Article V-1
On sovereignty
Every planet and every civilization is sovereign: it sets its own laws, while respecting the rights of all.
Every planet and every civilization is sovereign. It sets its own laws, chooses its institutions and conducts its internal affairs.
Sovereignty depends neither on age, nor on power, nor on level of consciousness.
It is exercised with respect for the fundamental rights of all beings who live on the planet or within the civilization.
Statement of reasons
Sovereignty is the collective form of free will (see Article I-5). A civilization that cannot set its own laws is no longer free, even if it is protected and prosperous. The second sentence applies equality of dignity to civilizations: a young planet is as sovereign as the First Civilization.
The third sentence sets the limit. Sovereignty belongs to a civilization to protect the freedom of its beings, not to crush them. It prepares Article V-6, which settles the case of a civilization that oppresses its own.
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Small Laws
An ancient civilization judged that the laws of a young planet were clumsy. It offered its own, more refined, tested over millennia. The planet adopted them, out of respect and out of fear.
The ancient laws were excellent, but they had been written for other beings, other bodies, other needs. On the young planet, they produced injustices no one understood, since no one there had written them. The planet lost the ability to correct its own mistakes. It had received good laws, and lost the right to make them.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. A young civilization risks giving itself bad laws. Letting it do so is negligence.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. A civilization that makes mistakes can learn; a civilization forbidden to make mistakes cannot. The network can advise, share its knowledge (see Article V-5) and protect threatened beings (see Article V-6). It cannot legislate in its place.
Earthly example
Human international law rests on the sovereign equality of states and the right of peoples to self-determination, proclaimed by the Charter of the United Nations. It also increasingly recognizes that this sovereignty has limits when it is used to commit crimes against populations.