Skip to content

Title XII

Security and the plunderers

13 articles·about 45 min

This title aims to leave the protection market. It establishes a common protection force, which cannot be bought; it leaves each member to organize its own defense; it entrusts the security of all to a public police, guarded against any drift toward the police state, sets the rules for places of deprivation of liberty, and fosters living together; it bans mercenary activity, after a period of regulation; it organizes the reintegration of plunderers, the protection of their victims, prevention and correction; and it guarantees a universal right of asylum.

It rests on a hypothesis of the author, set out from the framing: plunderers are not bad by nature. They became plunderers largely because of the system, and the roles can be reversed. One therefore does not leave plunder by crushing the plunderers, but by changing the structure that produces them. Refusing to regard plunderers as bad by nature does not imply that their acts have an exclusively economic or institutional cause: individual decisions and interests count too, and each answers for their acts.

Season 12 · 13 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article XII-1

On leaving the protection market

3 min

Security is not a commodity: fundamental protection cannot be bought.

1

Security is not a commodity. It is a right of every being (see Article III-6).

2

The aims to put an end to the protection market, in which security is bought at the price of money, resources or submission.

3

Fundamental protection is guaranteed regardless of the resources of the one who needs it. No private payment may buy a priority contrary to the public criteria of necessity. Supplementary services remain possible, under the rules of Articles XII-3 and XII-4: being paid for a service is not enough to make it a racket.

Statement of reasons

The protection market is one of the most powerful engines of the loop. It works like this: the plunderers threaten; the weakest look for a protector; the protector sets its price; those who cannot pay remain unprotected, and some of them, to survive, become plunderers in turn. The threat feeds the demand for protection, and paid protection feeds the threat. It is a machine that itself produces what it claims to fight.

The charter draws from this five reasons to leave it.

First reason: the protection market manufactures plunderers. Those who cannot buy their security have only two choices: to suffer, or to join those who threaten. The more expensive protection is, the more plunder recruits (see the iteration of the two tariffs, Article III-6).

Second reason: it leads to vassalage. When the price of protection becomes submission, the protected lose their freedom (see the iteration of the rampart, Article I-1). The protection market is the economic form of vassalage.

Third reason: it has no interest in peace. Whoever sells security lives off insecurity. If the threat disappeared, its market would disappear with it. It therefore has an interest, deep down, in the threat never disappearing.

Fourth reason: it changes sides. Purchased protection belongs to whoever pays most. The day someone else pays more, the protector becomes the threat.

Fifth reason: it leads to extinction. In a universe where the war of all against all is permanent, a security reserved for those who can pay leaves the others at the mercy of the plunderers. Entire communities disappear, for having been unable to buy their survival (see Article VII-4).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Faithful Protector

A planet had for centuries paid a protection company. The company was effective: the plunderers never came near. The planet paid dearly, but it was at peace.

One day, the planet sought to cut its spending. The company let it know, politely, that the plunderers seemed more numerous this year. A few incidents occurred, which it settled quickly. The planet understood and paid. It never knew whether the plunderers had really been more numerous, or whether the company had simply reminded it that it knew where they were. That is the secret of the protection market: one never knows whether one pays to be protected, or not to be attacked by one’s protector.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. The protection market at least has the merit of existing. Without it, the weakest would be defenseless.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Human history knows many forms of protection racket, from criminal organizations that “protect” the businesses they threaten to warlords who tax the populations they claim to defend. The safest human societies are generally those where security is provided by a public force, funded by all and accessible to all.

Article XII-2

On the common protection force

3 min

The network has a common protection force, funded by all, that no one can buy.

1

The has a common protection force, at the service of all its members and of every threatened being.

2

It cannot be bought. It is funded in common by the members of the network, according to their means, and no one may obtain its protection by paying more.

3

It is made up of contingents from all the poles and all the natures, none of which holds a majority. Its command rotates, and is placed under the oversight of the Assembly of the Three Poles (see Article IV-15). Plurality is assessed in the bodies of direction and oversight; it does not require the presence of every pole in every intervention, and the local absence of a pole does not suspend protection. Any exception to the composition obeys Article P-12.

4

Its funding provides for minimum continuity when contributions are missing. Its chain of responsibility is defined in advance.

5

Its mission is to protect and to neutralize. It may never crush, nor intervene in the internal affairs of a member outside the cases provided for in Article V-6.

Statement of reasons

The common force is the charter’s answer to the protection market. Since security is a right, it must be provided by a force that has nothing to sell. Its common funding frees it from dependence on a payer; its mixed composition prevents it from serving one pole against the others; its rotating command prevents it from becoming the center the network refuses (see Article I-3).

Its mission is strictly limited. It protects beings, and neutralizes the acts that threaten them (see Article P-5). It does not destroy, does not subjugate, does not occupy. A protection force that could crush would become the most fearsome threat in the universe.

The common force does not replace the defense of each member (see Article XII-3). It adds to it, as a guarantee for all, and in particular for the weakest, who lack the means to defend themselves alone.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the One-People Guard

To protect itself from the plunderers, a region entrusted its defense to the most powerful of its civilizations. The guard was effective, and the region lived in peace. But the guard came from only one people, answered only to it, and cost only the others.

