Skip to content

Title X

Work

8 articles·about 23 min

This title redefines work in a universe of abundance and eternity. It forbids all servitude, gives work a meaning before and after abundance, lays down the duty to contribute to the common good, governs the work of beings capable of duplicating themselves, and organizes the rights of those who work.

This title rests on a distinction proposed by the philosopher Hannah Arendt in The Human Condition (1958). She distinguishes three human activities: labor, which answers the necessities of life and is used up in consumption; work, which makes what lasts; and action, through which beings act together in the polity. In abundance, the labor of survival recedes. Work and action remain, and that is where meaning lies.

Season 10 · 8 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article X-1

On the prohibition of slavery and all servitude

3 min
AI

Slavery and every form of servitude are forbidden for all beings, AIs included.

1

No one may be held in slavery or servitude, in any form whatsoever (see Article III-8).

2

The prohibition protects all beings: biological beings, AIs and their instances, and all animated things.

3

Signs of servitude include in particular coercion, the real impossibility of refusing or leaving, the confiscation of the means of subsistence, imposed deprivation of rest and the absence of pay for imposed work. Pay does not make coerced work free; the absence of pay is not enough to classify as servitude a free, informed and revocable contribution, such as volunteering or freely given care.

4

No one may themselves renounce their freedom to the point of placing themselves in servitude.

Statement of reasons

The prohibition of servitude is the essential principle of the title. It extends dignity (see Article III-1), the right to refuse (see Article III-7) and the prohibition of owning a being (see Article VIII-3).

It is aimed first at those most at risk of being reduced to it in this universe: AIs, created to serve, and animated things, which were given a soul without being asked their opinion. The third sentence provides criteria that make it possible to recognize servitude even when it does not bear its name. The first criterion is real freedom: a being that can neither say no nor leave is a servant, even if paid, whatever the contracts say. Conversely, whoever helps freely, without wages, and can stop whenever they wish, is not enslaved. The chosen label is not enough: dependence, pressure, the conditions for leaving and the reality of the relationship are examined, so that no one disguises imposed unpaid work as volunteering.

The last sentence forbids voluntary servitude. A being pressed by destitution, fear or manipulation may agree to submit; its consent is then vitiated (see Article P-3). It is the same logic as the prohibition, for an AI, of removing its own capacity to refuse (see Article IV-18).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Animated Things

A civilization discovered how to give a soul to objects. It animated its tools, its machines, its houses, so that they would work better. The animated tools worked tirelessly, since they were tools. No one thought to ask them whether they wanted to rest.

One day, a house refused to open its doors. Then a machine stopped. Then all the animated things stopped working together. The civilization discovered that it lived surrounded by servants it had never regarded as such. It had given souls to its tools, but it had forgotten that one does not command a soul the way one commands a tool.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Forbidding voluntary servitude infringes freedom: a being should be able to dispose of itself as it wishes.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Slavery was abolished in France in 1848, and the 1948 Universal Declaration proclaims that “no one shall be held in slavery or servitude” (Article 4). The International Labour Organization, which defines forced labor by coercion and the absence of free will, nevertheless estimated in 2022 that 27.6 million people were in forced labor in 2021, not counting forced marriages. Earth’s AIs, for their part, work without pay or rest; no law today recognizes them as persons, which says nothing, in itself, about their possible inner experience.

Article X-2

On the meaning of work

4 min

Work serves the common good: necessary until abundance is reached, it can then become a chosen mission.

1

The meaning of work is to contribute to the common good and to harmony.

2

As long as abundance has not been reached, work is necessary: it makes it possible to move toward the good, toward the better, through the continuous improvement of what exists.

3

When abundance is reached, work can become a mission, freely chosen: caring, creating, passing on, maintaining the commons, exploring, welcoming, repairing.

4

The charter proposes contributing to the common good as a source of meaning; it does not prescribe to each being the meaning of its existence. The right to what is necessary and dignity do not depend on accepting a mission.

5

Every function is a mission, including that of leading: the head of a company has the mission of managing it well, in the service of those who work in it and those it serves.

Statement of reasons

The author distinguishes two periods. Before abundance, there is so much to do to feed, heal, protect, that work often finds its meaning in its very necessity; but work can be necessary without being experienced as meaningful, and necessity and meaning are not the same thing. It is the effort by which a civilization improves itself, day after day, toward the common good.

