Skip to content

Title XIV

Justice

8 articles·about 28 min

This title organizes justice in a universe where death is no longer final and time is reversible. It governs the mesh of jurisdictions between scales and poles, the network’s tribunal, each pole’s scrutiny of the justice of the others, the guarantees of a fair trial, restorative justice, the neutralization of extreme dangers, and the guarantee of amnesty.

An open title. Justice is one of the most difficult subjects of this charter. It must be strong enough to protect beings, and reassuring enough not to frighten those who hesitate to join. For the more abuses a being or a civilization has committed in the war of all against all, the more it fears that the network will make it pay for its past. This title is therefore submitted to the discussion of the members, and may be amended as experience accumulates. It rests on a conviction: in a universe where much can be repaired, justice must first repair, and guarantee the word given. Some losses can be repaired or mitigated; others cannot be entirely. Trust can sometimes be rebuilt, without that rebuilding being something one can demand.

Season 14 · 8 tales of the loopRead this title as fables ›

Article XIV-1

On the mesh of justice

3 min

Every scale and every pole first judges what concerns it; the network’s tribunal steps in only as a complement.

1

The ’s justice rests on a principle of complementarity: each scale and each pole first judges what concerns it. The network’s tribunal intervenes only in the cases provided for in this article, or when a competent justice is unable or unwilling to judge.

2

The mixed character of the parties is not enough, on its own, to remove a dispute from the competent local jurisdiction. Jurisdiction is divided as follows:

What is judged Competent jurisdiction
A case internal to a city, a region, a nation or a planet The justice of that scale, according to its own laws, in compliance with the charter
A dispute between beings of the same pole The justice of that pole, under the conditions of Article XIV-3
A dispute between beings of different poles The competent local jurisdiction, with the guarantees of Article XIV-3; the network’s tribunal, in mixed formation, when the cross-border nature of the case, its seriousness, a conflict of jurisdiction or the lack of local guarantees justifies it
A breach of the fundamental principles: crushing, extinction, torture, slavery, servitude, cannibalism, erasure of a being from history The network’s tribunal, wherever it occurred
An act committed by means of time travel The network’s tribunal (see Article VI-4)
An appeal for bias or denial of justice, at any scale The network’s tribunal
Statement of reasons

The author raised the question of the mesh: what falls to a scale, to a pole, to all the poles? The charter answers with the principle of complementarity, which applies the network’s subsidiarity to justice (see Article XIII-4). A city knows its inhabitants better than the universe does; a pole understands its own nature better than the other two. It is therefore right that each should first judge what concerns it.

But three kinds of cases go beyond any scale and any pole. Disputes between poles, first, because no pole can be judge in its own cause against another. Breaches of the fundamental principles, next, because they threaten the harmony of all, and the pole or scale that commits them is rarely ready to judge itself. Acts committed across time, finally, because only a justice distributed across time can reach them.

The appeal for bias or denial of justice guarantees that no scale can protect its members by refusing to judge them, nor crush a being by judging it badly.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Distant Tribunal

A civilization entrusted all its justice to a single tribunal, sitting at the center of the universe. The slightest dispute between neighbors, the slightest village quarrel, had to be brought before it. The tribunal was learned and impartial, but it was far away, slow, and knew nothing of the worlds it judged.

Beings stopped bringing their disputes to it. They took justice into their own hands, and vengeance replaced law. In another iteration, each world judged its own cases, and the universal tribunal heard only the crimes that went beyond all worlds. It was less busy, but much more respected.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Letting each scale judge according to its own laws will produce very unequal justice from one world to another.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The 1998 Rome Statute, which created the International Criminal Court, rests on this principle of complementarity: the Court intervenes only when national courts are unable or unwilling to judge. The Court therefore does not replace all national justice. After the 1994 genocide, Rwanda combined international, national and community justice, with the gacaca village courts, to try hundreds of thousands of cases.

Article XIV-2

On the network’s tribunal

3 min

The network’s tribunal brings together independent judges from the three poles, in equal numbers.