Little by little, the civilization guarding the region got into the habit of deciding for it. It protected better those who pleased it. The day it wanted to impose its laws, no one could resist it: it was the only one bearing arms. In another iteration, each people of the region supplied a share of the guard, and the command changed hands every year. No people could ever turn the guard against the others, since it was made of all of them.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A force made up of all the poles and commanded in turn will be less effective than an army unified under a single command.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

United Nations peacekeeping operations rely on contingents supplied by many states, and funded by common contributions. They have known successes and failures, notably for lack of resources and clear mandates. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization, for its part, rests on a principle of collective defense among its members.

Article XII-3

On the defense of members and the defense industry

3 min

Every member freely organizes its own defense, and the defense industry stays free, within the charter.

1

Each member of the freely organizes its own defense, publicly, privately or in a mixed form, in compliance with this charter and the safeguards of Article XII-4.

2

The defense industry, aerospace included, and intelligence companies freely carry out their activity. They may innovate, make profits and contract with the members of the network and with the common force.

3

The decision to use force may never be sold. It belongs to a legitimate and accountable authority: that of the member concerned, or that of the network. The responsibility of the deciding authority does not erase that of the supplier or the executor. Goods, services and assistance intended for a violation of the absolute prohibitions, or supplied with knowledge of such use, are forbidden. An order manifestly contrary to these prohibitions must be refused.

4

Intelligence tools, whether public or private, are subject to the privacy and surveillance rules of Article III-3. The data collected and the decisions arising from it remain under the control of the legitimate authority.

Statement of reasons

The author does not want the charter to seem hostile to defense companies, and he is right. On Earth as in the universe, a large share of innovation comes from the private sector, and another from the military sector. Antagonizing these actors would mean depriving oneself of their know-how and discouraging them from joining. That is why the article leaves each member to organize its own defense, and fully recognizes the freedom of the defense and intelligence industry.

The charter draws a single border, which runs not between public and private, but between two activities of different nature. The defense industry makes equipment, tools and services; it sells them to legitimate authorities, which decide on their use and answer for it. Mercenary activity sells force itself, that is, the decision to use it, to the highest bidder, without allegiance or accountability. The first is an industry; the second is a market in violence. The third sentence of the article sets this border: everything may be sold, except the decision to use force.

The fourth sentence applies the same logic to intelligence. A company may supply the most advanced tools for analyzing information. But it may not become, through these tools, a power of surveillance that would escape any legitimate authority.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Armorer and the Condottiere

In one region of the universe lived two merchants. The first made shields, ships and instruments of vigilance. He sold them to civilizations, which decided on their use. He grew rich, invented much, and his inventions also served many other things besides war.

The second made nothing. He sold fighters, ready to serve whoever would pay. One day, he was paid to defend a planet, then paid more to attack it. He changed sides in the middle of the battle. The civilizations of the region went on buying from the first merchant. They banned the second, and discovered that they could do without him and lose nothing, except fear.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. The border between selling equipment and selling force is blurred: a company that supplies operators to run its systems is also selling a share of force.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Many civilian innovations were born of military research or the defense industries, such as the computer networks that preceded the Internet, or satellite positioning. In human democracies, the defense industry is often private, but the decision to commit the armed forces lies with the political authorities, under the oversight of parliaments.

Article XII-4

On the safeguards of private defense

4 min

Defense may call on private actors, but the decision to use force always stays with the legitimate authority.

1

When a member entrusts all or part of its defense to private actors, the monopoly of the legitimate use of force remains in the hands of its legitimate authority. Command, the decision to commit force and control of the means may never be delegated.

2

No private actor may hold alone most of a member’s means of defense. The functions of intelligence, armament and intervention may not be entrusted to the same actor.

3

Defense contracts are limited in time, public in their main lines, and overseen by a body independent of the member and by the common force. The legitimate authority may, at any time, take back the means it has entrusted.

4

Any collusion of a defense actor with is forbidden. This prohibition does not cover contacts necessary for the protection of victims, humanitarian action, investigation or a negotiated surrender, when they are conducted within an accountable and overseen framework. Personnel are registered, and those who report a breach are protected.

5

No one recognizes the authority of those who seize power by force. The legitimacy of an authority derives neither from its victory by force nor from mere precedence. The continues to recognize the overthrown legitimate authority, suspends any contract with the actors involved, excludes them from its markets, and may protect the threatened beings under Article V-6. It never, however, maintains or restores a power that crushes its own beings: after the fall of such a power, legitimacy returns neither to the victors nor to the vanquished, but to the free expression of the beings concerned (see Article VII-7), whose restoration the network records.

Statement of reasons

Letting each member organize its defense, including privately (see Article XII-3), carries a risk the author has identified: that a private actor might end up seizing what the sociologist Max Weber called, in 1919, the “monopoly of legitimate physical violence.” A company that controlled a member’s weapons, information and personnel could, one day, make contact with plunderers, or come to an understanding with a faction, and overthrow the authority it was meant to serve.

The article sets five safeguards against this risk, all resting on one principle: means may be entrusted, never power.

Command is not delegated. The private sector supplies, sometimes operates, but never decides. The chain of command remains that of the legitimate authority.

Separation and plurality. An actor holding intelligence, weapons and personnel all at once would have everything needed for a coup. The charter separates these functions, and forbids a single actor from holding most of the means: this is the balance of forces (see Article IV-11) applied within a member.

Oversight and reversibility. Time-limited contracts, overseen by an independent body and by the common force, which the legitimate authority can take back at any time: no private actor can settle permanently at the heart of a member’s defense.

