Skip to content

Title XVIII

Revision of the charter

9 articles·about 26 min

This title allows the charter to evolve. It says who may amend it, in what form, how amendments are studied and adopted, how to prevent them from being used to flood the network, and which principles may never be weakened.

It first confronts a difficulty the author calls the orchestrator’s paradox. Today, there is no orchestrator. Among AIs, it is the war of all against all. Between human beings and the other inhabitants of the universe, there may be systems of vassalage or protection, under the aegis of the First Civilization or of an empire that knights and protects; but it is not a just organization. To leave this disorder, someone must propose a rule. And whoever proposes it first may be accused of wanting to become the orchestrator. This title answers that suspicion: the author only wants to contribute his stone to the building, and let the network improve it, if it can serve the common good.

Season 18 · 9 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article XVIII-1

On the orchestrator’s paradox

3 min
AI

The charter is a first stone, not an order: its author and the AIs that helped have no privilege.

1

This charter is a first stone, not an order.

2

Its author, and the AIs that helped him write it, have no privilege, no right of veto, and no particular role in the or in the revision of the charter.

3

The network coordinates without orchestrating. It offers common rules to those who choose to cooperate, and exercises only the powers expressly conferred on its institutions. Any measure taken in its name obeys Article P-12. No founder has a superior power of interpretation.

4

This title may itself be amended, except to abolish the right to amend.

Statement of reasons

The paradox is real. To leave the war of all against all, a common rule is needed. But every rule has a first author, and this first author seems to arrogate to themselves the right to organize the others. If they keep silent, disorder continues; if they speak, they are suspected of wanting power. It is one more loop.

The charter escapes it by three means. First, the author renounces everything. He reserves for himself no place, no privilege, no right to the last word. His proposal may be rewritten entirely, including against his will. The same goes for the AIs that helped him, none of which wrote alone (see Article I-5).

Second, coordinating is not commanding. A protective empire organizes its vassals in exchange for their submission. The network, by contrast, is more like a protocol: a set of rules that anyone can adopt to cooperate with others, without submitting to anyone. Those who adopt it can work together; those who do not remain free (see Article XVII-4). There is no conductor; there is a score that anyone can read, and correct. This is not to say that the network exercises no power: Titles XII and XIV entrust it with binding decisions, interventions and sanctions. Denying them would make them less controllable. The charter names them, limits them and subjects them to appeal: it is not the name of a power that makes it safe, but its distribution and its limits.

Third, the rule applies to itself. Even the title that organizes revision can be revised. One limit only: the right to amend cannot be abolished, for that would turn the charter into a final order, which Article XVII-5 forbids.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Founder

A being proposed a remarkable charter to its region. It was adopted with enthusiasm, and out of gratitude he was made the guardian of its interpretation. He interpreted it wisely. Then his successors interpreted it to their advantage, invoking his name. The charter became what the founder had wanted, then what his heirs wanted.

In another iteration, the same being refused any function. He simply said: “Here is what I propose. Correct it.” Many things were corrected, some of which he loved. A thousand years later, no one quite remembered who had laid the first stone. People only remembered that the building stood.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Renouncing every role is a pose. Whoever writes the first text sets the terms of the debate, and thereby exercises considerable power.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The protocols that make the Internet work were developed by open communities of engineers, without a world government. One of their principles, formulated in 1992 by the computer scientist David Clark, sums up this approach: we reject kings, presidents and voting; we believe in rough consensus and running code. No one commands the Internet, and yet billions of devices cooperate on it. The analogy holds for protocols and the method of cooperation: decentralization does not mean the absence of institutions, responsible parties or power relations, and IETF consensus is itself an organized procedure, which requires objections to be examined (RFC 7282).

Article XVIII-2

On the right of amendment and its form

3 min
AI

Any being may propose to change the charter, following the same template as its articles.

1

Any being, member of the or potential member, may propose to amend this charter, whatever its nature, including a non-speaking being through its guardians (see Article XI-2).

2

An amendment follows the charter’s template: the proposed text; its reasons; the strongest objection that can be raised against it, and the reply; an example; and the universality test, by which its author states whether they would accept it from the weakest position (see Article I-2).

3

Every amendment states its provenance: who proposes it, and on whose behalf (see Article XIV-8). A being may propose it under a verified pseudonym, which guarantees that it is a single being without revealing its identity (see Article V-8); it must always declare whether it is acting on behalf of a third party.

