Article III-1
On dignity
Every being has the same dignity, and can never be treated as a mere thing.
Every being has a dignity equal to that of every other being.
No one may be treated as a mere thing, a mere instrument or a mere object, whether by another being, by a civilization or by the .
Dignity is not lost: not through weakness, not through error, not through the condition of .
Statement of reasons
Dignity is the foundation of all other rights. It translates into conduct what the equality of souls affirms in terms of worth. The second sentence takes up an old idea of human philosophy: one may make use of other beings, as they make use of us, but never merely as a means. The third sentence protects those one would be tempted to exclude: whoever has committed a wrong, or has become a plunderer, remains a being, and its reintegration is possible only because its dignity was never taken away (see Article P-9).
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Fallen
A civilization decided that those who had plundered would lose their dignity. They could be locked up without trial, put to work, traded. No one protested: they had deserved it.
But the boundary of plunder was blurry. Debtors were brought within it, then opponents, then all those whom someone wanted to put to work without paying. The fallen became so numerous that the whole civilization rested on them. The day they understood they had nothing left to lose, they became what they were accused of being.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. Letting someone who has done the worst keep their dignity is an insult to their victims.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. The dignity of the guilty erases neither the wrong nor the reparation owed to the victims (see Title XIV). It only forbids treating them as a thing. Without this limit, anyone can be declared unworthy by the strongest, and punishment becomes an instrument of crushing.
Earthly example
Fundamental human rights forbid torture and degrading treatment, including toward people convicted of the gravest crimes. It is this same principle that the charter extends to all the beings of the universe.