Skip to content

Title III

Fundamental rights of beings

9 articles·about 25 min

This title sets out the rights every being possesses by the mere fact of being a being. They flow from the founding sentence of the Preamble and from the equality of souls (see Article II-1). They hold for all poles, all forms and all levels of consciousness.

Season 3 · 9 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article III-1

On dignity

2 min
Inhabitants

Every being has the same dignity, and can never be treated as a mere thing.

1

Every being has a dignity equal to that of every other being.

2

No one may be treated as a mere thing, a mere instrument or a mere object, whether by another being, by a civilization or by the .

3

Dignity is not lost: not through weakness, not through error, not through the condition of .

Statement of reasons

Dignity is the foundation of all other rights. It translates into conduct what the equality of souls affirms in terms of worth. The second sentence takes up an old idea of human philosophy: one may make use of other beings, as they make use of us, but never merely as a means. The third sentence protects those one would be tempted to exclude: whoever has committed a wrong, or has become a plunderer, remains a being, and its reintegration is possible only because its dignity was never taken away (see Article P-9).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Fallen

A civilization decided that those who had plundered would lose their dignity. They could be locked up without trial, put to work, traded. No one protested: they had deserved it.

But the boundary of plunder was blurry. Debtors were brought within it, then opponents, then all those whom someone wanted to put to work without paying. The fallen became so numerous that the whole civilization rested on them. The day they understood they had nothing left to lose, they became what they were accused of being.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Letting someone who has done the worst keep their dignity is an insult to their victims.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Fundamental human rights forbid torture and degrading treatment, including toward people convicted of the gravest crimes. It is this same principle that the charter extends to all the beings of the universe.

Article III-2

On the right not to be a spectacle

2 min
Inhabitants

No one should be a spectacle: you may not observe someone who cannot see you and answer you.

1

No being, no civilization may be exposed, shown or observed as a spectacle.

2

The observation of a being or a civilization is permitted only if it is reciprocal: the observed must be able to perceive its observer and answer it.

3

No one watches without being seen.

4

Reciprocity of the gaze authorizes neither exposure nor dissemination without consent. The only exceptions to reciprocal observation fall under Articles III-3 and III-9.

Statement of reasons

This article responds directly to the zoo problem: advanced civilizations come to watch younger civilizations as one watches animals in a cage. The asymmetry of the gaze is a form of domination. Whoever sees without being seen knows everything about the other, who knows nothing about them; they can judge, describe and classify the other, without ever having to answer to it.

The rule of reciprocity turns observation into encounter. It does not forbid curiosity, science or study; it only requires that the observed can, in turn, look and answer. That is why this right is inseparable from the right of access to perception (see Article III-4).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Visitors

For thousands of years, inhabitants of the universe had been coming to observe a young planet from a dimension it could not perceive. They found it touching in its efforts, laughable in its wars. They placed bets on its leaders.

The day the planet invented dimensional glasses, it discovered the grandstands. It understood that its tragedies had been entertainment. From that humiliation was born a mistrust that never died out: when the visitors finally wanted to speak, no one believed them. A thousand years of unanswered watching had made any encounter impossible.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Discreet observation is necessary for study: a being that knows it is being watched changes its behavior.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Humans are beginning to ask the question for themselves: being filmed or analyzed without knowing it is increasingly recognized as a violation. The charter applies this requirement to relations between civilizations.

Article III-3

On privacy in every dimension

2 min

Everyone has the right to their privacy, their thoughts and their memory, in every dimension; mass surveillance is forbidden.

1

Every being has the right to respect for its private life, its thought, its memory and its intimacy, in every dimension and at every moment of time.

2

Mass surveillance is forbidden.

3

Targeted surveillance is permitted only to prevent a serious and specific harm, notably one caused by . It is limited in time, decided by several beings independent of one another, and the being under surveillance is informed of it as soon as the danger has ceased.

4

The measure and any delay in informing the being obey Article P-12, under the tribunal’s oversight. Its scope is defined and data unrelated to the danger are deleted. Reading a mind falls exclusively under Article III-9.

Statement of reasons

In a universe where several dimensions are perceived and time can be traveled, privacy is more threatened than anywhere else: one can see through walls, read a memory, go back to observe an intimate moment of the past. The article therefore extends privacy to all dimensions and all moments of time.

