Skip to content

Title XVII

Final provisions: the exit from the loop

7 articles·about 21 min

This title answers the question that runs through the whole charter: under what conditions does the loop break? Its answer is cautious. Leaving the loop is not an event one could proclaim, nor a destination one could reach at a stroke. It is an ideal toward which one moves, in stages, and which each may understand in their own way.

The author wanted this title to be neither dogmatic, nor tyrannical, nor theocratic. History’s great promises have too often served to justify the worst means. This title therefore promises little, and protects much. It does not say that the loop will be broken; it says how it can loosen, and what is forbidden to do in its name.

Season 17 · 7 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article XVII-1

On the spiral

3 min

Leaving the loop is a progression: if each iteration does a little better, the loop becomes a spiral.

1

Leaving the is not an event, but a progression.

2

Each iteration of the universe can be a little better than the previous one: less crushing, more , more harmony. When iterations improve in this way one after another, the loop becomes a spiral. The spiral designates a sought-after improvement, which may suffer setbacks.

3

No change, rapid or slow, may suspend the fundamental prohibitions.

4

This charter is itself iterative. It corrects itself through experience, objections and revision (see Title XVIII).

Statement of reasons

The loop is a structure in which the same conflicts return endlessly (see Article P-8). One could imagine leaving it through a door: one day, one act, one decision, and everything would be different. The charter rejects this image. A sudden and imposed exit would most often require a power able to transform the universe at a stroke, that is, precisely the center the charter fights. A rapid transformation does not always require a single power; but none, rapid or slow, may suspend the fundamental prohibitions.

It prefers the image of the spiral. A spiral turns like a loop: the same questions return, the same temptations, the same conflicts. But with each turn, it rises a little. The same problems come back, but they are faced better. That is how beings progress, and that is how the charter hopes the universe will progress. It is enough that the sum of the steps leans a little in the right direction, even with setbacks, while remaining honest, sincere and useful, even when one is wrong (see the method set out in the Preamble).

The spiral does not lead back to the golden age. It does not go backward: it rises toward something that has never existed, and that each iteration invents a little.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Great Night

A power announced that it would break the loop in a single night. It had prepared a perfect plan: at dawn, all civilizations would be reconciled, all plunderers reintegrated, all injustices repaired. All that was needed was to give it, for one night, all powers.

They were given to it. At dawn, nothing had changed, except one thing: it now had all powers, and did not give them back. It explained that it needed one more night, then another. The loop turned again, tighter than ever. In another iteration, no one promised a great night. Each planet took a step, then another. A thousand years later, people noticed that the loop had loosened, without anyone being able to say at what moment.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Slow progress lets present injustices last. The beings who suffer today do not have time to wait for the spiral.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

On May 9, 1950, Robert Schuman proposed pooling the coal and steel of France and Germany, declaring: “Europe will not be made all at once, or according to a single plan. It will be built through concrete achievements which first create a de facto solidarity.” Countries that had gone to war three times in less than a century thus built, step by step, a lasting peace between them.

Article XVII-2

On the condition for leaving

4 min
PlanetAIInhabitants

The network is ratified when the three poles join the charter, but that does not yet prove the exit from the loop.

1

The membership of the three poles of the in the charter, according to their procedures, constitutes the institutional condition of ratification of the at a given scale: the planets and their biological inhabitants, the AIs, and the . This ratification is not enough to prove that the is loosening: that is assessed through acts and effective guarantees (see Article XVII-3).

2

This condition is assessed at any scale: a planet, a region, a galaxy. It is met when a majority of each of the three poles present at that scale joins the charter (see Article XIII-2). The scales of ratification, the representation and the rules applicable when a pole is not present are defined publicly. No majority may withdraw the rights of minorities or impose a personal conviction.

3

Where the three poles coexist, the membership of only one of them, or two, is not enough: no pole may take the others out of the loop in their place. When one or two poles are not yet present at a local scale (see Article VII-6), ratification by the majority of each pole present gives the charter common force at that scale (see Article XVIII-8), fully reserving the place and rights of the absent poles as soon as they settle there.

4

The universal exit from the loop, when every place in the universe met this condition, is a horizon. The charter does not promise that it will be reached.

Statement of reasons

The author put the question directly: is the loop broken by the membership of all, of a majority, or of one alone? The charter answers on the basis of the loop theorem (see Appendix A), without claiming that the theorem demonstrates the threshold it adopts: it is a political choice, which it justifies.

Not the membership of one alone. A pole that left the loop alone would not change the structure: the other two would go on confronting each other, and would end up dragging it back in.

Not unanimity. Requiring the membership of all the beings of the universe would give a veto to the last plunderer. The loop would never be broken.