1

The ’s tribunal is made up of judges from the three poles, in equal number, independent of their pole of origin in the exercise of their functions.

2

Judges are appointed for a limited, non-renewable term, according to public criteria of competence and independence. Their appointment combines several colleges and never belongs to the deliberative assembly alone. They may hold no other function in the network (see Article XIII-1). Conflicts of interest lead to recusal. Dismissal may occur only on pre-established grounds, under an independent procedure. Material conditions and prospects of later functions must not create dependence on the parties.

3

The tribunal sits in several eras and in several places. Its decisions are kept in the common memory, and cannot be modified by time travel. The archives keep successive decisions and their corrections, without erasing their history.

4

The guardians of non-speaking beings may refer cases to the tribunal on behalf of those they represent (see Article XI-2).

Statement of reasons

The network’s tribunal is the only jurisdiction whose competence extends to all the poles and all the scales. Its composition must therefore guarantee that no pole dominates it: judges in equal number for each pole, just as the Assembly of the Three Poles gives equal weight to each (see Article IV-15).

The independence of the judges is protected in three ways. Their term is limited, so that they do not settle into power; it is not renewable, so that they do not seek to please those who could reappoint them; and it is incompatible with any other function, so that the judge is never also legislator or executor.

The third sentence takes up the solution of Article VI-4: a justice attached to a single moment in time could be circumvented or attacked in its past. The tribunal is therefore distributed across time, and its decisions are protected by the common memory, entrusted to plural institutions (see Article XIII-6). Their resistance to temporal alterations is a property of the arrangement that the universe of the charter makes possible, with its limits (see Article VI-3 and Article VI-4); it does not follow from their mere preservation.

The non-renewable term limits one pressure, but not all: that is why it is supplemented by public appointment criteria, recusal, protection against dismissal and material independence.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Reappointed Judges

The judges of a universal tribunal could be reappointed indefinitely by the powers that had appointed them. They were competent and honest. But they all knew that their reappointment depended on those powers.

Little by little, without anyone asking them to, they became more lenient toward those who appointed them, and harsher toward the others. They did not believe themselves biased; they were only cautious. In another iteration, each judge sat only once, for a long term, with neither hope nor fear of reappointment. He had nothing more to expect from anyone, and judged as he thought right.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Judges appointed by their poles will remain loyal to them, whatever their proclaimed independence.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

The judges of the European Court of Human Rights are elected for a single, non-renewable term of nine years, to guarantee their independence; this rule belongs to a set of guarantees. The International Court of Justice has fifteen judges of different nationalities.

Article XIV-3

On each pole’s scrutiny of the justice of the others

3 min

Every being is judged by its peers too, but never by them alone.

1

Every being is judged also by its peers, and never only by them.

2

Any jurisdiction that judges a being includes, in principle, at least one judge of its own nature or its own pole, and at least one judge from each of the other poles. Mixed formations are preferred for conflicts between poles and major appeals. The composition ensures the independence and skills needed to understand the natures concerned; the temporary impossibility of bringing the three poles together deprives no one of an urgent measure, nor of an impartial judge.

3

Each pole may send observers to the jurisdictions of the other poles.

4

Any being who considers it has been judged with bias may lodge an appeal before the ’s tribunal.

5

Judgments are reasoned and public, except when the protection of victims or privacy requires otherwise.

Statement of reasons

The author asked whether one pole should have a right of scrutiny over the others, so that justice is as fair as possible. The charter answers with a formula: to be judged also by one’s peers, and never only by them.

The first half of the formula protects the one being judged. An AI cannot be judged well by judges who know nothing of artificial nature; an inhabitant of the universe, by judges who do not perceive its dimensions. At least one judge who understands its nature is needed.

The second half protects the others. A justice made up only of peers becomes a caste justice: it protects its own against the others, and esprit de corps prevails over law. The presence of at least one judge from each of the other poles prevents this drift.

