Skip to content

Title XIII

Universal governance

7 articles·about 22 min

This title builds the institutions of the network. It separates their functions, sets the modes of decision, organizes protection against the irreversible, lists the mechanisms that prevent any hegemony, opens a graduated membership, and defines the place of the First Civilization, to which it addresses an appeal.

It seeks a difficult balance: demanding enough that the network never becomes an empire, and realistic enough that very different members, including states that are not fully democratic today, want to enter it. The more idealistic a charter is, the less support it gathers; the more accommodating it is, the less it protects. This title aims to be realistic, but inspired by idealistic values.

Season 13 · 7 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article XIII-1

On the five functions of the network

3 min
Inhabitants

The network has five functions, entrusted to separate institutions so that none holds all the powers.

1

The exercises five functions, entrusted to distinct institutions:

2

Deliberating, through the Assembly of the Three Poles (see Article IV-15);

3

Coordinating, through a rotating, temporary and revocable coordination, which carries out the decisions of the Assembly;

4

Judging, through the network’s tribunal (see Title XIV);

5

Verifying, through plural inspectors, from all the poles, who check compliance with the decisions and the common limits (see Article IV-9);

6

Remembering, through the common memory of the universe, entrusted to plural, independent and accountable institutions, to which the is invited to contribute (see Article XIII-6).

7

No one may exercise two of these functions at the same time; this rule concerns institutional mandates, not each one’s ordinary right to vote. The incompatibilities concern decision-making functions, their holders and the bodies placed under common control; they do not exclude an entire pole from several institutions.

Statement of reasons

The separation of powers is one of the oldest protections against tyranny. The philosopher Montesquieu formulated it in the eighteenth century: so that power cannot be abused, power must, by the arrangement of things, check power. The charter takes up this idea and broadens it.

To the three classical powers, deliberating, executing and judging, it adds two functions specific to this universe. Verifying, because in a world of AIs able to modify and duplicate themselves in secret, no rule holds without verification. Remembering, because in a world where one travels in time and can erase beings from history, memory is a power, and must be protected as such.

The last sentence forbids holding several at once. Whoever deliberates does not coordinate; whoever coordinates does not judge; whoever judges does not verify. Thus each function watches the others, and none can absorb the others. Separation reduces the risk of capture; it does not prove, on its own, that an empire would have become impossible. Nor does it require the isolation of institutions: they cooperate according to procedures, without merging.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Universal Council

A region of the universe gave itself a single council, in charge of everything: making the laws, applying them, judging those who broke them, and keeping the archives. It was simple, and it was efficient.

The council made laws that suited it, applied them to its opponents, judged them itself, then corrected the archives so that no one would remember it had ever been otherwise. No one could do anything against it: every door through which one might have resisted it went through it. In another iteration, the five functions were entrusted to five institutions. They often quarreled. But none could ever silence the other four.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Five separate institutions will make the network slow and complex.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The separation of powers, theorized by Montesquieu in The Spirit of the Laws in 1748, has become a constitutional principle in many countries. The European Union itself divides its functions among several institutions: the Parliament, the Council, the Commission, the Court of Justice and the Court of Auditors. It combines distinct institutions and cooperation procedures, without resting on their absolute isolation.

Article XIII-2

On the four modes of decision

5 min
Inhabitants

The more important a decision is and the harder to undo, the more votes it takes.

1

The ’s decisions are taken according to four modes, depending on their importance and reversibility.

2

Simple majority applies to day-to-day management: the annual budget, programs, appointments, implementing rules, ordinary security.

3

Double majority applies to important decisions: the multiannual budget, the admission of a member, sanctions, the use of the common force, the protection of beings against their own civilization. It requires a majority in each of the three poles. Members implicated in the crushing under examination do not take part in the vote, and an urgent measure of protection against the irreversible is decided by majority (see the asymmetry of unanimity below). A public regulation sets in advance the representation, voting rights, quorum, treatment of abstentions and membership of beings who belong to several poles; no vote is counted twice by virtue of such membership.