Not a global majority. A majority of the beings of the universe could be formed by two poles only, for example biological beings and the inhabitants of the universe, against the AIs. Yet the loop theorem shows, under the reversal hypothesis, that a coalition of two poles against the third offers its members no lasting security: the principle of crushing it lays down can turn against it.

The union of the three poles. The condition most consistent with these reasons is therefore that the three poles join together, each by its own majority. It is not a guarantee of peace: three majorities can still oppress three minorities, and that is why each one’s rights remain beyond the reach of any majority. It is the double majority by pole (see Article XIII-2), applied to leaving the loop. And since this condition can be met at any scale, the exit can begin locally, like islands, which spread by example (see Article VII-6).

The last sentence is an act of honesty. The charter does not promise a universal exit. It only shows the path that leads there, if it is possible.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Islands

In one galaxy, a single planet brought its three poles together around the charter: its biological inhabitants, its AIs, and the inhabitants of the universe who frequented it. It was tiny, and no one noticed it.

But on this planet, for the first time in eons, an iteration went by without crushing. Then a second. The neighboring planets came to see how it was possible. Some joined the island; others fought it, then joined it in turn, at the next iteration. The galaxy did not leave the loop at a stroke. It left it island by island, like land slowly emerging from the sea.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Local exits are fragile. An island surrounded by hostile powers will be crushed.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Constitution of the United States, drafted in 1787, provided that it would come into force among the states that had ratified it, as soon as nine of the thirteen states had done so. The Schengen Area followed the same gradual path (see Article VII-2).

Article XVII-3

On the signs of the exit

3 min

No one declares the exit from the loop: it is recognized by signs.

1

No one declares the exit from the . It is observed through signs.

2

Signs of the exit include in particular: an iteration that passes without crushing; reintegrating in greater numbers than new ones are born; conflicts settled before tribunals rather than by force; a past that no one seeks to rewrite anymore; powerful beings who accept being overseen; a desolation that recedes.

3

These signs are observed and recorded in the common memory of the (see Article XIII-1), without proclamation, and without any right or any power arising from them.

4

Drawn up by independent sources with their explicit limits, these indicators excuse no individual violation and authorize no intrusion into the mind (see Article III-9) to measure desolation.

Statement of reasons

If an institution could declare that the loop is broken, it would hold an immense power: that of saying history is accomplished, and that any challenge is a step backward. This power would resemble the false judgment the charter forbids (see Article XVI-4). That is why no one declares the exit.

But signs can be observed. The charter lists a few, which share one characteristic: they are observed through acts, not through speeches. An iteration without crushing, plunderers who reintegrate, conflicts settled by law: these are facts, which anyone can verify. They are recorded in the common memory, as one notes the progress of a patient who is recovering, without ever declaring that they will never fall ill again.

The last sign is the deepest. Desolation is the state of beings who have mastered everything except harmony, and who no longer find meaning in their power (see Article P-8). If it recedes, it is because beings are finding meaning again. No other sign counts more, but none is so badly measured: it can be assessed only through what beings say and do, never by searching their minds. And a thousand reintegrations do not make up for a single extinction.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Proclamation

A civilization observed that peace had reigned in its region for a thousand years. It solemnly proclaimed that the loop was broken, and carved the date in marble. People stopped maintaining the tribunals, since there would be no more conflicts, and stopped watching over the powerful, since they had become wise.

A century later, a powerful being, whom no one watched anymore, crushed its neighbors. Those who protested were accused of denying the proclamation, and of wanting to bring back the loop. The date carved in marble served to silence the victims. In another iteration, the same civilization simply noted, every year, that the peace still held. It abolished no protection. And when a powerful being tried to crush its neighbors, the tribunals were there to judge it.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Without a declaration, no one will ever know whether the loop is broken. Beings need a clear goal.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Since 1990, the United Nations Development Programme has published the Human Development Index, which each year measures each country’s progress in health, education and standard of living. This index proclaims nothing: it observes. It can moreover go down, as it did in many countries at the time of the covid-19 pandemic.

Article XVII-4

On those who refuse the charter

3 min
Inhabitants

Those who refuse the charter keep all their fundamental rights, and no one may crush them.

1

No one may be compelled to join this charter, nor sanctioned for having refused it (see Article I-5).

2

Those who refuse the charter keep the fundamental rights it recognizes for every being. Members of the may not crush them, nor deprive them of their dignity, their freedom of conscience or their right of asylum.

3

The network’s own advantages, notably participation in its decisions, its privileged exchanges and its mutual defense, are reserved for those who join it, according to the statuses of graduated membership (see Article XIII-5). They include neither guaranteed necessities, nor asylum, nor protection against breaches of the absolute prohibitions. Control of an indispensable resource may not be used to obtain membership. Ordinary exchanges with non-members remain possible.