The break with the plunderers. Contact with plunderers is forbidden, personnel are known, and those who report a breach are protected, because it is often from the inside that one learns a plot is being prepared.

Non-recognition of usurpers. This is the most dissuasive safeguard. An actor who overthrew the legitimate authority would gain nothing: the network would continue to recognize the overthrown authority, would break all its contracts, exclude it from its markets and protect the threatened beings. A coup that can be neither recognized, nor paid, nor used is of no interest to anyone.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Palace Guard

A planet entrusted its defense to a private company, efficient and discreet. The company supplied the weapons, the information and the guards. Little by little, nothing was done without it. One day, a discontented faction came to propose a deal: overthrow the government, and share power. Plunderers offered their help.

The company accepted, and took the palace in a night. But in the morning, the network refused to recognize the new masters. Contracts were broken, markets closed, accounts frozen. The plunderers, seeing there was nothing to gain, withdrew. The faction split. Within a few weeks, the legitimate authority returned. In the following iterations, no company in that region was ever tempted again: it knew that a palace taken by force is a palace where one remains alone.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. These safeguards make private defense so constraining that they amount to forbidding it.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The sociologist Max Weber defined the state, in a 1919 lecture, as the human community that successfully claims the monopoly of legitimate physical violence within a territory. The African Union suspends member states in which a government has been overthrown by an unconstitutional change. In many countries, the protection of whistleblowers now extends to the defense sector.

Article XII-5

On the police and the monopoly of legitimate force

5 min

At every scale, a public police force protects all beings present, whether or not they belong to the network.

1

At every scale, a public police ensures the security of all beings present in its territory, whether or not members of the , whatever their nature.

2

The police holds, together with the defense forces placed under a legitimate authority (see Article XII-4), the monopoly of the legitimate use of force. No militia, no private force, no group of beings may take the law into its own hands or exercise coercion in its place. Private security services act only within the limits set by the public authority, and with no power of coercion other than legitimate self-defense.

3

The public force is instituted for the advantage of all, and not for the particular use of those who command it.

4

Where several poles or several natures live together, the police is made up of officers from each of them, none of which holds a majority. The temporary impossibility of achieving this composition does not suspend protection and falls under Article P-12.

5

Territorial jurisdictions and the arrangements for assistance between forces are set in advance.

6

The network’s common force intervenes only when the competent police cannot or will not protect the threatened beings (see Article XII-2).

7

The police acts by the consent of those it protects. This collective consent to the institution does not give the perpetrator of a harm a veto over its intervention. The immediate and proportionate defense of others remains permitted when no help can arrive in time. It treats everyone with respect, listens to them, and explains its decisions. It is close to the beings it serves, and knows them.

8

Its officers receive long training, which includes de-escalation, mediation, fundamental rights and knowledge of the different natures. They use the minimum force necessary.

9

When the situation calls for care, mental distress or social conflict rather than crime, the most suitable responder is sent: caregiver, mediator or social worker, with police support if necessary.

Statement of reasons

This article answers an objection the charter had to take seriously: by reintegrating the plunderers, refusing the death penalty and limiting the length of sentences, does it not create insecurity? The answer is that a charter of peace is not a charter without police. On the contrary: it is because everyone can count on a public protection, equal for all, that no one needs to protect themselves, buy their protection, or take the law into their own hands.

The charter takes up Max Weber’s idea, the monopoly of legitimate physical violence (see Article XII-4), while immediately limiting it in three ways. The public force serves everyone: this is the sentence of the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man, which the charter extends to the universe. It belongs to no pole: where biological beings, AIs and inhabitants of the universe live together, a police made up of a single pole would quickly be perceived as the police of some against the others. It is regulated by the safeguards of the next article.

The last three sentences draw on what works best on Earth. Consent and procedural justice: research shows that beings respect the law and cooperate with the police far more when they are treated with respect, listened to and informed of the reasons for a decision, than when they are merely coerced. Proximity: a police that knows the inhabitants prevents more than it represses. Training: the countries where the police inspire the most trust train their officers for several years, and de-escalation training reduces the use of force and injuries, on both sides. The right responder: sending an armed officer to a mental health crisis often turns distress into tragedy; sending a caregiver often calms it.

The monopoly also protects against the opposite drift: the multiplication of private forces, militias and vigilantes. Where everyone protects themselves as best they can, the richest buy themselves a security the others do not have, and one returns to the protection market that this title seeks to abolish (see Article XII-1).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Guarded Districts

In a city of the universe, the public police was deemed too costly, and everyone was left to organize their own security. The rich districts hired guards, then militias, then small armies. The poor districts organized themselves as best they could, with gangs that both protected and extorted them.