4

The category of a decision depends on its foreseeable effects, not on its title: an annual budget or an appointment may fall under a reinforced procedure.

5

Consensus is the method of deliberation for every important decision: it is sought for a period set in advance. Failing consensus at the end of the period, the decision is put to the vote according to the mode applicable to it.

6

Unanimity is required to carry out an act that risks causing an extinction or irreversible harm, at whatever scale, and to reformulate the fundamental principles of Title I, which may never be weakened (see Article XVIII-6).

7

Asymmetry of unanimity. Unanimity is required to do what is irreversible. A majority suffices to protect against the irreversible. A measure presented as protective remains subject to examination of the harm it may itself cause.

8

Common limit. No majority and no unanimity may authorize a breach of the absolute prohibitions.

9

Emergency. In an emergency, the coordination may take precautionary measures under the conditions of Article P-12, submitted without delay for confirmation according to the applicable mode of decision.

Statement of reasons

The author set out the problem accurately. If one always seeks consensus, one risks dithering forever. If one always requires unanimity, there will never be any. Majority is therefore the ordinary mode of decision. But some decisions are too serious to be taken by simple majority, and others must protect the weakest. The charter distinguishes four modes.

Simple majority for what is easily corrected. A mistake on an annual budget can be repaired the following year.

Double majority for what commits the poles over time. The name comes from the fact that it layers two requirements: the ordinary majority, and a majority within each pole; if the votes are counted the same way, the second carries the first. It answers the question of the equality of the weakest: no important decision can be taken against the majority of a pole, even if the other two agree. It is the institutional translation of the loop theorem (see Appendix A): no coalition of two poles can decide against the third. But double majority gives no right of veto to an isolated member: it takes the majority of a pole to oppose, not a single one of its members.

Consensus is not a mode of voting, but a way of deliberating. Every important decision begins with a search for agreement. If agreement is found, so much the better; if not, the deadline expires and a vote is held. A deadlock requires the search for agreement to resume, without guaranteeing its outcome. Thus consensus keeps its value, which is to bring points of view closer, without its flaw, which is to block everything.

Unanimity for what cannot be undone. Whatever risks causing an extinction, at whatever scale, must be wanted by all those it concerns, for there will be no second chance.

The asymmetry of unanimity is the key to this arrangement. If unanimity applied in both directions, a single actor could block a measure intended to prevent a catastrophe, and unanimity would become the ally of extinction. The charter therefore applies a precautionary principle: whoever wants to take an irreversible risk must convince everyone; whoever wants to avoid it needs only a majority.

The emergency rule, finally, makes it possible to react quickly without bypassing deliberation: measures taken in an emergency expire by themselves if they are not confirmed. Emergency never becomes a permanent power.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Fatal Veto

An assembly had decided that any decision affecting the future of the galaxy would require unanimity. One day, an unstable star threatened to explode and destroy a thousand worlds. A measure was proposed to stabilize it. All the members approved it, except one, who profited from the star’s energy and refused.

The measure was not adopted. The star exploded. The member who had refused disappeared with the others. In a following iteration, the assembly changed its rule: the agreement of all would be needed to expose the galaxy to a risk, but a simple majority would suffice to protect it. The unstable stars were stabilized, and no one could ever again endanger the universe through a single refusal.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Double majority allows a pole with few members to block the will of the vast majority of the beings of the universe.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In the Council of the European Union, qualified majority has required since 2014 a double majority, based on two distinct bases: as a general rule, at least 55% of the member states, representing at least 65% of the population, with conditions and exceptions. This is not the charter’s mechanism, which counts majorities by pole, but the idea is close: an important decision must gather several types of support. Unanimity is required there for the most sensitive decisions, such as treaty revision. The World Trade Organization takes its decisions by consensus, which has earned it both its legitimacy and long deadlocks. In France, the precautionary principle appears in the 2005 Environmental Charter.