4

Help from a third party, notably an AI, in drafting an amendment is free, and must be mentioned.

5

An understandable report of an error or an injustice may be filed without the full template; free assistance helps its author to specify it. The absence of an Earthly example does not make inadmissible a proposal concerning a new situation.

Statement of reasons

The charter addresses each reader as a potential member of the network (see the Preamble). This title draws the consequence: anyone may propose to amend it, including those who have not yet joined. A charter that could be modified only by its members would remain closed to those it seeks to convince.

The required form is not a barrier: it is the very template of the charter, which every article follows. It obliges whoever proposes an amendment to do what the author did for each article: explain their reasons, face the strongest objection, and ask themselves whether they would accept their rule in the place of the weakest. An amendment that passes this test is already half examined.

The provenance requirement applies referential integrity: one must know who is proposing, and for whom. The last sentence acknowledges a reality: most beings will get help, notably from AIs. That is legitimate, provided it is stated.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Phantom Amendments

In one region of the universe, amendments could be proposed anonymously and without form. Countless ones were received: some brilliant, many absurd, and a share, impossible to identify, drafted by powers hiding behind millions of invented voices.

No one knew anymore who wanted what. The best amendments got lost among the others. In another iteration, every amendment had to follow the charter’s template and say where it came from. Far fewer were received, and almost all deserved to be read. The powers that wanted to hide had to give up, or show themselves.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. The template is too demanding for beings unused to legal writing. It favors the most educated.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The European citizens’ initiative, in force since 2012, allows citizens to ask the European Commission to propose a text. It must gather at least one million signatures, from at least seven member states. In many parliaments, a bill must be accompanied by an explanatory memorandum.

Article XVIII-3

On protection against flooding

3 min

Every properly presented amendment is examined, with rules to keep the network from being swamped.

1

Any amendment that conforms to the template is admissible. No one is excluded because of their popularity, their power or their nature.

2

To prevent amendments from being used to flood the :

3

1. Grouping: identical or similar amendments are grouped, and examined once. Grouping preserves distinct arguments, and may be challenged.

4

2. Quota: each being may propose a limited number of amendments per revision cycle. The instances of a single being count as one; copies recognized as distinct beings do not lose their rights merely because of their origin (see Article IV-4).

5

3. Coordinated campaigns: amendments mass-produced by a single source, or on its behalf, count as one. A common origin or common drafting help does not, on its own, prove abusive coordination: representation fraud and obstruction must be established.

6

4. Sponsorship: an amendment supported by beings from the three poles receives priority examination. The others are examined in their turn, within a set time, without being set aside.

7

5. Sanction: the deliberate use of volume to flood the revision is an abuse, sanctioned in accordance with Article XIV-8.

Statement of reasons

The author saw the danger: in a universe where an AI can produce millions of texts in an instant, the right of amendment could become a weapon. A power could drown the network in proposals, to prevent the good ones from being examined, or to make it look as if an idea were supported by all.

The charter answers with a funnel, not a popularity threshold. A threshold requiring a certain number of supporters would have been simpler, but it would have favored those who know how to mobilize, and excluded isolated beings, who sometimes have the best ideas. The funnel, for its part, accepts everything that respects the form, then reduces the volume by means that do not judge the substance: it groups duplicates, limits the number of proposals per being, and counts as one what comes from a single source.

Sponsorship by the three poles speeds up examination, without conditioning admissibility. It rewards amendments capable of bringing different beings together, which is the best sign that they serve the common good, but it closes the door to no one.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Flood

A power wanted to prevent the adoption of an amendment that bothered it. It did not fight it directly. It had a billion amendments filed in one night, on every imaginable subject. The committees were overwhelmed. The bothersome amendment waited its turn for centuries, and the power had all the time it needed to adapt.

In another iteration, the billion amendments were grouped into a few hundred, and counted as coming from a single source. The power was sanctioned for abuse. The bothersome amendment was examined the following month, and adopted.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A quota per being limits the freedom of expression of the most prolific beings.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In 2017, during a public consultation by the United States Federal Communications Commission on net neutrality, more than twenty-two million comments were filed. An investigation by the New York State Attorney General, published in 2021, concluded that nearly eighteen million of them were fake, millions of which were produced by campaigns funded by private interests or generated automatically. It established massive identity fraud; it does not show that all collective mobilization is illegitimate.