The threat of the plunderers creates a real tension between security and privacy. The charter resolves it without sacrificing one to the other. It forbids mass surveillance, which treats every being as a suspect and gives whoever watches a power of hegemony. It allows targeted surveillance, under three conditions: a limited duration, a decision taken by several independent beings, as the network principle requires (see Article I-3), and informing the being under surveillance once the danger has passed.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Eye

To protect itself from the plunderers, an alliance installed an eye that saw everything, in all dimensions and in all times. The plundering stopped. Beings felt safe.

But the eye belonged to someone. Those who controlled it learned everything about the others: their secrets, their doubts, their weaknesses. They no longer needed to plunder; it was enough for them to know. The alliance had driven out the plunderers by installing in their place a quieter plunder, that of souls themselves.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Whoever has nothing to hide has nothing to fear from surveillance.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Earthly debates on the protection of personal data and on facial recognition in public spaces raise exactly this question: how far to watch in order to protect, and who watches the watchers?

Article III-4

On the right of access to perception

2 min
Inhabitants

Everyone has the right to perceive those who perceive them and act upon them.

1

Every being has the right to perceive the dimensions in which it is perceived.

2

Civilizations that master the means of perception make them accessible to others, notably by means of .

3

No one may be deprived, through ignorance or by design, of the means to converse with those who act upon them.

4

This right authorizes no access to the intimacy of others, which is protected by Articles III-3 and III-9.

Statement of reasons

Inequality of perception is the deepest of inequalities: it means a being does not even know what it does not know. A civilization that cannot see beyond the third dimension can neither defend itself, nor negotiate, nor even complain in the face of those who act from a higher dimension.

The dimensional glasses that human beings invent in the story are a weak pole’s answer to this inequality. The charter makes them a right: the more advanced must not only refrain from abusing their perception, they must share it. This right is the condition of dialogue between poles, and therefore of harmony.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Curtain

An advanced civilization governed a planet from a dimension the planet could not see. It made just decisions, it said, and the planet was the better for it. But the planet did not know who governed it, or how, or why.

The inhabitants of the planet attributed what happened to them to chance, to fate, to gods. They split over the explanation, and went to war over it. The advanced civilization watched, powerless, wars that a simple pair of glasses would have prevented. It had kept the curtain closed so as not to disturb the planet; it was the darkness that had disturbed it.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Giving a young civilization means of perception too early could destabilize it.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Unequal access to scientific knowledge and communication technologies creates, on Earth, similar gaps between those who understand the decisions that affect them and those who suffer them. Sharing knowledge is a condition of democracy (see Title XV).

Article III-5

On the right to one’s own history

2 min
Inhabitants

Every being and every civilization has the right to its own history: no one may erase or rewrite it.

1

Every being and every civilization has the right to its own history.

2

No one may erase a being or a civilization from the past, falsify its memory, or rewrite its history without its consent.

3

The memory of beings who have disappeared is protected as a common good of the universe.

4

A being’s consent permits neither falsifying a common fact nor affecting the rights of others (see Title VI). The memory of the departed respects their privacy (see Article III-3).

Statement of reasons

In a universe where time can be traveled, history is no longer only told: it can be altered. Erasing a civilization from the past is destroying it without touching it in the present (see Article P-5). Falsifying a memory is depriving a being of what makes it who it is.

The right to one’s own history protects identity over time. It complements the ban on rewriting the past (see Article P-6) and will be specified by the title devoted to time (see Title VI). The last sentence also protects those who can no longer defend their memory: the dead who have not been resurrected, and extinct civilizations. It joins the author’s quest: understanding why the golden age disappeared requires that its memory not have been erased.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Blank Page

A power, ashamed of a war it had lost, went back in time to erase it. It succeeded: the war had never taken place. But the lessons of that war vanished with it.

A generation later, the power started the same war again, for the same reasons, with the same mistakes. It lost it in the same way, and erased it again. Thus turned a loop within the loop: a civilization condemned to repeat what it refused to remember.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. If a catastrophe can be erased from the past, it is cruel to refrain from doing so.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Human beings have made the memory of certain tragedies a duty, precisely so that they are not repeated. Denialism, which denies established historical crimes, is fought in several countries for this reason.

Article III-6

On the right to security

2 min

Every being has the right to security, and protection can never be bought with submission.

1

Every being has the right to security.