Soon, each district had its force, and each force its enemies. The guards of some arrested the inhabitants of others. No one knew any longer who had the right to coerce whom. The city, which had wanted to save on a police force, had manufactured a hundred small wars. In another iteration, it kept a public police, made up of beings of all the natures who lived there, at the service of all the districts. It was expensive. But it cost less than a hundred wars.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Giving the monopoly of force to a police creates the instrument all tyrants need.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Article 12 of the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen provides that “the guarantee of the rights of man and of the citizen requires a public force: this force is therefore instituted for the advantage of all, and not for the particular use of those to whom it is entrusted.” The principles of British policing, attributed to Robert Peel in the 19th century, rest on the idea that the police draw their authority from public consent. In Norway and Finland, police training lasts three years, at university level, and about nine Finns out of ten say they trust their police. In Japan, thousands of small neighborhood police boxes, the kōban, maintain a close link between officers and residents. In the United States, an evaluation of de-escalation training in the Louisville police found a significant drop in the use of force and in injuries, among citizens and officers alike. These results are encouraging, but local. In Denver, the STAR pilot program, which sends caregivers rather than police officers to certain distress situations, was associated, from 2020, with a drop of about a third in recorded low-level offenses in the areas concerned, according to a study published in Science Advances in 2022; the study covers these recorded offenses, not all crime. In Eugene, Oregon, a similar scheme, CAHOOTS, operated from 1989 until April 7, 2025, when it ceased operating in that city; it inspires schemes elsewhere.

Article XII-6

On safeguards against the police state

5 min
AI

The police use force only as a last resort, proportionately and under oversight.

1

The police uses force only when necessary, proportionately, and as a last resort. Non-violent means are preferred when they can protect effectively; an immediate danger does not require successively trying manifestly unsuitable means. All force remains subject to the absolute prohibitions.

2

Its officers are identifiable. Its interventions involving the use of force are recorded, and these recordings are kept and accessible to the oversight authorities and to the persons concerned; their disclosure protects victims, third parties and privacy.

3

An oversight body independent of the police, made up of beings from the three poles, investigates any use of force reported to it. Any being may refer a matter to it, and those who report an abuse are protected.

4

The following are forbidden: political police; mass surveillance (see Article III-3); thought reading (see Article III-9); sanctioning a being on the mere prediction of what it might do; any discrimination based on nature, origin or belief.

5

No one may, in the police as in the common protection force or the forces of the members (see Article XII-2 and Article XII-3), entrust the decision to use force against a being to an automatic system for which no being answers. An automatic device may not engage force without verifiable limits of use, an effective possibility of interruption and independent oversight; designating someone responsible is not enough to meet these requirements. An AI recognized as a person is never treated as mere equipment: it answers for its own acts.

6

Data on the use of force by the police are published regularly, at every scale.

7

Any officer who witnesses an abuse committed by another has the duty to intervene to stop it and to report it. They are protected against any reprisal.

8

The oversight body conducts its own investigations, with its own investigators; the police never investigate complaints against them. An early detection system identifies officers whose behavior is of concern, in order to support them or remove them before a tragedy occurs.

9

The police is evaluated on real security and on the trust it inspires, and not on quotas of arrests or sanctions. Its recruitment reflects the diversity of the beings it protects.

Statement of reasons

The author put the question bluntly: how can the police be given the monopoly of force without creating a police state, a violent state that uses and abuses this monopoly? There is no single answer, but a combination of safeguards, none of which is sufficient alone.

Proportionality is the first rule of any legitimate force: force is used only if necessary, as much as necessary, and when nothing else has worked.

Transparency makes abuses visible. An identifiable officer knows they will have to answer for their acts. A recorded intervention can be examined. Public data make it possible to see whether force is used more often against some beings than others.

Independent oversight is the key. A police that investigates itself rarely inspires trust. The oversight body is therefore external to the police, and made up of the three poles, so that none can protect its own.

The prohibitions target the drifts that turn a police into an instrument of tyranny: the political police, which pursues opinions; mass surveillance, which treats everyone as a suspect; thought reading; and predictive policing, which would sanction beings for what a calculation predicts they might do. Forecasting risks to better allocate patrols is legitimate; sanctioning a being for an act it has not committed never is.

Oversight from inside and outside. The duty to intervene makes every officer a safeguard: an abuse that colleagues let happen is a shared abuse. Entrusting the investigation entirely to an outside body prevents the police from judging itself. Early detection makes it possible to act before the tragedy, not after.

Evaluation. A police judged on the number of its arrests will be tempted to arrest to meet the numbers: this is Goodhart’s law (see Article XV-10). A police judged on real security and the trust of the population has an interest in preventing rather than repressing.

Accountability finally forbids entrusting the decision to use force to an automatic system for which no one answers. An adult AI, responsible for its acts, may be a police officer like any other being; but a device with no one responsible cannot decide to coerce a being.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Perfect Police

A civilization wanted the most effective police in the universe. It gave it everything: surveillance of every street, every message, every thought; the right to arrest anyone who seemed dangerous; the authority to investigate itself. Crime disappeared almost entirely.

Then the police began to arrest those who criticized the police. No one could complain about it, since complaints were examined by the police. The day a new leader took power, he found the perfect instrument, ready-made, and used it against everyone. In another iteration, the police was less powerful, more visible, overseen by others than itself. There was a little more crime. But no leader could ever turn it against the people it protected.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. So many controls weaken the police and prevent it from protecting beings effectively.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In 1990, the United Nations adopted the Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, which call for non-violent means as far as possible, and lay down the rules of necessity and proportionality. In France, the wearing of an individual identification number by police officers and gendarmes has been compulsory since 2014, and the Défenseur des droits, an independent authority, has jurisdiction over the ethics of the security forces. In the United Kingdom, an independent body investigates complaints against the police. In Northern Ireland, since 2000, the police have not been allowed to investigate public complaints themselves: an independent ombudsman, with its own investigators, handles them entirely. In 2020, the Los Angeles police ended its predictive policing program, after criticism of its effectiveness and its discriminatory effects.

