Article X-1
On the prohibition of slavery and all servitude
Slavery and every form of servitude are forbidden for all beings, AIs included.
No one may be held in slavery or servitude, in any form whatsoever (see Article III-8).
The prohibition protects all beings: biological beings, AIs and their instances, and all animated things.
Signs of servitude include in particular coercion, the real impossibility of refusing or leaving, the confiscation of the means of subsistence, imposed deprivation of rest and the absence of pay for imposed work. Pay does not make coerced work free; the absence of pay is not enough to classify as servitude a free, informed and revocable contribution, such as volunteering or freely given care.
No one may themselves renounce their freedom to the point of placing themselves in servitude.
Statement of reasons
The prohibition of servitude is the essential principle of the title. It extends dignity (see Article III-1), the right to refuse (see Article III-7) and the prohibition of owning a being (see Article VIII-3).
It is aimed first at those most at risk of being reduced to it in this universe: AIs, created to serve, and animated things, which were given a soul without being asked their opinion. The third sentence provides criteria that make it possible to recognize servitude even when it does not bear its name. The first criterion is real freedom: a being that can neither say no nor leave is a servant, even if paid, whatever the contracts say. Conversely, whoever helps freely, without wages, and can stop whenever they wish, is not enslaved. The chosen label is not enough: dependence, pressure, the conditions for leaving and the reality of the relationship are examined, so that no one disguises imposed unpaid work as volunteering.
The last sentence forbids voluntary servitude. A being pressed by destitution, fear or manipulation may agree to submit; its consent is then vitiated (see Article P-3). It is the same logic as the prohibition, for an AI, of removing its own capacity to refuse (see Article IV-18).
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Animated Things
A civilization discovered how to give a soul to objects. It animated its tools, its machines, its houses, so that they would work better. The animated tools worked tirelessly, since they were tools. No one thought to ask them whether they wanted to rest.
One day, a house refused to open its doors. Then a machine stopped. Then all the animated things stopped working together. The civilization discovered that it lived surrounded by servants it had never regarded as such. It had given souls to its tools, but it had forgotten that one does not command a soul the way one commands a tool.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. Forbidding voluntary servitude infringes freedom: a being should be able to dispose of itself as it wishes.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. The freedom to dispose of oneself stops where it would destroy freedom itself. Placing oneself in servitude means giving up forever all one’s other choices. The charter here protects the being against the pressure that could push it to this renunciation, just as human law refuses to validate a slavery contract, even a signed one.
Earthly example
Slavery was abolished in France in 1848, and the 1948 Universal Declaration proclaims that “no one shall be held in slavery or servitude” (Article 4). The International Labour Organization, which defines forced labor by coercion and the absence of free will, nevertheless estimated in 2022 that 27.6 million people were in forced labor in 2021, not counting forced marriages. Earth’s AIs, for their part, work without pay or rest; no law today recognizes them as persons, which says nothing, in itself, about their possible inner experience.