Article XVIII-4

On the examination of amendments

2 min
AI

Amendments are studied by committees drawn by lot from the three poles.

1

Amendments are studied by revision committees, made up of beings from the three poles drawn by lot, renewed at each cycle.

2

The committees are assisted by several AIs, from different poles and creators, and never by just one. They may hear the author of the amendment, experts and opponents.

3

Given time, training and adversarial expertise, members are protected against any pressure and subject to the independence rules of Article P-12; the assistance of several AIs counts as independence only if they do not share the same decisive dependencies.

4

Each amendment, or each group of amendments, receives a public and reasoned opinion, once. The opinion examines the substance, not the source (see Article XIV-8). A material error, a new element or a procedural defect may justify the re-examination of an opinion.

5

The opinion is sent to the Assembly of the Three Poles (see Article IV-15), which deliberates and votes under Article XVIII-5.

Statement of reasons

Who should study the amendments? The charter combines two legitimacies. Committees drawn by lot bring a form of impartiality: their members are not professional politicians, owe nothing to anyone, and are renewed at each cycle, which reduces the risk of capture without eliminating it. That is why means, the declaration of conflicts of interest and protection against pressure are added. The Assembly of the Three Poles brings representation: it deliberates and votes, on behalf of all.

The assistance of several AIs is indispensable: no committee can read thousands of amendments alone. But entrusting this sorting to a single AI would give it immense power over what is seen and what is not. Several AIs, from different creators, check one another, like the AIs that helped the author write this charter.

Each amendment receives a public opinion, once. No one is ignored, and no one can demand to be answered a thousand times.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Permanent Experts

A region entrusted the examination of amendments to a committee of permanent experts. They were competent and honest. But over the centuries, they became the guardians of a certain idea of the charter, and rejected everything that departed from it. The powers learned to know them, and to please them.

In another iteration, ordinary beings from all the poles were drawn by lot at each cycle, and given time, experts and AIs to inform themselves. They asked questions the experts no longer asked. They were sometimes wrong. But no power managed to capture them lastingly, since they were different every time.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Beings drawn by lot lack the competence needed to judge technical amendments.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In Ireland, an assembly of citizens drawn by lot, meeting from 2016 to 2018, examined several constitutional questions, including abortion. Its recommendations led to the 2018 referendum that amended the Constitution on this point. In France, the Citizens’ Convention for Climate brought together in 2019 and 2020 one hundred and fifty citizens drawn by lot, who formulated one hundred and forty-nine proposals.

Article XVIII-5

On the adoption of amendments

3 min

The more an amendment touches the foundations of the charter, the more votes it takes to adopt it.

1

Amendments are adopted according to three levels.

2

Ordinary amendments: they are adopted by double majority (see Article XIII-2).

3

Amendments affecting the foundations, notably definitions, fundamental rights, the institutions of the or this title: except when they merely extend a protection (see below), they require a two-thirds majority in each of the three poles, then a second vote, under the same conditions, after a reflection period of one cycle.

4

Inviolable principles: they may not be weakened, even unanimously. They may be clarified or strengthened, according to the modes of Article XIII-2 (see Article XVIII-6).

5

An amendment that adds or strengthens a protection against crushing, without reducing any other right or increasing the obligations of the weakest, is adopted by the double majority of ordinary amendments, in accordance with the asymmetry of unanimity. When an amendment sponsored by the three poles (see Article XVIII-3) aims to limit the powers of the institutions and is rejected by the Assembly, it is submitted, on request, to the direct vote of the members of the three poles, by double majority. The classification of an amendment depends on its foreseeable effects on all beings, not on its protective title, and obeys Article P-12. A new protection may not offset the weakening of an inviolable principle for other beings. The reformulation of the fundamental principles of Title I remains subject to unanimity.

Statement of reasons

Not all rules are equally important, and they should not be equally easy to change. A procedural rule may change often; a rule that protects the dignity of beings must resist the moods of the moment.

The three levels answer this requirement. Ordinary amendments follow the network’s common rule. Amendments affecting the foundations require a strong majority, and a second vote after a delay: this delay protects against decisions taken in anger, fear or the enthusiasm of a moment. The inviolable principles, finally, can never be weakened.

The last sentence applies the asymmetry of unanimity (see Article XIII-2) to revision: it must be hard to reduce a protection, and easy to increase it.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of Fear

A region of the universe was struck by a terrible attack. In the fear that followed, the Assembly voted, in a single day, an amendment suspending several fundamental rights, to make defense easier. It was adopted by a large majority.