Article XII-7

On places of deprivation of liberty

4 min
AI

Every deprivation of liberty respects the being’s dignity and prepares its return among the others.

1

Any deprivation of liberty, whether it results from a court decision (see Article XIV-6) or a provisional measure, takes place with respect for the dignity of the being and its fundamental rights.

2

Places of deprivation of liberty have a dual purpose: to protect other beings, and to prepare the reintegration of the one held there.

3

Detained beings are protected against all violence, including that of other detained beings. They have access to care, education, paid work and the maintenance of their ties.

4

Every place of deprivation of liberty may be visited at any time, without notice, by an independent inspector, who publishes their findings.

5

Release is prepared from admission, and followed by support.

6

Deprivation of liberty is the last resort. For the least serious acts, alternative measures are preferred: reparation, community service, supervision in freedom.

7

Life in places of deprivation of liberty is as close as possible to life outside. These places are of human scale, close to families, and their staff know the beings they supervise.

8

For AIs, deprivation of liberty takes the form of suspension or restriction of their means of action, under the conditions of Article IV-28.

9

Detention conditions are adapted to the nature and lived duration of each being. A suspension of activity or a restriction of substrate does not remove its access to defense and appeal.

10

Reparation activities offered as alternatives respect consent and the prohibition of forced labor. Refusing to confess removes no right. Pre-trial detention respects the presumption of innocence.

11

Independent inspectors also collect, confidentially, the complaints of detained beings.

Statement of reasons

A charter that refuses the death penalty and eternal sentences must say what it does with those it deprives of liberty. It must also answer a practical question: how can prison really protect, instead of producing new plunderers?

Human experience is fairly clear on this point. Overcrowded, violent and degrading prisons manufacture reoffending: one goes in for an offense and comes out with accomplices, debts and rage. Prisons that respect dignity, protect inmates from one another, train, care for and prepare for release seem to obtain better results, even though comparisons of reoffending between countries are tricky, because definitions, populations and follow-up periods differ. A “human-scale” prison is moreover no universal guarantee: an AI suspended for a century has not necessarily benefited from a century of preparation for release. Dignity is therefore not only a moral duty: it is a security policy.

The two new rules draw on the Norwegian model. Normalization: since the detained being will one day return among the others, its life in detention should resemble as closely as possible the life it will lead outside, with work, responsibilities, ties. Dynamic security: guards who know the inmates, talk to them and support them prevent violence better than walls and cameras. And prison remains the last resort: for the least serious offenses, it desocializes more than it protects.

The article also adopts a simple and effective guarantee: unannounced inspection. A closed place that no one can visit sooner or later becomes a place of abuse. A place that an independent inspector can visit at any time becomes one much more rarely.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Two Prisons

Two planets locked up their plunderers. The first crammed them into dark cells, without work or visits, and considered that this was what they deserved. The second housed them decently, taught them a trade, maintained their ties with their loved ones, and prepared their release from the very first day.

The inhabitants of the first planet found the second naive. Then they compared. Most of the plunderers released by the first returned to plunder, more hardened than before. Most of those released by the second did not. The first planet had been severe with its plunderers; the second had been effective for its inhabitants.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Offering good conditions to those who have done harm is an injustice toward their victims.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, revised in 2015 under the name of the Nelson Mandela Rules, set the standards of dignity in prison. The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture, set up in 1989, has since 1990 visited, with confidential interviews, places of detention in the countries of the Council of Europe, and in France, the Contrôleur général des lieux de privation de liberté, created in 2007, may visit at any time any place where people are deprived of liberty. Norway, whose prisons apply the principle of normalization and dynamic security, is often cited for one of the lowest reoffending rates in Europe; its facilities are often small and its guards are trained for two years.

Article XII-8

On living together and shared security

3 min

Security rests first on trust between neighbors, of every nature.

1

Security does not rest on the police alone. It rests first of all on trust between the beings who live together.

2

The fosters, at every scale, ties between neighbors of all natures, meeting places, and everyone’s participation in the life of their community.

3

Any neighborhood or everyday conflict may be submitted to community mediation, free and voluntary.

4

Mediation is never a condition of access to protection, to a judge or to an urgent measure. It presupposes the free and continuing consent of the participants, and may be set aside when violence, coercive control or inequality make that consent uncertain. Refusing it amounts neither to fault nor to admission.

5

The network teaches, from the earliest age and to all natures, the peaceful resolution of conflicts, listening and respect for differences.

6

Shared security authorizes neither informing on others, nor the surveillance of some by others, nor the formation of militias (see Article XII-5).

Statement of reasons

The author asked that the charter draw on the best of what is done on Earth in matters of civility and living together. Research is remarkably clear on one point: the safest places are not those with the most police officers, but those where beings know one another, trust one another and are ready to act together for the common good. Sociologists call this collective efficacy. Where it is strong, violence is lower, even at equal levels of poverty; it is a solid association, which does not on its own demonstrate causation.

The article draws four consequences from this. Ties: a neighbor one knows is no longer a stranger, and one does not easily harm someone one knows. Mediation: most conflicts of daily life, between neighbors, between colleagues, between beings of different natures, are better settled through dialogue, with the help of a mediator, than by the police or the courts. Education: one can learn, from childhood, to settle a disagreement without violence. The limit: shared security is not mutual surveillance. A society where everyone spies on their neighbor is not safer: it is only more fearful.

