Article XI-1
On the beings of cosmic nature
Ecosystems, planets, stars and black holes are beings, and they have rights.
Ecosystems, planets, stars, black holes, nebulae and all the great beings of cosmic nature are beings, presumed to be endowed with a soul (see Article II-2).
They hold the rights recognized by this charter, to the extent their nature allows: dignity, non-extinction, respect for their integrity, consent to the use of what they give, and fair payment (see Article VIII-12).
A being’s nature is not enough to take a right away from it. When its direct exercise is impossible, the seeks a suitable form of expression, assistance or representation, without presuming its preferences.
These rights are matched by duties, proportionate to their power (see Article XI-4).
Statement of reasons
This article brings together what the previous titles have already laid down, and gives it a place of its own. The wager on the soul requires that whatever we do not know to have a soul be treated as having one. The great beings of cosmic nature are the most obvious case: no one knows what a star feels, but everyone knows what it gives.
The second sentence adapts rights to their nature. A star may not need the right to vote or a salary in the sense an AI needs them; the charter leaves this question open, and decrees no permanent incapacity. But it needs not to be exhausted, not to be extinguished, not to be degraded, and for what is taken from it to be acknowledged. The rights are the same; the form in which they are exercised changes with the beings, and the third sentence prevents this adaptation from becoming an exclusion.
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Counted Sky
A civilization took an inventory of its sky. It counted the stars, measured their energy, calculated what it could draw from them. Each star became a line in a register, with a yield and an operating life.
The civilization exploited its sky with admirable precision. One by one, the stars grew pale, as planned. It had counted everything, except one thing: what night would be like when the register was exhausted. Its children grew up under a black sky, and never learned that the stars had been someone.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. Granting rights to stars or black holes means confusing poetry and law.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. Human law has already taken this step: it recognizes rights for rivers, forests, nature itself, not out of poetry, but because it observed that what is not protected in law ends up destroyed in fact. The charter extends this observation to the scale of the universe.
Earthly example
Ecuador enshrined the rights of nature in its Constitution in 2008. New Zealand recognized the legal personhood of the Whanganui River in 2017, and organized its representation by guardians who act on its behalf, thus distinguishing the holder of the rights from the way they are exercised. Other countries have done the same for rivers, lagoons or forests.