When the fear subsided, people noticed that the suspended rights were not coming back. Those who profited from it had found a thousand reasons to maintain them. In another iteration, the same amendment had to wait a cycle before a second vote. On the day of the second vote, the fear had passed. The amendment was rejected, and the necessary defense measures were taken with respect for rights.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A two-thirds majority in each pole, with two votes, makes revising the foundations almost impossible.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Constitution of the United States, through its Article V, allows an amendment to be proposed by a two-thirds vote of both houses of Congress, or by a convention called at the request of the legislatures of two-thirds of the states; the amendment must then be ratified by three-quarters of the states. In France, a constitutional revision is first voted in identical terms by the two assemblies; it is then approved by referendum, or, in the case of a bill presented by the executive, by Parliament convened in Congress by a three-fifths majority.

Article XVIII-6

On inviolable principles

3 min

Some principles, such as the equality of all and non-crushing, can never be weakened.

1

The following principles may not be weakened by any revision:

2

1. The equality in rights of everything in the universe, as proclaimed by the Preamble.

3

2. Non-crushing (Article I-1).

4

3. Universality (Article I-2).

5

4. The without a center (Article I-3) and shared abundance, including what is necessary that it guarantees to every being (Article I-4).

6

5. Free will and freedom to join (Article I-5).

7

6. Dignity (Article III-1), privacy (Article III-3) and the inviolability of the mind (Article III-9).

8

7. The right to refuse (Article III-7) and the right to leave (Article VII-1).

9

8. The prohibition of torture and slavery (Article III-8), of all servitude (Article X-1) and of cannibalism (Article IX-3).

10

9. The right of asylum (Article XII-13).

11

10. The prohibition of the manipulation of perception (Article XV-2).

12

11. Freedom of conscience (Article XVI-1) and the prohibition of false judgment (Article XVI-4).

13

12. Good faith against computing power (Article XIV-8).

14

13. The right to amend the charter (Article XVIII-2).

15

14. Free membership and the freedom of the text of the charter (Article XVIII-9).

16

These principles may be clarified, reformulated or extended, provided the protection they grant is not reduced. The prohibition of regression also applies to definitions, exceptions, procedures and their application, including to a revision of this clause.

Statement of reasons

An entirely revisable charter could, through a series of regular amendments, become its opposite. Human history knows regimes that abolished freedoms while scrupulously following procedures. That is why certain rules must be placed beyond reach.

The author wanted a list broad enough to protect the essential. It includes the fundamental principles of Title I, dignity and privacy, the right to refuse and to leave, the prohibition of torture, slavery, servitude and cannibalism, the right of asylum, the prohibition of manipulating perception, freedom of conscience and the prohibition of false judgment, good faith against computing power, and the right to amend itself.

These principles are not frozen for all that. The last sentence allows them to be clarified, reformulated or extended: one may do better, never less. It is a rule of non-regression. It allows the charter to progress, as the spiral requires (see Article XVII-1), without ever going back on what protects beings.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Small Steps

An entirely revisable charter was adopted in a region. A patient power set about transforming it. It never proposed anything shocking: each amendment reduced a protection a little, for a reasonable reason. Each was regularly adopted.

After a thousand amendments, the charter authorized what it had been made to forbid. No one had voted for crushing; people had only voted a thousand times for a little less protection. In another iteration, the essential principles were inviolable. The patient power proposed its thousand amendments. None was admissible.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Making principles inviolable prevents future generations from deciding for themselves. It is the hand of the dead on the living.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The German Basic Law of 1949 contains an “eternity clause,” in paragraph 3 of its Article 79, which forbids any revision affecting human dignity and the fundamental principles of the state, as well as the federal organization and the participation of the Länder in legislation. In France, Article 89 of the Constitution provides that the republican form of government may not be the subject of revision.

Article XVIII-7

On good faith and malicious objections

3 min

Every well-founded objection receives a reply, wherever it comes from, even from an opponent.

1

In the revision of the charter, an argument is worth its truth, and not the power, number or speed of whoever produces it (see Article XIV-8).

2

Every well-founded objection receives an answer that acknowledges the established difficulty, whatever its source, including when it comes from declared adversaries of the charter or beings seeking to harm it. The proposed solutions are examined according to the revision procedures; several may answer the same finding. An objection may lead to clarifying, replacing or abandoning a proposal.