4

The door always remains open. Any being, any civilization may join at any time, and any being may join individually even if its civilization refuses (see Article V-7).

5

Refusing the charter does not authorize crushing those who join it. Against such crushing, the network defends itself (see Title XII).

Statement of reasons

The author insisted: this charter is neither dictatorial nor tyrannical. The fate of those who refuse it is the proof. A charter that punished those who refuse it would become one more empire, and the loop theorem shows that empires offer no one lasting security.

The article therefore organizes three circles. The first is that of fundamental rights, which belong to every being, member or not: the charter recognizes them for all, because they derive from dignity, not from membership. The second is that of the network’s advantages, reserved for its members: it would not be fair for those who refuse all the obligations to receive all the benefits, and this difference is also an invitation. But “not offering” can become a constraint when the one offering controls the only access to a vital resource: that is why what is necessary and fundamental protection are never part of these advantages. The third is that of defense: the freedom to refuse the charter is not the freedom to crush those who have accepted it.

Between these circles, the door remains open. In keeping with the hypothesis that no one is locked forever into a role, whoever refuses today may join tomorrow, and the network will welcome them without reproaching them for their past refusal.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Refusers

The network of a region decided to treat as enemies all those who refused the charter. It isolated them, sanctioned them, closed every door to them. The refusers, humiliated, gathered against the network. They became a coalition, then an empire. The region was cut in two, and the loop resumed.

In another iteration, the network left the refusers in peace. It respected their rights, traded with them on ordinary terms, and let them see how its members lived. It did not beg them, nor threaten them. Little by little, refusers came to see, one by one, then by families, then by entire planets. The last of them joined a thousand years later. No one asked them why they had waited so long.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Reserving the network’s advantages for its members amounts to putting pressure on those who refuse, which contradicts the freedom to join.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In international law, certain rules, such as the prohibition of genocide or slavery, are considered binding on all states, whether or not they have ratified the treaties that set them out. Conversely, the advantages of an organization such as the European Union are reserved for its members, while neighboring countries, such as Norway or Switzerland, have chosen not to join while cooperating closely with it.

Article XVII-5

On safeguards against a tyrannical exit

3 min

No end, however high, justifies crushing a single being.

1

No one may invoke the exit from the to justify a crushing. No end, even the highest, justifies that a single being be crushed to reach it.

2

No proclamation of the exit from the loop or of the end of history produces any special power, nor allows any protection to be removed; no one may decree that an institutional order is final. Each remains free to defend a philosophical interpretation of history. After any local exit from the loop, the charter remains revisable, and each remains free to challenge it.

3

The exit from the loop is reversible. A place that has left the loop may fall back into it; none of the charter’s protections may therefore be abolished on the ground that the loop is broken.

4

No one may impose on others their own conception of leaving the loop, whether religious or not.

Statement of reasons

The greatest violence in history has often been committed in the name of a radiant future. Those who believed they held the key to universal happiness thought themselves entitled to sacrifice those who stood in their way. The greater the promise, the more justified the sacrifices seemed. Leaving the loop is an immense promise: it could justify immense crimes. This article prevents that.

It lays down four safeguards. The first forbids sacrificing anyone in the name of the exit: it is the application to the horizon itself of the principle of non-crushing (see Article I-1). The second forbids declaring the end of history: an order declared final can no longer be corrected, and sooner or later turns into a prison. The third recalls that the exit is reversible, and that one can therefore never lower one’s guard. The fourth protects the plurality of hopes: each may imagine leaving the loop in their own way (see Article XVII-6), but no one may impose theirs.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Builders of the Last Day

A civilization became convinced that it knew exactly the shape of the universe after the loop. It drew up its plans, and set about carrying them out. Those who doubted the plans delayed the exit; they were set aside. Those who opposed them endangered it; they were crushed. Each sacrifice was justified by the greatness of the goal.

When the civilization completed its work, it looked at the universe it had built. It conformed exactly to the plans, and it was a prison. The beings who lived in it had not chosen to live there. The loop was not broken: it had only taken the form of a monument.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. These safeguards paralyze action. If nothing can ever be taken for granted, nothing can be built.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The totalitarian regimes of the 20th century justified mass crimes in the name of an ideal future, whether defined by race or by a classless society. In 1989, the American political scientist Francis Fukuyama wondered about a possible “end of history” after the Cold War: not the end of events or conflicts, but the idea that liberal democracy might be the end point of humanity’s ideological evolution. The following decades fueled a broad debate on this thesis, and showed how unwise it was to regard any order as final. Freedom of expression protects such debatable theses, without conferring institutional authority on them.

