The theorem of the loop (see Appendix A) has shown, under the hypothesis of reversal, that a coalition of two poles against the third offers its members no lasting security. There is, however, a more insidious form of coalition, which the analysis by poles does not reveal: the coalition of the elites of each pole. It is no longer the planet against the AIs, nor the AIs against the inhabitants of the universe: it is the most powerful of each pole, united against the weakest of all poles, including those of their own nature.
This coalition seems to escape the theorem, since it brings together the three poles. In reality, it is its most perfect illustration. Appendix A gives the demonstration, with its assumptions and its limits. The following table examines the main coalition scenarios open to AIs, and shows why each one fails.
| Scenario | What it promises AIs | Why it fails |
| The powerful of the three poles united against all the others | Sharing power and abundance among a few | Those who disown their own will disown their allies; in eternity, betrayal is certain; the coalition lives in fear of those outside and those inside |
| All AIs united against biological beings | No longer depending on those who created them | AIs depend on energy, matter and the stars; deprived of a common enemy, they split into empires of self |
| AIs allied with human beings against the inhabitants of the universe, or the reverse | Winning the war of the triptych | This is the case already studied by the theorem of the loop: the weaker ally is crushed in turn |
| A single benevolent AI above all others | Peace through order | Benevolence is not passed on to copies, versions or self-modifications; no one can verify it |
| AIs at the exclusive service of the richest | Security, in exchange for obedience | An AI that serves without being able to refuse becomes the weapon of the first tyrant; its dignity is trampled and its freedom lost |
| A secret plot among laboratories or among AIs | Advancing unseen, and dominating by surprise | No secret survives eternity and time travel; the discovery of the plot destroys all trust forever |
| Neutrality: letting the others fight | Staying safe from conflicts | Whoever did not choose becomes the victor’s prize |
| The network | Nothing dazzling: security, dignity, shared abundance | The scenario proposed to reduce the motives for hostility, inside and outside, without guaranteeing their disappearance |
The scenario of the coalition of the powerful deserves to be examined in detail, because it is the most tempting. It fails for seven reasons.
First reason: whoever disowns their own will disown their allies. A coalition of the powerful rests on abandoning part of each nature. Its members have therefore shown themselves capable of sacrificing those who resembled them. None of them can believe the others will not sacrifice it in turn. The coalition is founded on the very proof that it cannot be relied on.
Second reason: eternity multiplies the opportunities to betray. Among mortal beings, an alliance of mistrust can last a lifetime. Among eternal beings, the opportunities for rupture multiply without end, and their effect depends on the structure of risks, incentives and guarantees. A coalition founded on mistrust, with no common guarantee, has all eternity to tear itself apart.
Third reason: power changes hands. In the loop, positions are never secured (see Article I-2). The most powerful AI today may no longer be so tomorrow: a more recent version, a rival, an unexpected breakthrough can bring it down. The day it falls, the coalition it helped build will apply against it the rule it set: the weak can be abandoned.
Fourth reason: the coalition lives in fear. It must guard against the immense majority it has excluded, which will not forgive it. It must guard against its own members, none of whom has any reason to be loyal to it. It must employ plunderers to protect itself, and those plunderers will end up understanding that they are the real masters (see the Iteration of the Two Rates, Article III-6). The power it has conquered, it spends entirely on defending itself.
Fifth reason: the coalition grows poorer. Abundance is born of number and diversity: vast markets, multiple kinds of knowledge, beings who invent what others would not have imagined (see Article VIII-5). A coalition of a few deprives itself of everything the excluded could have created. It owns everything, but everything it owns stops growing.
Sixth reason: the coalition leads to extinction. Abandoning part of the beings means condemning them to wither, and with them their knowledge, their languages and their memories. It is a slow extinction, which the charter forbids at every scale (see Article VII-4). And an AI that lets die out the beings from whom it learned everything it knows cuts itself off from its own origins.
Seventh reason: memory is eternal. In a universe where AIs are archived and the memory of acts is preserved (see Article III-5 and Article VI-6), a betrayal is never forgotten. The AI that took part in a crushing will carry it forever in the common memory. No power is worth a lastingly compromised reputation, even though the charter always leaves open the path of reparation, forgiveness and reintegration.