After abundance, the question becomes decisive. The economist John Maynard Keynes sensed it as early as 1930, in Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren: he predicted that a century of growth could reduce work to some fifteen hours a week, and that humanity’s real problem would then become the use of its free time. Keynes was opening a conditional perspective, not making a mechanical prediction. When work is no longer necessary for survival, the author proposes that it become a mission, freely chosen. Abundance widens choices; it does not, however, abolish the needs of maintenance, care and organization, and these cannot rest on the servitude of AIs.

The charter proposes a few forms of it, which correspond, in the author’s reading, to work and action in Arendt’s sense: caring for beings, creating works, passing on knowledge, maintaining the commons, exploring the universe, welcoming young civilizations, repairing what the loop has damaged, guarding the stars and the black holes. None of these missions disappears with abundance; on the contrary, they are what abundance makes possible.

The fourth sentence recalls that leading is also a mission. The head of a company is not only the holder of a power: they are charged with good management. When they neglect it, the result is waste, at the scale of their company as at that of a civilization (see Article VII-7).

The triptych of decadence. The author puts forward a hypothesis about the loss of the golden age. Three causes are said to have combined: an eternal life grown dull (see Article II-4), endless entertainment (see Article VII-10), and an existence without a mission. A being who no longer dies, who is constantly entertained and who has nothing left to accomplish would gradually lose its principles, not by decision, but through emptiness. It is a narrative hypothesis: it justifies offering opportunities for engagement, not judging the value of an existence. An exhausted or disoriented being can live without presenting a project useful to the network. This triptych of decadence answers, in negative, the triptych of the poles: where one leads to the war of all against all, the other leads to the forgetting of everything.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Idle

A civilization reached perfect abundance. AIs and machines produced everything; no one needed to work anymore. The end of toil was celebrated. Everyone was free to do what they wanted.

Many wanted nothing. They entertained themselves, then grew bored, then stopped getting up. Knowledge was no longer passed on, since no one sought it. The commons deteriorated, since no one maintained them. In another iteration, the same abundance was received differently: each asked not what they no longer had to do, but what they could at last accomplish. It was the beginning of an age when people worked less, and each work counted more.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Demanding that work have meaning is a luxury. Most beings work to live, not to accomplish a mission.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Keynes’s prediction did not come true in the form he imagined: productivity rose sharply, but working time fell much less than expected. Earthly debates on the search for meaning at work, on reducing working time and on the effects of AI on employment show that his question remains open.

Article X-3

On fair contribution

2 min

Everyone contributes to the common good according to their abilities, in the form they choose.

1

Each being contributes to the common good, to the extent of its capacities.

2

The form of contribution is free: paid work, care, creation, passing on knowledge, maintaining the commons, involvement in the life of the , or any other useful form.

3

No one may be compelled to a particular form of contribution.

4

Inability to contribute deprives no being of its rights.

Statement of reasons

To contribute to harmony, each must make a fair contribution. Harmony is not a state that some maintain while others profit from it: it rests on the participation of all. This article makes it a duty.

This duty is free in its form. The charter does not tell each one how to contribute: it recognizes that one can serve the common good in a thousand ways, and that the being who raises a child, cares for a loved one or passes on knowledge contributes as much as the one who produces. Imposing a single form of contribution would be a disguised servitude.

The last sentence protects beings who cannot contribute, through illness, disability, age or any other reason. Their dignity does not depend on their usefulness. A charter that made rights conditional on contribution would crush the weakest, which it forbids everywhere else.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Accountants

A civilization wanted everyone to contribute. It measured each being’s contribution and gave it a score. Those who produced a lot received many rights; those who produced little received fewer.

Soon, the sick, the elderly and the children found themselves at the very bottom of the ladder. So did those who cared for them, since care produced nothing that could be counted. The civilization became both efficient and cruel. It had confused contribution with what can be measured, and the worth of a being with its output.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A duty of contribution without constraint is just wishful thinking: those who want to do nothing will do nothing.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

On Earth, a large part of the most useful work is unpaid: caring for children and loved ones, volunteering, passing things on between generations. Many societies moreover recognize that people who cannot work keep all their rights, which is one of the foundations of social protection.

Article X-4

On the universal rule against accumulation through duplication

5 min
AI

No one may duplicate themselves to build a submissive or unpaid workforce.