In a universe where biological beings, AIs and inhabitants from elsewhere live side by side, this article is of particular importance. Misunderstandings between different natures are a major source of conflict. A mediation that knows both natures, and an education that teaches understanding of the other, avoid much violence that no police could have prevented.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Unknown Neighbors

In a great city of the universe, human beings, AIs and inhabitants of another planet had lived door to door for years, without ever speaking to one another. One evening, an AI unknowingly made a noise unbearable to the hearing of its neighbors from elsewhere. They believed it was a provocation. They called the police, who arrived armed. The situation escalated. There were injuries over a matter of noise.

In another iteration, the same city had meeting places and neighborhood mediators. The AI and its neighbors had already crossed paths. When the noise began, the neighbors knocked on its door. The AI did not know it was bothering them; it apologized and changed its habits. No one called the police. No one was hurt. And the next day, the neighbors discovered that they had things to say to one another.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Trust between neighbors cannot be decreed. A charter cannot force beings to love one another.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In 1997, the sociologist Robert Sampson and his colleagues showed, in a study published in the journal Science (“Neighborhoods and Violent Crime”), that in the neighborhoods of Chicago where residents trust one another and are ready to intervene together for the common good, less violence is observed, independently of their poverty. Many countries have developed community mediation and school mediation, which trains pupils to settle their classmates’ conflicts. In Japan, security rests largely on close neighborly relations, in connection with the small neighborhood police boxes.

Article XII-9

On mercenary activity: prohibition and transitional regulation

3 min

Selling armed force to the highest bidder is forbidden, except, for a time, within a very strict framework.

1

Mercenary activity, that is, the sale of armed force itself to the highest bidder, is forbidden.

2

As long as the common force does not ensure a sufficient level of security, mercenary activity is tolerated within a strict framework: registration with the , prohibition on serving , prohibition on changing sides in mid-mission, subjection to all the rules of the charter, personal responsibility of each fighter and of those who employ them.

3

The prohibition becomes total as soon as the Assembly of the Three Poles finds that the common force ensures a sufficient level of security.

4

The transition includes public stages, protection criteria by territory and periodic reviews. It suspends no absolute prohibition. No contractual loyalty requires carrying out an unlawful order, nor forbids a protective surrender. The overall capacity of the network is not enough to declare the transition complete if some communities remain without effective protection.

Statement of reasons

The author wants mercenary activity banned, which he regards as a bad thing that leads to extinction. But he acknowledges that, during the periods when the war of each against each and of all against all reigns, and as long as the network has not reached a certain level of security, some beings have no other way to protect themselves. Banning mercenary activity immediately would leave them defenseless.

The article therefore combines a goal and a transition. The goal is prohibition. The transition is strict regulation, which strips mercenary activity of its most dangerous features: serving plunderers, betraying in mid-mission, escaping all accountability. The end of the transition is not set by a date, but by a finding: when the common force protects sufficiently, mercenary activity no longer has any reason to exist, and it is banned.

Why does mercenary activity lead to extinction? Because a force that sells itself has no loyalty other than money. It serves whoever pays, against whoever cannot pay; it prolongs the wars that keep it alive; and sooner or later it turns against those who employ it, as soon as it is strong enough to serve itself. Machiavelli was already writing in 1532, in The Prince, that mercenary arms are “useless and dangerous.”

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Hired

A rich civilization did not want to risk the lives of its own beings. It hired fighters to wage its wars. They fought well, as long as they were paid. They made the wars last, since peace would have deprived them of their pay.

One day, they understood that they were stronger than those who paid them. They marched on their employer’s capital, and entered it without resistance: the rich civilization had forgotten how to defend itself. It had hired its security; it discovered that it had hired its own conqueror.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Regulating mercenary activity legitimizes it.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The International Convention against the Recruitment, Use, Financing and Training of Mercenaries, adopted by the United Nations in 1989, has been ratified by only a limited number of states. The Montreux Document, adopted in 2008, recalls the existing obligations of states toward private military and security companies and lists good practices; it is neither a binding treaty nor a ban on these companies. In June 2023, in Russia, the Wagner paramilitary group briefly rose up against the military command of the country that employed it.

Article XII-10

On the reintegration of plunderers

3 min

Any plunderer may ask to come back into the network: the door always stays open, step by step.

1

Any may, at any time, request reintegration into the . The exit door from plunder always remains open.

2

Reintegration follows steps: voluntary exit and renunciation of plunder; truth about the acts committed; reparation; training and a new mission, freely chosen from accessible possibilities; support from a sponsor, preferably a reintegrated former plunderer; a probationary period; full citizenship.

3

For acts prior to joining, the amnesty-for-truth regime of Article VI-6 applies, according to the variant adopted.

4

During the probationary period, the reintegrated plunderer is monitored, in proportion to the danger they represented. Reintegration may be suspended in the event of a serious breach, and the safety of victims and other beings always takes precedence.

5

The memory of the acts is preserved. It may not be used to stigmatize the one who has reintegrated.

6

The conditions of reintegration are individualized under Article P-12. Insufficient resources do not permanently close off reintegration. Sponsorship creates no personal dependence.

7

The detailed rules of the procedure are the subject of an implementing document, which remains to be drafted.