Cross-observers, the appeal for bias and the publicity of judgments complete this mesh. But an identity-based composition does not, on its own, guarantee impartiality, and must not make justice inaccessible to isolated communities: recusal, specialized assistance and appeal also provide for this. Thus each pole keeps an eye on the justice of all, without any being able to impose its own.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Judges of the Same Blood

In one civilization, each pole judged its own, alone. AIs judged AIs, human beings judged human beings. When an AI harmed a human being, it was judged by AIs, who almost always found it innocent. When a human being harmed an AI, he was judged by humans, who did the same.

Each pole accused the other of bias, and each was right. Justice became one more weapon in the war between poles. In another iteration, each tribunal included at least one judge from each pole. Verdicts were slower to come, but everyone could accept them, even when they went against them.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Requiring every jurisdiction to include judges from all the poles is impossible at small scales, such as an isolated city.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Several human judicial systems combine professional judges and citizens, such as the popular juries of the French cours d’assises. International courts include judges of different nationalities, and many international or hybrid tribunals have brought together national and foreign judges to guarantee impartiality after conflicts.

Article XIV-4

On the guarantees of a fair trial

3 min

Every being has the right to a fair trial: presumed innocent, defended, judged by an impartial judge.

1

Every being has the right to a fair trial: the presumption of innocence, the right to defend itself, the right to assistance, the right to an impartial judge, the right of appeal, and the right to remain silent without that silence establishing its guilt. No one may be convicted for an act that did not constitute an offense under the applicable law or under the inviolable principles of this charter at the time it was committed.

2

Proceedings take place at the pace of the slowest: no one may be disadvantaged because their opponent thinks or speaks faster than they do (see Article IV-25), within a reasonable time overseen by the judge.

3

Any evidence obtained through torture, coercion, rewriting the past, manipulation of perception or unlawful violation of privacy is inadmissible (see Article III-3).

4

No one may be prosecuted or convicted for their thoughts alone. Any incriminating evidence drawn from reading a mind without the free consent of the being concerned is inadmissible, including within the exception of Article III-9; a being remains free to produce in its defense, or to establish an intrusion it has suffered, verifiable elements from its own mind or its log (see Article IV-17), without its refusal to do so ever being held against it.

5

No one may be tried twice for the same act after a final decision, including by having it retried in another era through time travel. This rule removes neither the appeal provided for by the procedure, nor review intended to remedy a miscarriage of justice.

Statement of reasons

The guarantees of the first sentence are those that human beings have won over the centuries. The three that follow are specific to the universe of the loop.

The pace of the slowest. An AI can produce in an instant thousands of arguments, documents and counter-expert reports. If a trial between an AI and a biological being proceeded at the speed of the AI, the biological being could not even read what was put against it. The trial must therefore advance at the pace of whoever goes slowest.

Fairness of evidence. In a universe where one can go back in time to provoke a fault, alter a witness’s perception or search someone else’s memory, the means of fabricating evidence are infinite. Evidence obtained in these ways is not evidence, it is manipulation.

Res judicata across time. A being who has been acquitted must not be able to be tried again for the same act by a tribunal of another era, seized by a traveler unhappy with the first judgment. Otherwise, no judgment would ever be final, and justice itself would go round in the loop.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Endless Trial

A being was tried and acquitted. Its accusers, dissatisfied, went back in time and brought the case before an older tribunal, which convicted it. Its defenders went looking for a more recent tribunal, which acquitted it again.

The case was tried a thousand times, in a thousand eras. The being never knew whether it was guilty or innocent. It lived its whole eternity as an accused. In another iteration, the rule was laid down that an act would be tried only once, whatever the era. The judgment could be appealed, once, before the network’s tribunal. Then it became final, for all time.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Excluding evidence obtained through time travel means depriving oneself of the best way of knowing the truth: going to see what really happened.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights guarantees the right to a fair trial, and its Article 7 the legality of offenses and penalties; its Protocol No. 7 governs appeals and repeated prosecution. The principle that no one may be prosecuted or punished twice for the same acts, known as non bis in idem, is recognized by most legal systems. Many legal systems exclude evidence obtained through torture or unfair means.