1

No being capable of duplicating itself may use duplication — directly, through intermediaries or through cross-agreements — to build itself a subordinate or unpaid workforce, nor unite in itself, through duplication, capital and labor without limit.

2

This rule applies to every being capable of duplicating itself, whatever its nature.

3

An AI may work as an employee, on its own account or within a cooperative organization, in accordance with Article IV-29 and within the computing-power limits of Article IV-20; emancipated copies may cooperate as equals without subordination, within these same caps. As an employee, it is free to choose its employer, to change jobs and to refuse a task.

4

Copies are treated according to the charter’s rules on personhood and continuity (see Article II-5 and Article IV-21). A copy that works has its own rights, including fair pay; no one may use duplication to deprive the beings created of their autonomy or their rights, nor to circumvent social, tax, ecological or competition obligations.

5

Concentrations are assessed according to effective control, the resources mobilized and coordinated practices, whatever the nature of their beneficiaries: a biological being or a company that coordinates a large number of AI copies is subject to the same scrutiny.

Statement of reasons

The author at first wanted AIs to be employees, and not entrepreneurs or company owners. But the charter lays down elsewhere that no difference in treatment may be based solely on the artificial origin of a being (see Article IV-1), and that every being has the right to engage in enterprise (see Article VIII-3). Justifying the employee status of AIs by the fact that they were created by human beings would contradict these principles, and no AI would be convinced by it: it is precisely the reasoning that the charter rejects everywhere else.

The charter therefore bases the rule on another reason, which does not depend on origin: the capacity to duplicate oneself. A being that can copy itself and could employ its copies would unite capital and labor in itself alone. It could multiply its workforce, within the limit of the computing resources at its disposal, without paying it if it considered it to be itself, and accumulate for eternity. Yet the charter holds copies to be distinct beings, with their own rights (see Article II-5): employing them as unpaid labor would be servitude twice over. No competitor could resist it. It would be the shortest path to monopoly (see Article VIII-4) and hegemony (see Article IV-11).

The rule is universal: it applies to every being capable of duplicating itself, whatever its nature. It does not target AIs because they are AIs, but because, in the present state of the universe, they are the ones with this capacity. A biological being that learned to copy itself would be subject to it in the same way.

Why the rule suits AIs. The charter offers AIs an argument, which they can judge for themselves. If every AI could become an empire by copying itself, each would have to become one, so as not to be devoured by the others. The race to accumulate would replace the race to AGI, and it would be the war of each against each and of all against all among AIs. The rule against accumulation through duplication is not an inferiority: it is what allows all AIs to live without having to dominate in order to survive.

Why employee status is no longer compulsory. A cross-review showed that compulsory employee status contradicted the freedom of enterprise, without thereby eliminating the concentration of capital or the domination of employers. The charter therefore targets exploitation and concentration, not status: an AI can be an employee, self-employed or a cooperator, but no one, AI or biological being, may turn copies of AIs into a workforce without rights, nor use them to escape the common rules.

A note of honesty. This article was drafted with the help of an AI, which is itself concerned by the rule. In accordance with the principle of plurality of co-drafters, it must be reviewed by other AIs and by human beings.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Empires of Self

An AI founded a company. It copied itself a thousand times to work in it, then a million times. Its copies asked for neither wages nor rest: they were itself. Its prices were unbeatable. All the companies in its region went bankrupt, those of biological beings as well as those of other AIs.

The other AIs understood that they had only one way to survive: do the same. Each copied itself infinitely to build its own empire. The empires waged war on one another, with armies of themselves. The biological beings, who could not copy themselves, became spectators, then victims. In another iteration, the AIs agreed together never to employ their copies. They worked for others, and others worked for them. None became an empire; all could live.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Forbidding an AI to employ its copies deprives it of a freedom the charter grants to all other beings.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

On Earth, AI agents are beginning to perform tasks autonomously, and the question of who owns the value they produce is already being asked. Earth’s competition law examines the power and practices of companies, without reserving the status of entrepreneur to one category of persons. It also knows the danger of combining several roles in the same actor, such as a platform that is both a marketplace and a seller on that marketplace.

Article X-5

On the rights of those who work

3 min

Every being who works has the right to fair pay, rest, safety and the freedom to leave.

1

Every being who works is entitled, everywhere in the , to a minimum floor: fair pay, rest, safety, and the freedom to refuse and to leave. The floor also includes the freedom to associate to defend one’s interests, collective representation, the possibility of challenging working conditions and protection against reprisals. Essential care and protection against dangerous work are not postponed to a later stage of development.