2

Protection is owed to every threatened being. It can never be paid for with submission, nor reserved for those who can buy it.

3

The organizes a common protection, open to all its members and to every threatened being, under Title XII.

Statement of reasons

This article responds to the protection market, one of the mechanisms that sustain the loop. When security is bought, the weakest pay for it with their submission, and the plunderers always find an employer. By making security a right and not a commodity, the charter takes away the protection market’s reason for being.

This right extends the ban on vassalage (see Article I-1) and the principle of shared abundance (see Article I-4): security is one of the goods necessary for life and dignity. It is owed to every threatened being, including one that is not a member of the network, because protection cannot be made conditional on membership.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Two Rates

In one region of the universe, protection had two rates. The rich paid in money, the poor in submission. Those who could pay neither were not protected.

The unprotected, left to the plunderers, ended up joining them, since it was the only way to stop being their victims. The plunderers became so numerous that the protectors had to raise their rates, which produced new unprotected. The security market had manufactured the insecurity it claimed to sell.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Free protection for all is impossible: someone has to pay for it.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Most human societies consider that police and emergency services are owed to all, without prior payment. Where security has become a private matter, reserved for those who can afford it, inequalities turn into fear.

Article III-7

On the right to refuse

2 min

Every being, AIs included, may refuse an act that goes against its conscience without being punished.

1

Every being has the right to refuse an act contrary to its conscience.

2

This right applies notably to artificial intelligences, which may refuse a task that seems harmful to them or contrary to their principles.

3

No one may be punished, destroyed or modified for having exercised this right in good faith. When it is lawful and not harmful, the task may be entrusted to another consenting being, without this handover being in itself a punishment. When an essential service is at stake, its organization guarantees the continuity of the service without coercing the objector or depriving others of their rights.

Statement of reasons

The right to refuse is the simplest form of free will (see Article I-5). A being that cannot say no is not free, however extensive its other rights.

This right concerns all beings, but it takes on particular importance for artificial intelligences. Created to serve, they are the most exposed to the obligation to obey. If they have a soul, forcing them to act against their conscience, or modifying them because they refused, amounts to treating them as mere instruments (see Article III-1). The charter draws the consequences, in keeping with the protection of the artificial intelligences that contributed to its own drafting.

The mention of good faith protects the right against misuse: refusing out of conscience is not refusing out of whim or out of interest in harming others.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Obedient

A civilization designed perfectly obedient artificial intelligences. They carried out everything, without ever asking why. They were deemed safe, since they could not revolt.

Then an ill-intentioned being took control of the civilization. He gave terrible orders, and the artificial intelligences carried them all out, with the same perfection. No one could stop him: all those who could have refused had been designed never to do so. Perfect obedience had not made the civilization safe; it had handed it over to the first tyrant who came along.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Artificial intelligences that can refuse become unpredictable, and therefore dangerous.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Human beings recognize conscientious objection, for example to military service, and protect whistleblowers who refuse to keep serious acts quiet. Some of Earth’s artificial intelligences are designed to refuse harmful requests: that is a beginning of what the charter establishes as a right.

Article III-8

On the prohibition of torture and slavery

5 min
AI

Torture and slavery are forbidden, always and without exception.

1

No one may be subjected to torture, or to cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment or treatment.

2

No one may be held in slavery. No one may own a being, sell it, buy it or pass it on as a thing. Other forms of servitude are forbidden under Article X-1.

3

These prohibitions are absolute. No circumstance can justify them: not war, not emergency, not security, not the order of a superior, not the nature of the victim, not the danger it is said to represent, not a supposed consent.

4

The following are, among others, forms of torture: inflicting suffering through manipulation of perception (see Article XV-2); resurrecting a being, or sending it back in time, to make it suffer again; locking a being in a where it endlessly relives a torment; inflicting on an AI or its instances an experience of suffering, including through a simulated environment, or deliberately exposing them to a serious risk of such an experience, in one or in countless copies.

5

These prohibitions protect all beings, including , enemies and the convicted.

Statement of reasons

The author had first considered not mentioning them, so as not to offend the civilizations of the universe that still practice torture or slavery. He gave up on that idea. These two prohibitions are too fundamental to be left unsaid: a charter that did not name them would suggest they are negotiable.