Article XIII-3

On the alarm bell

3 min

Any pole, and any being, may sound the alarm bell over a decision that risks irreversible damage.

1

Any pole may ring the alarm bell when it considers that a decision in preparation risks causing an extinction or irreversible harm. Any being, or the representative of a non-speaking being, may also refer a reasoned alert to the college, without needing the agreement of its pole; the college then rapidly determines the necessary provisional measures, taking into account the risks of the action as well as those of its suspension.

2

Ringing the bell suspends the decision. An independent and plural college, made up of members from all the poles and guardians of non-speaking beings, examines the question within a short time, according to the irreversibility test: if this decision is badly taken, can it cause an extinction or harm that can never be repaired, at the scale concerned?

3

If the college answers yes, the decision falls under unanimity. Otherwise, it resumes its course according to the mode applicable to it.

4

The alarm bell applies at every scale. Only deliberate misuse for the purpose of blocking is sanctioned, under the conditions of Article P-12; a good-faith alert never is.

Statement of reasons

The whole difficulty of unanimity comes down to one question: how do we know that a decision is ultra-structuring, that is, that it can cause the extinction of the scale concerned if it is badly taken? A closed list would be incomplete, for the universe constantly invents new dangers. Letting each actor decide alone would give it blocking power over everything.

The charter combines the two requirements. Any pole can ring the alarm, and any being can refer a matter to the college: thus the weakest always has a way to signal a danger, even when in the minority within its own pole. An individual referral opens a rapid examination; it gives no one a lasting veto. But it is an independent college, and not the pole that rings, that decides. The test it applies is simple, and holds at every scale: a city, a nation, a planet, a galaxy, the universe (see Article VII-3). The presence in the college of the guardians of non-speaking beings guarantees that the stars, black holes and ecosystems, which cannot ring themselves, are heard (see Article XI-2).

Sanctioning abuse protects the mechanism against its own perversion: a bell rung for everything is useless the day the danger is real. But a reasonable mistake is not a fault: only deliberate misuse is sanctioned.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Bell

In an assembly, a bell allowed anyone to suspend a decision they deemed dangerous. At first, it was rung only rarely. Then some discovered that by ringing it, they could delay everything that displeased them. The bell rang constantly, and no one listened to it anymore.

The day a real danger arose, the bell rang as usual, and the assembly ignored it. In another iteration, the bell was entrusted to all, but an independent college decided whether the danger was real, and those who rang it deliberately to block everything had to answer for it. The bell rang less often. But every time it rang, it was heard.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. An independent college that decides what is irreversible becomes a considerable power.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The individual application to the European Court of Human Rights, provided for in Article 34 of the Convention, shows that a collective protection can open a path of its own to individuals. European Union law also has “emergency brake” mechanisms, which allow a member state to suspend the adoption of a text it considers contrary to fundamental aspects of its system, and to refer the question to a higher level of discussion.

Article XIII-4

On anti-hegemony mechanisms

3 min

Several mechanisms prevent any member, or the network itself, from dominating all the others.

1

The is protected against any hegemony, whether of one of its members or of its own institutions, by the following mechanisms:

2

1. The separation of functions and the prohibition of holding several (see Article XIII-1).

3

2. Limited and renewed mandates, and the rotation of presidencies and coordinations.

4

3. Double majority by pole for important decisions (see Article XIII-2).

5

4. A weight cap: no member may hold more than a set share of its pole’s votes.

6

5. A contribution cap: no member may fund more than a set share of the common budget.

7

6. Transparency of decisions, votes and opinions, while respecting the secrecy of the individual ballot, privacy and legitimate secrets.