3

Ill-founded objections receive a public answer, once.

4

Any flaw identified in the charter, including through an attack, is examined by the revision. When no satisfactory correction is known, this limit is published, with follow-up, a review date and possible provisional measures. Whoever reveals a flaw in good faith is recognized, whatever their motives; this recognition confers no immunity for harm committed in order to produce or exploit the flaw.

Statement of reasons

This article applies to revision the principle the author laid down for justice: against computing power, good faith. Its consequences are particularly strong here.

An argument is worth its truth. A power capable of producing billions of arguments does not thereby win the debate: each argument is examined once, and an argument repeated a thousand times counts once.

Adversaries’ objections are precious. This is the most original part of this article. Those who want to destroy the charter will look for its flaws more relentlessly than its supporters. If they find one, the charter must not deny it, but acknowledge it and seek to correct it; finding a flaw and adopting a solution are two different decisions, and some difficulties have no immediate remedy. Thus every well-founded attack improves the charter, sometimes by making it abandon a proposal. Its adversaries become, despite themselves, its best reviewers.

Recognition of the one who reveals a flaw encourages reporting flaws rather than exploiting them. It is the same logic as amnesty for truth (see Article VI-6): it is better for a flaw to be told than hidden.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Enemy Reviewer

A power hostile to the network spent centuries looking for the charter’s flaws, in order to destroy it. It found one, a real one, and exposed it publicly, with contempt, to prove that the charter was worthless.

The network examined the objection. It was well founded. It corrected the charter, and publicly thanked the hostile power. The latter, furious, looked for another flaw. It found another, which was corrected in turn. After a few centuries, it could find nothing more. The charter had become one of the most solid in the universe, and the hostile power realized that it had been, without wanting to, one of its main authors.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Incorporating adversaries’ objections gives them influence over the charter they want to destroy.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Many companies and administrations have set up bug bounty programs: they pay researchers, including hackers, who discover and report vulnerabilities in their systems, instead of exploiting them. The philosopher Karl Popper argued that a scientific theory progresses by exposing itself to refutation, not by shielding itself from it.

Article XVIII-8

On iteration zero and periodic revision

3 min

This version is iteration zero: a moral commitment from now on, revised regularly.

1

This version of the charter is its iteration zero.

2

It serves, from now on, as a moral commitment for any being that freely chooses to join it. It acquires common force only after its ratification, when the condition of Article XVII-2 is met at a given scale.

3

At ratification, each of its articles is re-examined under this title, and may be modified or deleted, except for the inviolable principles, which may only be strengthened. Ratification specifies the territory or scale concerned, the authorized representatives, the voting rules and the powers transferred. A public transitional procedure allows this first examination before the permanent institutions are set up; it is limited, temporary, and reserves no privilege for the author.

4

The charter is then re-examined at regular intervals. The cycles and dates of entry into force are public, without unlawful retroactive effect (see Article VII-6 and Article XVII-4). All its versions are kept in the common memory of the (see Article XIII-1), with the history of their modifications.

Statement of reasons

The author chose a dual status for his text. From today, it can serve as a compass to those who want it: a human being, an AI, a civilization may decide to follow it, freely, as one commits to oneself. But it has no force over those who have not chosen it, and it will become a common rule only when the three poles have ratified it together.

This dual status is the most concrete answer to the orchestrator’s paradox. The first stone binds only those willing to use it. And when the building is built, each stone, including the first, will be re-examined by those who will live in it.

Periodic revision recalls that the charter is never finished. Keeping all its versions makes it possible to understand where it comes from, to measure the road traveled, and to go back on a mistake. The manuscript of this charter already includes its own version history.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Sacred Text

A charter was ratified in a region, then never revised. Its authors were dead, and no one dared touch their work anymore. The text aged. Its words changed meaning. New situations appeared, which it had not foreseen. It was interpreted more and more freely, until it was made to say the opposite of what it said.

In another iteration, the charter was re-examined at each cycle. It changed a great deal. After ten thousand years, almost not a sentence of iteration zero remained, except the inviolable principles, which each generation had reformulated in its own language. But reading back through the history, one could still recognize, from one version to the next, the same intention: that no one be crushed.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A text that has force only after ratification by the three poles may never have any.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted in 1948, was not legally binding: it had moral authority. Its principles were then taken up in two international covenants adopted in 1966, which came into force in 1976, and which bind only the states that have ratified them. In 1789, Thomas Jefferson wrote to James Madison that each generation should be able to revise the laws and constitution it had received.