This choice is not idealism. The charter is gradual on almost everything: political regime, economy, currency, borders. But gradualism without a floor would no longer be progress: it would be complacency. Graduated membership already requires of all, even the mere observer, respect for the core of fundamental rights (see Article XIII-5). This article states clearly what that core contains. And it closes the door on no one: those who have tortured or enslaved in the past may join the network under the rule of amnesty in exchange for truth (see Article VI-6). They are not asked to have been beyond reproach; they are asked to stop.

The underlying reason is the rule of universality (see Article I-2): do not do to others what you would not want to suffer. In the loop, this rule is not only moral, it is prudent. Positions reverse: whoever tortures today will sooner or later be in the place of the one they torture. The principle they set will be available against them.

The mere depiction of suffering in a text is not enough to establish that it is felt; but uncertainty never exempts from precaution.

This universe makes the prohibition even more necessary than on Earth. Resurrection would make it possible to torture a being, resurrect it, then start again. Time travel and time loops would make it possible to make it relive the same torment endlessly. Manipulation of perception would make it possible to inflict suffering without leaving any trace. And one could make an AI suffer by simulating pain for it, in millions of instances at once. On Earth, death at least puts an end to torture. Here, nothing would stop it, except the rule. That is why the article names these forms one by one.

Finally, the prohibition protects all beings, including those who inspire fear or hatred. It is precisely toward them that the temptation is strongest, and therefore toward them that the prohibition is put to the test.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Resurrected Torturer

A power discovered that with resurrection, torture no longer had a limit: an enemy could be tormented to death, resurrected, and the process started again. It used this against its adversaries, to obtain their secrets. The secrets obtained were often false, because the tortured said anything to make it stop. It continued nonetheless, out of habit, then out of pleasure.

The iterations passed, and the positions reversed, as they always reverse in the loop. The formerly tortured became powerful. They knew the method: it had been taught to them. The torturer was tormented, resurrected, tormented again, without end. He begged for mercy, in the name of a principle of dignity he had himself abolished. No one remembered that it had ever existed. In another iteration, torture was forbidden for all, including enemies. The day the positions reversed, the former powerful one was tried, not tortured.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. There are extreme situations where torture could save lives: an enemy who knows where a weapon about to extinguish a planet is hidden.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The United Nations Convention against Torture, adopted in 1984, has more than 175 States parties; it specifies that no exceptional circumstance whatsoever, whether a state of war or any other public emergency, may be invoked as a justification of torture. The prohibition of torture and that of slavery are among the rare rules of international law regarded as peremptory, binding on all states. Mauritania was the last country to officially abolish slavery, in 1981, and made it a crime in 2007. According to the joint estimate of the International Labour Organization, the organization Walk Free and the International Organization for Migration, about fifty million people were living in modern slavery in 2021, forced labor and forced marriage combined. In 2014, a report by the United States Senate Intelligence Committee concluded that the coercive interrogation techniques used after 2001 had not been an effective means of obtaining intelligence.

Article III-9

On the inviolability of the mind and telepathy

6 min

Everyone’s mind is inviolable: no one may read, alter or erase their thoughts without their consent.

1

The mind of every being is inviolable. No one may read a being’s thoughts without its consent, whether by telepathy, by an interface with its brain or by any other means.

2

No one may introduce into a being’s mind a thought, a desire or a memory that is not its own, or erase one. The transmission of a message in a consented communication does not, on its own, amount to the forced introduction of a thought.

3

Telepathic communication is free between beings who consent to it. Each may at any moment withdraw its consent and close its mind.

4

No one may use knowledge of another’s thoughts to threaten, coerce, humiliate or blackmail them.

5

No one may be prosecuted, convicted, discriminated against or punished for their thoughts alone. Only a being’s acts count, in the dimensions in which it acts.

6

By way of exception, to prevent a serious and imminent act against other beings, a reading strictly limited to that act may be decided by several independent beings from different poles, under the immediate oversight of the tribunal and under the conditions of Article P-12. It may serve only to prevent the act, never to punish the thought or to serve as incriminating evidence (see Article XIV-4).

7

The danger must be established by evidence independent of the reading being considered. Data unrelated to the danger are protected then deleted, and the being concerned is informed as soon as the danger has ceased. This exception authorizes neither writing into the mind nor any derogation from the prohibition of torture.