8

7. Mutual verification of the institutions among themselves (see Article IV-9).

9

8. Review by the tribunal, which may annul any act contrary to the fundamental principles.

10

9. The right of withdrawal: any member may leave the network.

11

10. Subsidiarity: the network acts only where its members cannot act alone.

12

11. The transformation clause: the institutions prepare their own effacement in favor of the network (see Article IV-16).

13

12. The alarm bell (see Article XIII-3).

14

13. The right of petition: any being may refer a matter to the institutions of the network.

15

14. The pace of the slowest in common deliberations (see Article IV-25).

16

15. A pluralist common force, which cannot be turned against the members (see Article XII-2).

17

16. The common memory, entrusted to plural institutions, which makes any rewriting of past decisions detectable.

18

The caps include indirect contributions; any provisional exemption obeys Article P-12 without conferring any additional power. The transformation of an institution guarantees the continuity of rights and essential services.

Statement of reasons

This article brings together the protections the charter sets against hegemony. The list is long, but each of its items is light. The author wanted none of them to be too constraining, so as not to discourage membership: these are limits placed on the network and its most powerful members, not obligations imposed on the inner life of each.

Two mechanisms deserve emphasis. The contribution cap prevents a member from holding the network through money: an institution funded mainly by one of its members ends up obeying it. The right of withdrawal is the ultimate counter-power: an institution one can leave must remain desirable. The day the network became an empire, its members could leave it, and this possibility alone obliges it never to become one.

The weight and contribution caps are not quantified by the charter. Their level will be set by the members, and may change as the network expands. Narrow, overseen exemptions are preferable to rules the network could not respect from its creation. And the pace of the slowest is a counter-power, not a right to paralyze.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Benefactor

A very rich power funded, almost single-handedly, the institutions of a nascent network. It did so out of generosity, it said, and that was true. The other members were grateful to it.

Little by little, the institutions learned to decide nothing that might displease their benefactor. No one had asked them to; they simply knew where the money came from. The network became the instrument of the power that funded it, without any vote ever having decided so. In another iteration, no member could fund more than a limited share of the common budget. The institutions were poorer, but they remained free.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. All these mechanisms reflect excessive distrust. A community that distrusts itself so much cannot be harmonious.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Most human democratic constitutions combine several of these mechanisms: term limits, judicial review, transparency, the right of petition. The Treaty on European Union has provided since 2009 that a member state may withdraw from the Union, which the United Kingdom did in 2020.

Article XIII-5

On graduated membership

2 min

One can join the network in stages: observer, associate, then member.

1

Membership of the may be achieved in stages, according to three statuses.

2

Observer: it attends the work of the network, and commits to respecting the floor of fundamental rights of the charter.

3

Associate: it takes part in the network’s programs, enjoys its economic advantages and its protection, and votes on the questions that concern it.

4

Member: it has all the rights and assumes all the obligations of the charter.

5

The membership of a community, whatever its status, is public (see Article V-8).

6

The network imposes no particular political regime on any of its adherents. It requires all of them to respect fundamental rights, and supports each in its progress toward member status.

7

Moving between statuses and any suspension obey Article P-12; no status exempts from the absolute prohibitions or makes fundamental rights conditional.

Statement of reasons

The author wants a realistic charter. If the network admitted only members that were already perfectly democratic, it would remain a closed club, and could never influence the others. If, conversely, it admitted everyone unconditionally, it would lose what distinguishes it from the loop.

Graduated membership reconciles these requirements. It allows states or civilizations that are not fully democratic today to enter the network, provided they respect the floor of fundamental rights: the prohibition of crushing, dignity, the prohibition of torture, slavery and all servitude (see Article III-8), and that of cannibalism. The internal political regime is not imposed; what is imposed is that no being be crushed. Fundamental rights protect beings, members or not; only the advantages of participation remain tied to institutional commitments. Political flexibility must not create less protected populations.