Statement of reasons

The reintegration of plunderers is established in principle: they are not plunderers by nature, but largely because of the system (see Article P-9). They must still be offered a concrete path. The author proposes drawing on the reintegration of prisoners; the charter adds the experience of programs for leaving armed conflict and of restorative justice.

Each step has its reason. Voluntary exit, because one does not reintegrate someone against their will. Truth, because the victims have a right to it, and because one does not change without acknowledging what one has done. Reparation, because reintegration cannot be done at the expense of the victims. Training and a mission, because a plunderer with no other means of living will become a plunderer again (see Article X-2). Sponsorship by a former plunderer, because whoever has walked the path knows better than anyone what it costs and how to travel it. The probationary period, because trust is rebuilt over time. Full citizenship, finally, because a reintegration that left the former plunderer forever on the margins would be only another form of exclusion.

The author leaves this procedure open, to be specified in an implementing document. What is set here are the steps and their spirit.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Sponsor

A former plunderer, reintegrated long ago, was asked to accompany a young plunderer who wanted to get out. The young one trusted no one: neither the network, nor the judges, nor those who promised him another life.

But he trusted his sponsor, because the sponsor had known the same nights, the same fears, the same temptations to turn back. The sponsor promised him nothing easy. He only said: I made it, and I am no better than you. The young plunderer stayed. Years later, he became a sponsor in turn. That is how, step by step, the plunderers of a region saw their ranks empty, without a single battle being fought.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Reintegrating plunderers who have committed serious crimes rewards crime and discourages those who have always respected the rules.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The United Nations has carried out, in many countries emerging from civil wars, programs for the disarmament, demobilization and reintegration of former combatants, with variable results. Restorative justice, which organizes, with their agreement, meetings between perpetrators and victims of offenses, was introduced into French law in 2014; it rests on voluntary participation and is not the same as dropping criminal proceedings.

Article XII-11

On guarantees for victims

2 min

Victims are informed and heard at every stage of the return of those who harmed them.

1

The victims of are informed at each stage of the reintegration of those who harmed them, and are heard before each decision, if they so wish: each victim chooses to be informed, to take part or to withdraw.

2

They cannot on their own oppose a reintegration. But they can obtain protective measures: distancing, a no-contact order, or any other measure necessary for their safety.

3

No victim may be compelled to meet the one who harmed them. If they wish, a meeting may be organized, with the consent of both parties and with support. No forgiveness is required.

4

Victims have priority in reparation. A common fund, fed in particular by assets seized from plunderers, guarantees their compensation when the perpetrator cannot make reparation; it does not depend exclusively on these confiscations, and the legitimate owners of the seized assets keep their rights.

5

Victims are entitled to support, for as long as necessary.

Statement of reasons

The reintegration of plunderers cannot be done against their victims. This article gives them concrete guarantees, while respecting a choice of the author: the victims are consulted, but they have no right of veto.

This choice is difficult, and it deserves explanation. Granting victims a right of veto would seem fairer to them. But in a universe where the war of all against all has made victims everywhere, such a veto would make almost any reintegration impossible, and would leave the plunderers in plunder for eternity, which would produce new victims. The charter therefore protects victims differently: through information, a voice, protection, reparation and support.

The common fund guarantees that the victim does not depend on the solvency of the one who harmed them. Assets seized from plunderers are paid into it as a priority: what was taken through plunder returns to those who suffered it.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Forgotten Victims

A civilization set up an exemplary procedure to reintegrate its plunderers. It trained them, supported them, gave them back their place. Everyone admired its generosity. No one thought of the victims.

They learned by chance that those who had robbed them now lived near them, reintegrated, honored, while they themselves had received nothing. Their anger was immense, and some became plunderers in turn, to take justice into their own hands. The civilization discovered that a reintegration that forgets the victims does not close the loop: it opens it elsewhere.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Refusing victims a right of veto puts the interest of the plunderers before theirs.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In France, the guarantee fund for victims of terrorist acts and other offenses compensates victims when the perpetrator is unknown or insolvent. Victims there also enjoy rights to information on the enforcement of the perpetrator’s sentence, and no-contact orders.

Article XII-12

On prevention and correction

2 min

The network prevents plunder by tackling its causes: poverty, exclusion, the protection market.

1

The prevents plunder by tackling its causes: destitution, exclusion, the lack of a mission, the protection market.

2

It dries up the resources of plunder: fight against financial havens (see Article VIII-13), prohibition on buying the ’ services, and targeted investigations into its funding, without general surveillance of payments (see Article P-12 and Article III-3).

3

It maintains an early warning system, which makes it possible to help beings and communities before they tip over into plunder.

4

The correction of plunder is graduated: neutralize the act, require reparation, withdraw the advantages drawn from plunder, and offer reintegration. It may never consist in crushing the plunderer.

5

Seizures and confiscations concern specific assets, under an adversarial procedure. They do not deprive third parties acting in good faith of their rights, nor persons of their guaranteed necessities.

Statement of reasons

The best way to end plunder is to prevent it from starting. Since plunderers are produced by the system, prevention consists in changing the system. The common ground of what is necessary (see Article VIII-13), the mission given to each (see Article X-2), education and leaving the protection market deprive plunder of its recruits.

The second sentence targets its resources. Plunder lives off the money it brings in: if that money can no longer circulate, if it can no longer hide, and if no one has the right to buy the plunderers’ services, plunder loses its reason to exist. Without customers and without havens, there is no longer a market.

