Article XVII-1
On the spiral
Leaving the loop is a progression: if each iteration does a little better, the loop becomes a spiral.
Leaving the is not an event, but a progression.
Each iteration of the universe can be a little better than the previous one: less crushing, more , more harmony. When iterations improve in this way one after another, the loop becomes a spiral. The spiral designates a sought-after improvement, which may suffer setbacks.
No change, rapid or slow, may suspend the fundamental prohibitions.
This charter is itself iterative. It corrects itself through experience, objections and revision (see Title XVIII).
Statement of reasons
The loop is a structure in which the same conflicts return endlessly (see Article P-8). One could imagine leaving it through a door: one day, one act, one decision, and everything would be different. The charter rejects this image. A sudden and imposed exit would most often require a power able to transform the universe at a stroke, that is, precisely the center the charter fights. A rapid transformation does not always require a single power; but none, rapid or slow, may suspend the fundamental prohibitions.
It prefers the image of the spiral. A spiral turns like a loop: the same questions return, the same temptations, the same conflicts. But with each turn, it rises a little. The same problems come back, but they are faced better. That is how beings progress, and that is how the charter hopes the universe will progress. It is enough that the sum of the steps leans a little in the right direction, even with setbacks, while remaining honest, sincere and useful, even when one is wrong (see the method set out in the Preamble).
The spiral does not lead back to the golden age. It does not go backward: it rises toward something that has never existed, and that each iteration invents a little.
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Great Night
A power announced that it would break the loop in a single night. It had prepared a perfect plan: at dawn, all civilizations would be reconciled, all plunderers reintegrated, all injustices repaired. All that was needed was to give it, for one night, all powers.
They were given to it. At dawn, nothing had changed, except one thing: it now had all powers, and did not give them back. It explained that it needed one more night, then another. The loop turned again, tighter than ever. In another iteration, no one promised a great night. Each planet took a step, then another. A thousand years later, people noticed that the loop had loosened, without anyone being able to say at what moment.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. Slow progress lets present injustices last. The beings who suffer today do not have time to wait for the spiral.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. The slowness of the spiral does not concern the protection of beings. Fundamental rights apply immediately, and the network protects those who are threatened starting today (see Title XII). What is gradual is the transformation of the structure. And history shows that transformations imposed at a stroke often produce more suffering than those they claimed to abolish.
Earthly example
On May 9, 1950, Robert Schuman proposed pooling the coal and steel of France and Germany, declaring: “Europe will not be made all at once, or according to a single plan. It will be built through concrete achievements which first create a de facto solidarity.” Countries that had gone to war three times in less than a century thus built, step by step, a lasting peace between them.