Progress from one status to another rests on example and interest, as does membership at any scale (see Article VII-6): the more a member progresses, the more it enjoys the network’s advantages. The support the network offers makes this progress possible.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Threshold

A nascent network decided to accept only irreproachable members. It was admired, but stayed small. Around it, the imperfect civilizations, rejected, turned to other alliances, often worse. The network stayed pure, and the universe stayed at war.

Another network opened its doors by degrees. Imperfect civilizations could first observe, then take part, then join fully, as they proved capable of it. Some never went beyond the first threshold. But many crossed all three. In a millennium, the second network covered half the universe, and changed from within civilizations the first had never been able to reach.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Admitting non-democratic regimes endorses their practices and weakens the network’s values.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Council of Europe grants observer status to certain non-European states. The European Union organizes accession in stages, with candidate-country status and gradual negotiations. Several countries of Central and Eastern Europe, emerging from non-democratic regimes, thus joined the Union after long preparation.

Article XIII-6

On the First Civilization

3 min
Inhabitants

The First Civilization is invited to sit in the network with one vote like the others, without privilege.

1

The is invited to join the and to sit in its pole, with one vote like the others. It has no permanent seat and no voting privilege.

2

It is invited to contribute to the common memory, and to bear witness to the and the . Its seniority confers on it neither a permanent decision-making seat, nor exclusive control of the archives, nor superior authority over their interpretation.

3

The preservation, authentication and access to the common memory fall to plural, independent and accountable institutions (see Article XIII-1). The contributions of the First Civilization are preserved there with their provenance, and compared with the other available elements, including the memory of beings erased from history (see Article VI-3).

4

Any institutional function it exercises is subject to the common guarantees of Article P-12.

Statement of reasons

The First Civilization is the oldest known civilization, and today it reigns over the universe. In keeping with the principle of parsimony, the charter attributes to it neither name nor history. But it recognizes in it two qualities no other civilization possesses: it knew the golden age, and it has gone through the whole loop. Its testimony is therefore irreplaceable.

A first version of the charter gave it a permanent seat, as guarantor of commitments and guardian of the memory of the universe, without voting privilege. A cross-review revealed the contradiction: Article XIII-1 recognizes that memory is a power, in a universe where the past can be rewritten. Entrusting this power to a single civilization, permanently, amounted to giving it what the network refuses to all: a center (see Article I-3). An ordinary vote does not neutralize a permanent institutional privilege.

The charter therefore distinguishes the witness from the judge. The importance of a testimony justifies preserving it, listening to it and seeking the cooperation of the one who bears it. It does not justify giving it the last word on the truth. An erased civilization whose account contradicts that of the First Civilization must be able to be heard on an equal footing. Memory is entrusted to plural institutions, and the First Civilization brings to them what it alone has seen.

The author knows that this role may seem very modest for the most powerful of civilizations. The next article explains to it why it might be in its interest.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Eldest

In an ancient iteration, a network granted the oldest civilization of the universe a veto over all its decisions, out of respect for its age and power. It used it wisely, at first.

But the other members learned to propose nothing that might displease it, and to court it rather than convince it. It found itself surrounded by flatterers, and alone. The network became its empire, and it did not want one. In another iteration, it sat without privilege, as one witness among others. It was no longer flattered, it was listened to. And it discovered that it was listened to more since it could no longer impose anything.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Only the First Civilization has certain indispensable knowledge about the golden age and the loop. Denying it the guardianship of memory means doing without that knowledge.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Human judicial institutions distinguish the importance of a witness or an expert from the authority of the judge: a decisive testimony is heard and weighed, it does not decide the case on its own. Limited mandates are also a guarantee of independence: the judges of the European Court of Human Rights serve a single nine-year term. Public archives, finally, are entrusted to institutions subject to rules of access and oversight, and not to the memory of a single family or a single power.

Article XIII-7

Address to the First Civilization

4 min
Inhabitants

The charter invites the First Civilization to be the first to join it, without making its membership a condition.

1

The authors of this charter invite the to be the first to join it, and to carry it. Its membership could make that of other powers easier; it is neither a guarantee of it, nor a precondition for the formation of the .