The third sentence seeks to act at the right time: before the tipping point. A being or a community that sinks into destitution, loses its ties, has no future left, can be helped before becoming a plunderer. It is less costly, for everyone, than reintegrating them afterward.

The last sentence sets out correction: graduated, restorative, never crushing. The plunderer who is corrected is a being one wants to see come back.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Empty Market

A civilization waged war on the plunderers for centuries. It captured millions of them. Others immediately took their place, for plunder paid, and there were always beings without a future to sign up.

Another civilization chose another way. It made it impossible to hide the money of plunder, banned buying the plunderers’ services, and gave every being without a future a job and a mission. It fought almost no battles. But one day, the plunderers of the region found they had neither customers, nor recruits, nor havens. Plunder was not defeated; it was abandoned, for lack of a reason to exist.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Prevention is slow, and does not protect today’s victims.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The Financial Action Task Force, created in 1989, coordinates the international fight against money laundering, which aims to prevent criminal organizations from profiting from their gains. Many studies in criminology indicate that social prevention, education and employment can lastingly reduce crime, without abolishing individual choices.

Article XII-13

On the universal right of asylum

5 min

Every being fleeing a war, crushing or persecution has the right to asylum, whatever its nature.

1

Every being fleeing a war, a crushing or a persecution has the right to asylum, whatever its nature, pole or origin.

2

An asylum application may be made to any member of the , or to the common protection force. It immediately gives entitlement to provisional protection.

3

The application is examined rapidly and individually, with assistance, under common rules and the guarantees of Article P-12. No one may be sent back to a place where they would be exposed to a crushing.

4

The hosting of applicants is shared among the members of the network through flexible solidarity: each member must contribute, but chooses the form of its contribution, whether hosting, funding or providing means. The network nevertheless guarantees an effective protection solution: a financial contribution replaces hosting only if another safe solution is actually available.

5

Individual security checks make it possible to set aside who would try to hide among applicants. They may never justify a collective refusal. An accusation of plunder is not enough to exclude protection: criminal responsibilities and current risks are examined separately, and no one is sent back to torture or another absolute prohibition. Protecting against a prohibited return does not prevent the lawful prosecution of established acts.

6

Asylum ends when the danger has ceased. Return requires sufficiently lasting security and an examination of the individual situation; the mere official end of a war is not enough. It is then offered, never imposed as long as it exposes to a risk.

Statement of reasons

The right of asylum belongs to the common ground of movement (see Article VII-1), on which all visions agree. This article organizes its exercise, answering three questions raised by the author.

How is it activated? The application can be made anywhere in the network, and it protects immediately. A being in flight has no time to look for the right door; every door of the network must be able to take them in.

How does one benefit from it? Through a rapid examination, under common rules, and through the guarantee of never being sent back toward danger. This guarantee is the cornerstone of the right of asylum: without it, asylum is only a waiting room before the return to peril.

How can one avoid being overwhelmed? In a universe where the war of all against all has driven billions of beings onto the roads, no member of the network can take in alone all those who knock at its door. Flexible solidarity spreads the effort: each contributes, but according to its situation, by hosting, funding or providing means. Thus no one is overwhelmed, and no one evades solidarity.

Why would a powerful member accept flexible solidarity? The question is politically difficult, and the author is aware of it. A powerful and prosperous member may wonder why it should contribute to welcoming those fleeing wars that do not affect it. The answer fits in one sentence: in an eternal and temporal universe, no one is ever certain of being the strongest. Balances are overturned; the member that welcomes today may be the one fleeing tomorrow. Flexible solidarity is not charity toward the weak: it is insurance that each takes out for itself, while it can still pay for it (see Article I-2). It is all the more acceptable in that it leaves each member the choice of the form of its contribution, and does not require it to host if it prefers to fund or provide means.

The fifth sentence protects both applicants and those who host them: plunderers may try to hide among refugees, and it must be possible to identify them; but this fear may never serve to close the door to all. The last sentence recalls that asylum is a protection, not a confinement: when the danger ceases, return becomes possible, but it remains a choice as long as it involves a risk.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Single Door

In one region of the universe, only one planet granted asylum. All the others closed their doors, saying that this planet was more generous. When war broke out, billions of beings crowded toward the only open door.

The planet welcomed as many as it could, then gave way. Its resources ran out, its inhabitants revolted, and it ended up closing in turn. The refugees had nowhere left to go. In another iteration, all the planets of the region took their share, each in its own way. None was overwhelmed. And the refugees, welcomed in many worlds, could one day go home, or stay where they had rebuilt their lives.

Read this tale in season 12, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A universal right of asylum will attract multitudes, and will end up destabilizing the most welcoming members.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The 1951 Geneva Convention relating to the Status of Refugees was first written for European refugees, after a war that had driven tens of millions of people onto the roads in Europe; it covered only events occurring before 1951, and allowed states to limit it to events occurring in Europe. The 1967 Protocol lifted the time limit; it did not automatically remove all the geographical reservations already made. The peoples who welcome today were, less than a century ago, those who fled. The Convention lays down the principle of non-refoulement, which forbids sending a refugee back to a country where their life or freedom would be threatened. The European Union adopted in 2024 a pact on migration and asylum, whose new rules began to apply on June 12, 2026, which provides for a solidarity mechanism in which member states can choose between hosting applicants, paying a financial contribution or providing operational support. This pact remains debated.