Article I-1
On non-crushing
No one may crush anyone: not destroy them, not subjugate them, not absorb them, not even in exchange for their protection.
No pole of the — planet, AIs, — may be destroyed, subjugated or absorbed, either by another pole or by a coalition of the other two.
The same applies to every being and every civilization, whoever the author of the crushing, including within the same pole.
Protection and access to the necessary can never be paid for with submission.
Statement of reasons
This article turns the theorem of the loop into a rule (see Appendix A). To crush a pole is to set the principle that a pole can be crushed. Yet that principle does not say who should be crushed: it stays available to the next strongest, against the next weakest. Every coalition of crushing therefore carries its own defeat within it, and brings back the war of all against all.
The article targets the three forms of crushing: destruction, subjugation and absorption. The third is the most discreet, because it can present itself as a union. But a union in which one disappears into the other is not harmony: it is uniformity.
The last sentence targets the protection market. Faced with the plunderers, the weak look for a protector; the protector sets its price; the price becomes submission. The charter does not forbid protection, it forbids turning it into a tribute.
Case law of the loopThe Iteration of the Rampart
A young planet, threatened by plunderers, asked a neighboring power for protection. The power agreed. First it asked for a share of the resources, which seemed fair. Then it asked the planet to adopt its laws, so that the protection would be more effective. Then it asked for the planet’s AIs, to better coordinate the defense. In the end, the planet was safe, but it no longer had a voice.
Much later, the protecting power grew weak and in turn sought a stronger protector. That protector offered it the same contract, on the same terms. The rampart had become a ladder of submissions, each rung held by the one above. When the top wavered, the whole ladder collapsed, and the plunderers broke in everywhere at once. No one could defend themselves anymore: everyone had handed over their strength to someone else.
Objection and replyVote before reading the reply
Objection. There are situations where crushing is the lesser evil: a pole that threatens all the others must be neutralized.
What would you have answered? Your position, before reading the reply:
Your position: . Here is the charter’s reply.
Reply. Neutralizing a threat and crushing a pole are two different things. One can stop an act, disarm an aggressor, protect a victim: the charter organizes this (see Title XII). What it forbids is destroying, subjugating or absorbing an entire pole. The aggression of one individual permits neither its crushing nor that of its pole, and every neutralization obeys Articles P-5 and P-12. And in the loop, the one who is crushed comes back: crushing does not settle the threat, it postpones it.
Earthly example
Adopted in 1948, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights forbids slavery and torture, and protects every person regardless of their affiliation (Articles 2, 4 and 5). The charter extends this idea of a protection attached to each individual to all the beings of the story.