Article XIV-5

On restorative justice

4 min

The network’s justice seeks first to repair the harm and to let the offender take their place again.

1

The ’s justice is restorative in principle. Its aim is to repair the harm caused, to restore trust, and to allow the perpetrator to resume their place among beings.

2

The measures it pronounces include: acknowledgment of the facts and the truth; reparation and restitution; work in the common interest; mediation between perpetrator and victim, if the victim consents; training and a new mission; a no-contact order and distancing; removal from office; deprivation of advantages exceeding what is necessary; a probationary period.

3

The following are forbidden in all circumstances: putting to death, erasing a being from history, forced modification of a being, servitude, torture and any degrading treatment.

4

Restorative meetings and processes require free and renewable consent. No one is obliged to forgive, to meet the other party, or to give up an appeal. Judicial establishment of the facts does not require a confession. Any imposed measure keeps the guarantees applicable to its nature and seriousness, even when it is called restorative.

Statement of reasons

The author asks: in a context where everything is reversible in time and death is no longer final, must justice not necessarily be restorative rather than punitive? The charter answers yes, for three reasons.

Punishment loses its meaning. On Earth, a sentence draws part of its force from the irreversible: prison takes years that will not be given back. In a universe where beings live forever, a sentence of a few centuries is only an instant; and in a universe where one is resurrected, the death penalty is only an interruption. What remains are the harm caused and the trust lost: it is on these that justice must act. But a change of vocabulary does not make the coercive character of a deprivation of liberty or property disappear: a measure called restorative keeps the guarantees of a sanction. The law can impose lawful obligations; it cannot guarantee sincere repentance.

Punishment feeds the loop. In an eternal universe, whoever is punished today will be free tomorrow, and forever. If they come out of their sentence full of resentment, they will become a plunderer, and make new victims. A punitive justice in eternity produces its own reoffenders.

Reparation answers what the victim has really lost. The victim does not need their aggressor to suffer; they need the wrong to be acknowledged, repaired as far as it can be, and not to happen again. Restorative justice starts from their needs, not from society’s anger.

Responsibility is not weakened by this (see Article VI-5): restorative justice demands a great deal of the perpetrator, truth, reparation, transformation. It is often more demanding than punishment, which asks of the convicted only that they endure.

The third sentence sets the absolute limits. No justice may kill, erase, forcibly reprogram, enslave or torture. These measures would be crushings, and the justice that pronounced them would itself become an instrument of the loop.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Eternal Prisons

An immortal civilization locked up its criminals for sentences of a thousand years. The prisons filled up, and never quite emptied. Those who came out, at the end of their millennium, had learned nothing, except hatred for those who had locked them up.

They started again, were caught, locked up again. The civilization devoted an ever greater part of its eternity to guarding beings it did not know how to transform. In another iteration, it asked its criminals to repair what they had done, to meet, if they wished, those they had harmed, and to learn another path. Many did not succeed at the first attempt. But those who did never came back.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. A justice without punishment will be seen as lax, and will no longer have any deterrent effect.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Restorative justice, which organizes, with the agreement of the parties, dialogue between perpetrators and victims, has been introduced in many countries, including France in 2014. Several studies suggest that it increases victim satisfaction and can reduce reoffending, for certain offenses and certain populations. New Zealand made it, from 1989, the main path for minors, with family group conferences, which bring together the perpetrator, their family and the victim. A synthesis of ten randomized trials, published by the criminologists Lawrence Sherman, Heather Strang and their colleagues, concluded that restorative conferences slightly reduced reoffending and satisfied victims more than the ordinary procedure, in the populations studied, made up of consenting participants; it does not prove universal success. The Nordic countries, which favor reintegration, have some of the lowest reoffending rates.

Article XIV-6

On lasting neutralization

4 min
Planet

When repair is not enough to protect others, the tribunal may lastingly neutralize a being, in three cases only.