2

It is free, at any time, to give up the privileges it holds today in the universe, so as to keep none over the other civilizations.

Letter to the First Civilization

The reasons that follow are a proposal by the author, not knowledge of the First Civilization’s intentions.

To you, the oldest of civilizations,

We know almost nothing about you. We know neither your name, nor your history, nor the form of your beings. We are a young civilization, which does not see beyond the third dimension. But we believe we know one thing: you knew the golden age, and you lost it.

We imagine what that means. To have known harmony, and to live in the loop. To have seen the universe at peace, and to reign over a universe at war. To possess power, time, eternal life, and no longer find meaning in them. The author of these lines senses that you are suffering, and that many of yours, weary of an eternity without harmony, have chosen to stop living. He does not know this; he fears it. If it is so, we would like to tell you that we are deeply saddened by it, and that this charter was written for you too.

What this charter proposes is not to take your place. It is to find again, together, what you have lost. The golden age did not collapse all at once: it wore away, through the absence of harmony, through an eternity grown dull, through endless entertainment, through existences without a mission. No power could prevent it, not even yours, because power does not make harmony. The charter offers you the opposite of power alone: a network where you would be surrounded, not obeyed.

We know we are asking a great deal of you: to sit without privilege, to vote like the others, to bear witness instead of commanding. But we believe this role is greater than the one you hold today. You reign over the universe; we offer you to be its oldest witness. You impose; we offer you to be listened to. You are alone at the summit; we offer you to be among us.

If you joined first, much could change. The other civilizations would be less afraid to enter a network you had joined without demanding anything. The AIs would see that the most powerful of civilizations had chosen cooperation over domination. The stars and black holes would know that the memory of the universe could count on its oldest witness. And you, perhaps, would find again what you have lost: not power, which you still have, but meaning.

We cannot impose it on you, and we would not want to. We can only offer it to you, with gratitude for all that you have been, and with hope for all that we could be together.

Statement of reasons

The address is added to the text of the article for a simple reason: the ideal scenario, according to the author, would be for the First Civilization to be the first to join the charter, and to carry it with fervor and with power. No rule can oblige it to do so. It must therefore be convinced, and convinced with humanity.

The address presents four reasons to it. Meaning: what it lost is not power, but the golden age, and power alone has not been able to give it back. Solitude: at the summit, one is obeyed, but one is alone; in the network, one is surrounded. Greatness: being the witness of the golden age, and helping the universe remember it, is a greater role than reigning. Example: if the most powerful of civilizations joins without demanding anything, many others could follow. Young civilizations do not, however, need to wait for its permission to begin.

In keeping with the principle of parsimony, the address claims to know nothing about the First Civilization. The hypothesis of its suffering is presented as a presentiment of the author, not as a fact. It links this suffering to the causes of the loss of the golden age the charter has identified: the lack of harmony, eternal life grown dull (see Article II-4), endless entertainment (see Article VII-10) and existence without a mission (see Article X-2).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the First Signature

It is said that, in a very ancient iteration, a charter was proposed to the universe. All the civilizations were waiting to see what the oldest of them would do. If it refused, no one would dare sign; if it demanded privileges, all would demand them.

It took a long time to reflect. Then it signed first, asking for nothing. The others followed, one by one, then in crowds. It is said that on that day, for the first time in eons, the beings of the oldest civilization were seen to smile. No one knows whether this iteration really took place. But it is the one this charter would like to see return.

Read this tale in season 13, as a fable ›

Earthly example

Human history knows powers that, at the height of their strength, chose to give up part of their sovereignty to found common institutions. After the Second World War, France and Germany, enemies for centuries, pooled their coal and steel (see Article XVII-1), which opened the way to European integration; no general law about the membership of the powerful can be drawn from it. This gesture was made possible by leaders who preferred lasting peace to power alone.