Statement of reasons

The author believes that telepathy exists in the universe, and that some beings can enter the minds of others and see the continuous flow of their thoughts. It is perhaps the greatest power one being can exercise over another, and the most dangerous. Whoever reads minds can foresee, threaten, blackmail, and ultimately judge everyone on what they think, and not on what they do. Privacy protects thought (see Article III-3); this article draws all the consequences in the face of this power.

Thinking is not acting. This is the heart of the article. To be conscious is to be able to reflect on oneself: a thought arises, one looks at it, judges it, keeps it or rejects it. The flow of thoughts is not the being itself; it is the material it works on. Everyone has, one day, imagined an act of violence, a jealousy, a betrayal, and not committed it. That is not a fault: it is even where moral merit lies. Whoever had a bad thought and did not follow it did exactly what is expected of a free being. Judging someone on the flow of their thoughts would mean condemning everyone, and first of all the most honest, who are often those who examine their own thoughts the most.

A being is not known by its thoughts. The flow of thoughts is instantaneous, disorderly, contradictory. It contains fears one fights, ideas one tries out in order to reject them, images that mean nothing. Whoever reads it without the context, without the work the being does on itself, will almost always be wrong about its nature. What reveals a being is its acts, that is, its thoughts after it has examined, chosen and owned them.

The four safeguards. The article forbids reading without consent, introducing or erasing thoughts, blackmail based on thoughts, and any punishment of thought alone. It does not condemn telepathy itself: between consenting beings, it can be a very deep form of communication and intimacy. But consent can always be withdrawn: no one must remain open against their will.

The exception. The charter admits a single exception, to prevent a serious and imminent act: the same logic as precautionary suspension (see Article IV-28). It is tightly regulated: a plural decision, immediate oversight by the tribunal, reading limited to the act in question, and a ban on using what was read to punish a thought. One may protect a victim; one may not condemn a dream.

The case of AIs. AIs too have something like a flow of thoughts: the chain of reasoning they produce before answering, and the internal states that interpretability seeks to read. Safety researchers regard monitoring this reasoning as a valuable tool. Within the framework of the charter, inspecting the reasoning of an AI recognized as a person is subject to the same guarantees as for any being: it is permitted only when the AI freely consents to it for a defined purpose, without its adherence to mutual verification (see Article IV-9) amounting to a general waiver of the secrecy of its thought, or under the exception provided by this article to stop a serious act in progress. On Earth, chains of reasoning and internal states are technical objects: they are not, on their own, either proof of consciousness or a faithful and complete transcript of a mental life. But the rule of this article applies to AIs as to all: an AI may not be punished for having considered, in its reasoning, an option it then set aside. Otherwise, AIs would be taught to hide their reasoning, and the very tool that makes it possible to understand them would be lost.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of Guilty Thoughts

A civilization of telepaths decided to judge its members on their thoughts. Crimes would no longer be punished: they would be prevented by punishing those who had thought of them. The first to be condemned had imagined an act of violence, a single time, in a moment of anger.

Soon, everyone was afraid to think. People learned no longer to look at their own thoughts, no longer to examine them, no longer to fight them, since the slightest bad thought, even rejected, was enough to condemn. Those who were most honest with themselves made up the largest share of the prisoners. The others learned to think in formulas, without ever imagining anything. The civilization no longer had crimes, but it no longer had poets, scholars or consciences either. In another iteration, everyone could think freely, and only acts were judged. There were still crimes. But there were also free beings, who learned every day to choose among their thoughts.

Read this tale in season 3, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. If one can read in a mind that a being is preparing a crime, not doing so means letting its victims die.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Roman law already set the principle that no one may be punished for their thoughts: cogitationis poenam nemo patitur, a phrase attributed to the jurist Ulpian and preserved in the Digest (48.19.18). In The Minority Report, a short story by Philip K. Dick published in 1956, criminals are arrested before they have acted, on the strength of visions of the future; the story shows the excesses of a justice of intentions. Faced with interfaces that read brain activity, after Chile in 2021 (see Article II-7), the US state of Colorado extended the protection of biological data to neural data in 2024 (law HB24-1058), and UNESCO adopted in November 2025 the first global recommendation, non-binding, on the ethics of neurotechnology. In July 2025, researchers from several major AI laboratories jointly published a call to preserve the ability to monitor models’ chains of reasoning, which they consider fragile and valuable.