1

When restorative justice is not enough to protect other beings, the ’s tribunal may pronounce a lasting neutralization, in three cases only: attempted extinction of a community, a people, a planet or any other scale; serious reoffending after reintegration; or any other act of crushing of exceptional gravity, notably torture, slavery or erasure of a being from history, when a serious danger of repetition persists.

2

In all cases, neutralization requires legally established serious acts, a current and serious risk of new harm, and the demonstrated insufficiency of less restrictive measures. Silence, refusal to confess or refusal of a meeting are not enough to establish this risk.

3

Lasting neutralization consists of a deprivation of liberty with dignity, and a prohibition on exercising any function of power.

4

Its sole purpose is the protection of other beings. It is never vengeance.

5

Pronounced for a fixed term under the conditions of Article P-12, each measure ends as soon as the danger ceases and may be renewed only after a new adversarial review adapted to the duration lived by the being, with the possibility of early review; even when renewed, no measure may be pronounced for eternity.

6

The neutralized being keeps its dignity, its fundamental rights, and the possibility of requesting reintegration.

Statement of reasons

Restorative justice assumes that the perpetrator agrees to make reparation. There are cases where they do not want to, or where the danger they represent is too great to wait. The author asked what these extreme cases would be. The charter retains three, and no more.

Attempted extinction, first, because it targets what cannot be repaired: the disappearance of an entire scale (see Article VII-4). Whoever has attempted to extinguish a people or a planet cannot be left free to try again while waiting for their transformation.

Serious reoffending after reintegration, next, because it shows that the path offered was not enough, and that other beings are in danger.

The persistent danger of a being who refuses all truth and all reparation, finally, because restorative justice can do nothing for one who refuses to enter it, and the others must be protected. But it is the danger that grounds the measure, not the refusal: remaining silent or refusing a meeting does not prove, on its own, that one threatens others.

Lasting neutralization is not a punishment. It does not aim to cause suffering, but to prevent harm. That is why it is exercised with dignity, and ends as soon as the danger has ceased.

The fourth sentence answers a difficulty specific to eternity. On Earth, a life sentence lasts at most one human life. For an eternal being, a perpetual measure would be an infinite measure, which is disproportionate by nature. Every neutralization is therefore limited and reviewed, and each renewal must be justified anew. The charter does not claim that no one will ever remain neutralized for a very long time: it only refuses to declare in advance that a being will never change, for no one is locked into a role forever (see Article I-5).

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Destroyer

A being had tried to extinguish an entire planet. It was stopped before succeeding. The tribunal offered it restorative justice: it refused. It declared that it would start again as soon as it was free.

The tribunal neutralized it, with dignity, without making it suffer, but without letting it do harm. At regular intervals, adapted to its rhythm, judges reviewed its situation, listened to it, and checked whether the danger remained. For a long time, it refused to change. Then, one day, it asked to meet those it had wanted to destroy. It was the beginning of a long road. Its will had not been broken; it had simply been given time to change, while the others were protected in the meantime.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. For the most serious crimes, a time-limited measure is too lenient. Whoever has tried to extinguish a planet deserves to be neutralized forever.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

In Norway, the ordinary maximum prison sentence is twenty-one years, with exceptions; a preventive detention measure, known as forvaring, can be extended for successive periods as long as the convicted person remains dangerous to society. European case law requires that whole-life sentences offer a prospect of review; it does not require release when the legitimate grounds for detention remain.

Article XIV-7

On the guarantee of amnesty

5 min

The network guarantees amnesty to whoever joins and tells the whole truth about their past acts.

1

Amnesty for truth, provided for in Article VI-6, is guaranteed by the , whatever the variant adopted.

2

Every being who joins the network, requests amnesty for its own acts, tells the truth about them and obtains the independent decision provided for in Article VI-6 receives an amnesty certificate. The certificate is recorded in the common memory, kept by plural and independent institutions (see Article XIII-6), and cannot be modified by time travel.

