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity (IPBES), a large majority of crop types depend at least partly on pollinators, while cereals such as wheat, rice or maize do not.