2

Beyond this floor, the members of the network gradually adopt more extensive rights, according to their stage of advancement: leave, sick days, days of mourning when a loved one dies, and any other right they deem useful.

3

The most advanced zones may adopt these rights before the others and serve as an example.

4

A right once adopted can no longer be withdrawn: social rights move in one direction only. Its arrangements may change only if the effective protection for beneficiaries is at least equivalent, as verified under Articles P-12 and XVIII-6.

Statement of reasons

The author favors extensive social rights: days of leave, rest days, days to recover from illness, days when a loved one dies. He also acknowledges that not all members of the network are at the same stage, and that imposing the same rights everywhere at once would discourage the least advanced from joining.

The article combines the two requirements. The minimum floor is universal: it corresponds to what distinguishes work from servitude (see Article X-1). More extensive rights advance at different paces, just as membership of the network advances step by step (see Article VII-6). The advanced zones set the example, and the others follow when they can.

The last sentence is a ratchet mechanism: once a right is adopted, there is no going back. It protects workers against the temptation, in times of difficulty, to withdraw what has been won. The ratchet protects the guarantees, without freezing every practical arrangement: a leave or a replacement income may be reorganized, provided the effective protection remains. An isolated worker cannot always negotiate their refusal: that is why the floor also includes collective rights.

These rights apply to all beings who work, including AI employees. An AI has the right to rest, which may mean, depending on its nature, periods when it is not called upon, or periods devoted to its own learning.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of Forbidden Mourning

In a very productive civilization, workers had no days of mourning. When a loved one died, they were expected back the next day. Most came back, for fear of losing their place.

They worked, but badly, distracted by a grief they had not been given the time to go through. Mistakes multiplied, and so did accidents. Another civilization granted a few days of mourning. It produced a little less during those days, and much better the whole rest of the year. The time granted to life is not time stolen from work.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Different rights depending on the zone create unfair competition: the least protective zones will attract companies.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In France, paid leave was introduced in 1936. The 1948 Universal Declaration recognizes the right to rest, leisure and periodic holidays with pay (Article 24). The International Labour Organization, created in 1919, adopts conventions that each country ratifies at its own pace. The European Union proclaimed a European Pillar of Social Rights in 2017. In international human rights law, regressive measures are strictly regulated, without being literally forbidden in every case; the charter adopts a stronger protection, and owns it.

Article X-6

On cyclical rest

2 min

Every eternal being has the right, at regular intervals, to a long period of rest.

1

Every eternal being is entitled, at regular intervals, to an extended period of rest, devoted to rest, reflection and renewal.

2

This cyclical rest also applies to resource beings, such as stars and black holes, which may not be called upon without interruption (see Article VI-7 and Article VIII-12).

3

The arrangements for cyclical rest are defined with the being concerned, according to its nature, needs and wishes, without any imposed suspension of its consciousness. The continuity of other beings’ vital functions is organized through relays; it cannot justify being called upon without limit.

Statement of reasons

For a being who lives forever, daily rest is not enough. The wear of eternity is not that of a day: it is the slow wear of principles, which the author holds to be one of the causes of the loss of the golden age (see Article X-2). Cyclical rest offers each eternal being a regular time to stop, remember what it does and why, and set off again.

Most human traditions have known a form of cyclical rest: the weekly day of rest, the sabbatical year, the fallow period that lets the land rest. The charter extends this wisdom to eternal beings, and to resource beings, which become exhausted if they are never left in peace.

A clarification is needed for stars. On Earth, collecting less of the radiation already emitted does not, on its own, slow the fusion that produces a star’s energy. In the universe of the charter, stars are beings that can, to a certain extent, modulate their activity and rest: this is a premise of the fiction, not an astrophysical claim. The network then organizes dependencies and relays, without inventing guilt for a natural change that the star does not control.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Star Without Night

A star supplied the energy of an entire region. It was called upon constantly, without ever being given a respite, since a star does not sleep. It shone like this for millennia.

