Article XIV-1
On the mesh of justice
Every scale and every pole first judges what concerns it; the network’s tribunal steps in only as a complement.
The ’s justice rests on a principle of complementarity: each scale and each pole first judges what concerns it. The network’s tribunal intervenes only in the cases provided for in this article, or when a competent justice is unable or unwilling to judge.
The mixed character of the parties is not enough, on its own, to remove a dispute from the competent local jurisdiction. Jurisdiction is divided as follows:
| What is judged | Competent jurisdiction |
|---|---|
| A case internal to a city, a region, a nation or a planet | The justice of that scale, according to its own laws, in compliance with the charter |
| A dispute between beings of the same pole | The justice of that pole, under the conditions of Article XIV-3 |
| A dispute between beings of different poles | The competent local jurisdiction, with the guarantees of Article XIV-3; the network’s tribunal, in mixed formation, when the cross-border nature of the case, its seriousness, a conflict of jurisdiction or the lack of local guarantees justifies it |
| A breach of the fundamental principles: crushing, extinction, torture, slavery, servitude, cannibalism, erasure of a being from history | The network’s tribunal, wherever it occurred |
| An act committed by means of time travel | The network’s tribunal (see Article VI-4) |
| An appeal for bias or denial of justice, at any scale | The network’s tribunal |
Statement of reasons
The author raised the question of the mesh: what falls to a scale, to a pole, to all the poles? The charter answers with the principle of complementarity, which applies the network’s subsidiarity to justice (see Article XIII-4). A city knows its inhabitants better than the universe does; a pole understands its own nature better than the other two. It is therefore right that each should first judge what concerns it.
But three kinds of cases go beyond any scale and any pole. Disputes between poles, first, because no pole can be judge in its own cause against another. Breaches of the fundamental principles, next, because they threaten the harmony of all, and the pole or scale that commits them is rarely ready to judge itself. Acts committed across time, finally, because only a justice distributed across time can reach them.
The appeal for bias or denial of justice guarantees that no scale can protect its members by refusing to judge them, nor crush a being by judging it badly.
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Distant Tribunal
A civilization entrusted all its justice to a single tribunal, sitting at the center of the universe. The slightest dispute between neighbors, the slightest village quarrel, had to be brought before it. The tribunal was learned and impartial, but it was far away, slow, and knew nothing of the worlds it judged.
Beings stopped bringing their disputes to it. They took justice into their own hands, and vengeance replaced law. In another iteration, each world judged its own cases, and the universal tribunal heard only the crimes that went beyond all worlds. It was less busy, but much more respected.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. Letting each scale judge according to its own laws will produce very unequal justice from one world to another.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. It is inevitable, and it is also respect for the diversity of worlds. But inequality has limits: each justice must respect the charter, and any being can refer a case to the network’s tribunal if it is the victim of a biased judgment or a denial of justice. Absolute uniformity would be more equal, but it would also be more distant and less understood.
Earthly example
The 1998 Rome Statute, which created the International Criminal Court, rests on this principle of complementarity: the Court intervenes only when national courts are unable or unwilling to judge. The Court therefore does not replace all national justice. After the 1994 genocide, Rwanda combined international, national and community justice, with the gacaca village courts, to try hundreds of thousands of cases.