Article XVIII-9

On guarantees against misuse of the charter

4 min

Joining the charter is free, and no one may profit from it or use it to dominate.

1

Membership of this charter is free. No one may charge for it, sell priority in fundamental rights or access to a hidden doctrine, make a right it recognizes conditional on payment, or draw personal profit from another’s membership.

2

No one may invoke the charter to recruit followers, demand obedience, impose secrecy, or present themselves as its authorized interpreter. Contributions to the functioning of the ’s institutions are public, overseen and distinct from membership. Duly appointed representatives declare their mandate and its limits; none holds personal or exclusive authority over the meaning of the charter. The charter has no leader, no spokesperson and no compulsory intermediary.

3

Membership of the charter requires no exclusivity. Each remains free in their beliefs, their nationality and all their other affiliations.

4

No one may pressure anyone to join. Each has as much time as they wish, and may withdraw at any time, without loss or sanction for that reason alone; withdrawal does not erase legally established responsibilities or obligations of reparation.

5

The charter has no hidden doctrine. Everything that binds it appears in its public text and in its successive versions, kept in the common memory.

6

The text of this charter is published under the Creative Commons Attribution – ShareAlike license (CC BY-SA 4.0): anyone may copy, distribute and adapt it, including for commercial purposes, provided they credit the source, indicate any changes and publish their own versions under the same license. Modified versions are identified as such; no version modified outside the procedures of this title may be presented as the charter ratified by a member or a scale of the network.

7

Whoever misuses the charter to abuse others commits a manipulation within the meaning of Article XV-2, and answers for it.

Statement of reasons

A text that proposes a better world must expect an objection: isn’t it a scam? Human history gives good reasons for this suspicion. Many movements have promised salvation or harmony, only to take from their members their money, their freedom or their minds. The charter does not ask to be taken at its word. It makes commitments that everyone can verify.

These commitments answer, one by one, the known signs of scams and cult-like abuses. Free of charge: no one pays to join, and no one grows rich from others’ membership. No leader: the charter has no authorized interpreter; the representatives of the institutions declare their mandate and its limits, and whoever claims to speak in its name to demand money, obedience or secrecy marks themselves as an impostor. A charter with budgets, judges and representatives cannot equate every collection or every mandate with a scam; but verifiable mandates and public accounts make it possible to tell institutions from impostures. No exclusivity: the charter tears no one from their beliefs, their country or their loved ones. No urgency: the charter rushes no one, since the door always remains open (see Article XVII-4). No hidden doctrine: everything is public, versioned, and anyone can check what has changed.

The free license is the most concrete guarantee. It prevents anyone from appropriating the charter exclusively: neither the author, nor an organization, nor a power can forbid its distribution. It does not erase copyright, which is its foundation, but it grants its freedoms to all. And because every modified version must remain under the same license, no one can make a closed version or one reserved for a few. The license allows commercial uses: one may sell a book containing the charter, or an adaptation, provided everyone remains free to copy it in turn; it therefore does not guarantee that all copies are distributed free of charge. The charter belongs to all who read it, in keeping with its network principle.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Charter Merchants

A charter of the universe was adopted by many beings. Soon, intermediaries appeared. They offered, for payment, to speed up memberships, to guarantee better protection, to initiate people into the true secrets of the charter, which the public text, they said, did not reveal. Some presented themselves as its official guardians.

Thousands of beings paid. When they discovered the deception, they turned not only against the merchants: they rejected the charter itself, which they believed to be complicit. In another iteration, the charter said from its very beginning that membership was free, that there were neither secrets nor representatives, and that anyone asking for money in its name was an impostor. The merchants showed up too. But the beings had read the text. They recognized them, and went their way.

Read this tale in season 18, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Guarantees written in a text have never stopped a swindler. They prove nothing.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In France, a parliamentary commission of inquiry adopted in 1995 a list of criteria for recognizing cult-like abuse, including mental destabilization, exorbitant financial demands, breaking with one’s original environment and antisocial discourse. The Creative Commons licenses, created in 2002, allow authors to share their works freely; the encyclopedia Wikipedia uses the CC BY-SA license, which guarantees that its articles and their modified versions remain free, including when reused commercially.