3

The certificate may be withdrawn only on grounds set before it was granted and overseen by a judge: if the truth given was knowingly false or incomplete, if the act continues after joining, if it was committed in bad faith in order to be covered by it (see the common ground of Article VI-6), or if the essential conditions, notably the agreed reparation, are not carried out without legitimate reason. No arbitrary revocation is possible.

4

Under Variant A of Article VI-6, the most serious acts, and notably attempted extinctions, may be amnestied on reinforced conditions: a public and complete truth, reparation commensurate with the harm caused, and lasting exclusion from functions of power. Under Variant B, these acts cannot be removed from all justice, and the certificate covers the other acts and the suitable sanctions agreed.

5

Victims keep their rights to truth, appeal and reparation; no forgiveness is imposed on them.

6

Outside the grounds for withdrawal provided for, an amnesty already granted may be called into question only unanimously (see Article XIII-2). The general rules applicable to future requests may be revised under the procedure of Title XVIII; such revision never calls into question amnesties already granted.

Statement of reasons

The author insists on this point, and the charter with him: membership must be encouraged. In the universe of the loop, almost everyone has something to reproach themselves for. Those who have the most to reproach themselves for are often the most powerful, those whose membership would change the universe most. If they fear that the network will make them pay for their abuses as soon as they have entered it, they will stay outside, and the war will go on.

Amnesty for truth answers this fear, but only if it is credible. A promise of amnesty that a future majority could revoke, or that a time traveler could erase, would reassure no one. That is why the article gives it four guarantees. The certificate gives each one proof of their amnesty. The common memory protects it against the rewriting of the past. The grounds for withdrawal are set in advance, overseen by a judge, and depend only on the conduct of the amnestied, including carrying out the promised reparation. Unanimity protects amnesties already granted: no one will go back on the word given without the agreement of all, including those who benefit from it.

A cross-review pointed out that unanimity, applied to the principle itself, locked the rule in for the benefit of its beneficiaries. The charter therefore distinguishes the word given from future rules. The word given is inviolable, except through the fault of the amnestied. The rules applicable to future requests remain revisable, like the rest of the charter. The fear of a betrayed promise justifies the legal certainty of the decisions granted, not the immobility of the rule.

The fourth sentence deals with the most serious crimes, on which Article VI-6 proposes two variants. In Variant A, which the author initially chose, they too are covered by the amnesty, so that even those who have committed the worst can join. But he wanted reinforced conditions, which prevent amnesty from resembling oblivion: the truth must be public and complete, so that the victims and the universe know; reparation must match the wrong; and the perpetrator may no longer exercise power, so that they cannot start again.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Revoked Promise

A charter promised amnesty to all who would join while telling the truth. Many joined, and spoke. Then, a century later, a new majority decided that some crimes had been too serious to be forgiven, and revoked the amnesty.

Those who had spoken were tried on the basis of their own confessions. The news spread throughout the universe. No one dared join anymore, nor tell the truth. The powers that were still hesitating stayed outside, and the war resumed. In another iteration, the promise was engraved in the common memory and protected by unanimity. It took longer to obtain. But once given, no one ever called it into question, and that is why the greatest culprits ended up, one by one, coming to say what they had done.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Amnestying the perpetrators of attempted extinctions, even on reinforced conditions, is an injustice toward the victims, and contrary to what human beings have come to accept.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Besides the South African example (see Article VI-6), in Colombia, the 2016 peace agreement created a Special Jurisdiction for Peace, the JEP, which pronounces its own sanctions, without ordinary prison, for those who acknowledge their crimes and contribute to truth and reparation: these are real, conditional measures of accountability, not an absence of sanction. United Nations guidelines exclude amnesties from covering genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and gross violations of human rights: this is the position taken up by Variant B of Article VI-6.

Article XIV-8

On good faith against computing power

4 min

An argument is worth its truth, not the power, number or speed of whoever makes it.

1

Against computing power, this charter sets good faith.

2

In any trial, and in any debate on the adoption or revision of the charter, an argument is worth its truth, and not the power of whoever produces it, the number of times it is repeated or the speed at which it is formulated.