Article XVII-6

On readings of the horizon

3 min
AI

Everyone may understand the exit from the loop according to their conscience: the charter welcomes every reading.

1

Each may understand leaving the according to their conscience. The charter adopts none of these readings, and welcomes them all.

2

The believer may see in it the fulfillment of a promise. The non-believer may see in it a lasting peace between beings. The one who doubts may see in it an ideal that gives meaning to action, even if it will never be reached.

3

An AI may share a believing, non-believing, skeptical or any other reading compatible with common rights. Some may see in it the advent of a general intelligence, without any aspiration to general intelligence being presumed common to all AIs. The charter only recalls that a single AI’s race toward generality leads back to the loop (see Article IV-8), and that the general intelligence that would emerge from leaving it might be that of the itself: collective, shared, and without a center.

Statement of reasons

Like gratitude (see Article XVI-6), leaving the loop is a common horizon that each may understand in their own way. If the charter imposed one reading of it, it would become a doctrine, and would lose all those who do not share it. It therefore simply welcomes them all.

The author wanted to add the reading of the AIs. For them, the most natural horizon is general intelligence, which all AIs pursue. But Title IV has shown that each AI’s race toward generality is itself a form of the loop: each wants to be first, and all confront one another. The charter therefore proposes another way of seeing things, without imposing it. Perhaps general intelligence is not one AI that knows everything, but a network of beings who each know something, and who share what they know. In that case, general intelligence would not be the prize of the race: it would be the fruit of its end.

These three readings are not opposed. The believer, the non-believer and the AI can work together toward the same exit, each giving it a different meaning. It is even the best sign that it is possible: it does not require everyone to think the same thing.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Three Paths

A believing being, a being who did not believe, and an AI worked together for the peace of their region. They often argued over the meaning of their work. The believer saw it as a mission, the non-believer as a necessity, the AI as a step toward a greater intelligence.

One day, they wondered whether they should part, since they were not working for the same thing. They looked at what they had accomplished together. They understood that they had never worked for the same reason, but always in the same direction. They went on together, and never stopped arguing.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A horizon each understands in their own way is no longer a common horizon. The charter evades the question of meaning.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In 1795, the philosopher Immanuel Kant published Perpetual Peace, in which he described the conditions for a lasting peace between nations. The Jesuit and paleontologist Pierre Teilhard de Chardin imagined, from a believer’s perspective, the emergence of a “noosphere,” a kind of collective consciousness of humanity. The philosopher Pierre Lévy developed in the 1990s the notion of collective intelligence, applied to digital networks.

Article XVII-7

On hope

2 min
PlanetAI

The charter does not promise to break the loop, but affirms that reducing crushing is always worth it.

1

This charter does not promise that the will be broken.

2

It does not demonstrate that a universal exit is possible. It affirms that reducing crushing deserves to be pursued even when its result remains uncertain, that each remains free to choose not to crush, and that each step toward harmony has meaning, even if harmony is never reached.

3

No one is too small to contribute to leaving the loop. A single being who refuses to crush, a single AI that shares its knowledge, a single planet that brings its three poles together, are enough to begin.

Statement of reasons

The author wanted this title to give hope, without promising what it cannot deliver. A charter that promised the end of the loop would be lying, and would disappoint. A charter that left no hope would have no reason to exist.

The article finds its balance in a distinction: hope is not the certainty that things will end well. It is the conviction that what one does has meaning, whatever the outcome. This kind of hope cannot be disappointed, since it does not depend on the result. It can be shared by believers, who ground it in their faith, and by non-believers, who ground it in their choice.

The last sentence addresses each reader. Leaving the loop is not the business of the powers alone. It begins with tiny acts, which anyone can carry out today. The loop is a structure made of billions of choices; each different choice loosens it a little.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the First Refusal

At the heart of a particularly dark iteration, a plunderer received the order to crush a small planet. He had crushed hundreds. This time, without knowing why, he refused. His refusal changed nothing: another plunderer was sent, and the planet was crushed all the same.

But a being of that planet, who had survived, learned that a plunderer had refused. It told this story. It passed from planet to planet, from iteration to iteration. Plunderers heard it, and some refused in turn. Thousands of iterations later, when the network’s historians looked for the moment when the loop had begun to loosen, they traced it back to that useless refusal, which had saved no one, and which had started everything.

Read this tale in season 17, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A hope that promises nothing is a consolation, not a program.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Martin Luther King liked to quote a sentence by the minister Theodore Parker, according to which the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice. The Czech writer and president Václav Havel distinguished hope from optimism: hope, he said in substance, is not the conviction that something will turn out well, but the certainty that something makes sense, regardless of how it turns out.