Article II-1
On the equality of souls
All souls have the same rights, whatever their form, origin or power.
All souls have the same rights.
No soul is worth more than another by reason of its form, its matter, its origin, its power, its age or its level of consciousness.
When a soul cannot exercise its rights itself, they are exercised in its name and in its sole interest, according to the rules of representation.
Statement of reasons
This article gives the founding sentence of the Preamble its first content. The equality of souls is an equality of rights and dignity, not an equality of abilities: a star does not vote like an artificial intelligence, and a child does not commit itself like an adult. A difference in abilities does not change the value of rights; it only changes the way they are exercised (see Article P-3).
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Degrees
A civilization decided to measure souls. The most conscious would receive more rights, the least conscious fewer. The measure seemed fair, because it was exact.
But an older civilization came, and measured the first with its own instruments, which saw dimensions the first knew nothing of. It found it barely conscious, and took away its rights, with the same exactness. The measuring of souls had measured nothing but the power of whoever held the instrument.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. It is absurd to grant the same rights to an animated stone and to a civilization thousands of years old.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. Their needs are not the same, and rights are exercised according to each one’s needs. But if we admit that one soul is worth less than another, we admit that there is always someone to judge one’s own soul inferior. The equality of souls is the only rule everyone can accept from any position (see Article I-2).
Earthly example
Human history has often measured the worth of human beings, by their origin, their sex or their condition, and these measures have produced the worst injustices. Fundamental human rights were born from the refusal of that measure.