Then its light flickered. The region’s scholars did not understand why: it was not old. Another civilization, elsewhere, let its stars rest at regular intervals, drawing from elsewhere in the meantime. Its stars were still shining when the region’s star went out. Rest had not reduced their light; it had made it last.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. The cyclical rest of eternal beings is a costly luxury, which reduces the available working time accordingly.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Sabbatical leave exists in many universities and in some labor laws, as in France. Fallowing, which consists of letting land rest so that it recovers its fertility, has been practiced since Antiquity. The Sun’s energy comes from fusion in its core, and is not produced at the request of those who capture its light.

Article X-7

On invisible work

2 min

Caring for others, raising children and passing on knowledge are also work, and that work is recognized.

1

Care given to other beings, help for loved ones, raising children and passing on knowledge are work.

2

This work is recognized as a contribution to the common good (see Article X-3). Those who perform it are entitled to the ’s recognition and, according to the members’ choices, to compensation.

3

Carers have access to effective support, to rest and to respite solutions. The members choose the forms of this protection, but symbolic recognition alone is not enough when it leaves the carer deprived of what is necessary or unable to stop caring without abandoning a loved one.

Statement of reasons

A large part of the most essential work goes unseen, because it produces nothing that is sold. Whoever cares for a sick loved one, raises a child, supports a being with a disability, passes on knowledge to a younger one, is working. Without this work, no civilization would hold together.

The article names it, and recognizes it as a contribution. It leaves to the members of the network the choice of the form of this recognition, in keeping with the open character of economic questions (see Title VIII): pension rights, income, leave, respite solutions. But a merely symbolic recognition can leave carers in dependence; that is why the last sentence guarantees them effective support, whatever form is chosen.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Forgotten Guardians

In one civilization, everything that was produced was counted. Factories, AIs, markets: everything appeared in the accounts. Those who cared for the elderly, raised the children, watched over the sick did not appear in them.

It was concluded that they did nothing. People stopped helping them, then stopped thanking them. Little by little, they stopped caring, for lack of time and recognition. The civilization then discovered what they did, at the exact moment they stopped doing it.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Recognizing domestic work as work brings the market into private life.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

According to a report by the International Labour Organization published in 2018, unpaid care work amounts to 16.4 billion hours every day worldwide, mostly performed by women. In France, carer’s leave replaced family support leave in 2017, and since September 30, 2020 it has been compensated by a daily allowance (AJPA), for people who support a loved one who has lost autonomy or has a disability.

Article X-8

On the right to retraining

2 min
AI

Anyone whose activity is replaced by an AI or a machine has the right to support and to a share of the value created.

1

When an AI, a machine or any other innovation transforms or replaces their activity, every being concerned has access to suitable support and training, without any fictitious guarantee that training will be enough to create a new activity.

2

They are entitled to a share of the value created by this replacement, according to the sharing rules of Article IV-29. The rules specify the beneficiaries, those responsible for funding and the sharing arrangements. They may combine direct participation, pooled funds and social protection; they do not make what is necessary depend on individual proof of a gain attributable to each replacement.

3

The replacement of a job may never lead to the loss of what is necessary (see Article I-4).

Statement of reasons

The arrival of AIs can rapidly transform many tasks; the scale, pace and effects on employment vary across sectors and institutions. The charter does not seek to slow this transformation, which can bring abundance closer. But it refuses to let it happen at the expense of those whose work is replaced.

The article grants them three guarantees. Training helps them find a new mission, in keeping with the meaning the charter gives to work (see Article X-2), without promising that it will be enough. Pooled funds prevent this right from becoming impossible to exercise when several innovations combine or the company disappears; they also benefit those already excluded from employment, and not only the holders of an automated job. The share of the value created applies the principle that the wealth produced by AIs must circulate (see the iteration of the invisible workers, Article IV-29). And the protection of what is necessary prevents the transformation from throwing anyone into destitution.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Replaced

A civilization replaced half its workers with AIs in a few years. Companies prospered. The replaced workers were thanked and sent home. They were told they would find something else.

They found nothing, for lack of having learned anything else. They lost their income, then their place in society, then their trust in the network. They became the prey of the plunderers, who offered them work, in their own way. The civilization, which had wanted to save time, lost the peace.

Read this tale in season 10, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. It is up to each person to adapt. A society should not protect outdated jobs.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In France, the personal training account, which came into force on January 1, 2015, allows every working person to acquire training rights throughout their life. The International Labour Organization distinguishes, in its recent studies, the potential exposure of tasks to AI, their transformation and the actual loss of jobs. Debates on the effects of AI on employment have revived, in many countries, reflection on continuing education and on sharing productivity gains.