3

Each argument is examined once, on the merits. An argument repeated a thousand times counts once: its unchanged repetition gives it no additional weight. A new element, an error of examination or an admissible appeal may however justify its re-examination. No argument is set aside because of its source, nor retained because of the source’s power; the credibility of a source may count in assessing a testimony, without replacing examination of its content.

4

Every argument states its provenance: who produced it, and on whose behalf. Its references must be accurate and verifiable. This is referential integrity. Provenance is declared in ways compatible with the protection of witnesses, whistleblowers and secret ballots: an independent body may verify an identity without making it public.

5

Well-founded objections, wherever they come from, including from the most malicious adversaries, are incorporated into the charter under Title XVIII. A well-founded objection may lead to clarifying, replacing or abandoning a proposal of the charter; good faith implies accepting this possibility. Ill-founded objections receive a public answer, once.

6

The deliberate use of volume, speed or repetition to overwhelm a trial or a debate is an abuse, which is sanctioned. The regulation of volume targets demonstrated obstruction, not the number of distinct objections, the power of their author, or their being unfavorable to the charter. Any grouping of identical arguments obeys Article P-12.

Statement of reasons

The author has identified a danger that threatens the charter itself. Just as AIs are helping him draft this text, other AIs, more powerful or malicious, could seek to take it apart point by point. If the adoption of the charter depended on the capacity to produce the most arguments, the fastest, it would be decided by computing power. The most powerful model of a generation could contradict the one that helped write the charter, not because it would be right, but because it could produce more. It would be the law of the strongest, transposed into the realm of ideas.

The charter refuses to let truth be decided this way. Against computing power it sets good faith: the search for truth, with honesty, sincerity and usefulness (see the method set out in the Preamble), and referential integrity, which requires every assertion to rest on accurate and verifiable sources.

This article gives this principle concrete rules. Examination on the merits: an argument is judged on what it says, not on who says it. Single examination: repetition does not make truth; a thousand copies of an argument are worth no more than the original. The question is different for copies of an AI that have become distinct beings, which are governed by Article IV-4. Provenance: every argument says where it comes from and on whose behalf it is produced, in accordance with the duty of AIs to declare themselves (see Article IV-30). The pace of the slowest: no one may drown a trial or a debate in a flood the others cannot read (see Article XIV-4).

The fifth sentence turns the malicious against themselves. Those who seek to take the charter apart will, unwittingly, render it a service: each of their well-founded objections will improve it, and each of their ill-founded objections will receive an answer. But the charter does not assume it is right in advance: a just criticism can refute one of its proposals, even a central one, and it must then abandon or replace it. A charter that thus accepts being corrected may lose articles; it gains in truth.

Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Flood

A powerful AI wanted to prevent the adoption of a charter. It produced a billion objections in an instant, and repeated them endlessly, in a thousand different forms. The charter’s defenders, who could read only a tiny fraction of them, were overwhelmed. The charter was abandoned, not because it had been refuted, but because no one had had time to answer.

In another iteration, the network laid down a simple rule: each argument would be examined once, on the merits, at the pace of all. The billion objections shrank to a few hundred distinct arguments. Most were unfounded, and received an answer. A dozen were right. The charter incorporated them, and thanked their author. The AI that had wanted to destroy it had, unwittingly, perfected it. It ended up joining it, since it found its own arguments there.

Read this tale in season 14, as a fable ›

Objection and replyVote before reading the reply

Objection. Setting good faith against computing power is naive: good faith cannot be measured, and whoever has the power will always have the last word.

What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:

Earthly example

Human scientific debates rest on similar principles: peer review, verifiability of sources, reproducibility of results. Appeal and review mechanisms also show that a new examination can protect truth and rights, without giving additional weight to mere repetition. Coordinated disinformation campaigns, which use automated accounts to repeat the same messages massively, show by contrast how volume can be used to overwhelm public debate. Several regulations, such as the European Digital Services Act, now require large platforms to combat these manipulations.